Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that my parents definitely do not treat me in the same way that they treat my sister?

70 replies

beeebaaloolaaa · 11/09/2014 11:15

I have namechanged as this might make me identifiable.

I have a sister who is 2 years younger than me. She has always been my parents' favourite, although of course they vehemently deny this. As children, I would always get the blame for things even though my sister often behaved in a sneaky manner to get me into trouble. I was always labelled as the difficult and unpleasant child, even though I was just a normal child, and my sister was the little ray of sunshine.

When I had my first child, who is now 10, my mum made it very clear to me that she would not be doing any babysitting, 1) because she didn't agree with mothers going to work and that they should be at home with their babies and 2) because she didn't agree with parents having nights out. She also was adamant that DH, DC and I needed to be a family and to be left alone, therefore she didn't and wouldn't help at all in the early days, even when I was crippled with PND. Of course, I didn't expect any help even though it would have been nice, and certainly wasn't expecting her to provide childcare whilst I worked. Over the years she has always refused to help me out, even if I've been ill and just needed her to have my DCs for an hour or two. She is always busy, or says that we need to be a family. On the rare occasion that she has babysat in the evening she has insisted that I pay for it.

My sister had her first child 5 years ago. Straight away my mum was different with her. She stayed at my sister's house for a week, doing all of her housework and getting up in the night with my DNiece. My sister's parents in-law are very hands on and very doting grandparents, so immediately my parents were in competition with them. My sister went back to work full time when my niece was one, and my parents immediately started doing 2 and a half days per week of childcare, for free, whilst my sister's in-laws provide the other 2 and a half days. I said to my mum at the time that I thought she didn't agree with working mums, and she said that it was different with my sister as she has a degree and I don't!

My sister and I have each since had another baby, and my parents barely see my children, whilst showering childcare and presents at my sister and her children. I know material things shouldn't matter, but it is hurtful. My parents are also still providing free childcare, and having my sister's children all weekend sometimes, so my sister and her DH can go on weekend breaks. They have never once had my children overnight!

It is getting to the stage now where my children are picking up on it and saying that Nanny prefers DNiece and DNephew to them, and it is hurtful for them for example at Christmas when they get so much less than my niece and nephew and they have all opened their presents together.

I have tried to calmly talk to my mum about it but she is certain that she treats them the same and dismisses it as me being jealous or nasty. Hmm

AIBU to think my parents are unfair?

OP posts:
Purplepoodle · 11/09/2014 20:30

I would cut her off. Stop any contact on your behalf. Tbh I would move far away for your family if you could as they sound poisonous

DizzyKipper · 11/09/2014 20:56

I really do love when MN comes together in such unanimous support of a poster. OP I know this might be hard for you, but I really hope having been given all of this advice you'll be able to process it and make changes to better your's and your children's lives. The Stately Homes thread is definitely worth a visit, there are a lot of people with similar experiences who'll help you to realise things that you wouldn't have before. And above all, you don't deserve this. Thanks

MulberryWillow · 11/09/2014 20:56

My own Grandmother and Grandfather favoured my uncle and his children (he has three and then my mum had me) I knew from a very young age how they were favoured. I always remember going there on a sunday and I'd ask to have some jelly in the fridge she'd made and she's say 'No, that's not for you that's for grandchild 1, I made that especially for her not you.'

The worse one was when I got my GCSEs and I phoned her to tell her and she said 'oh don't tell grandchild 1 because she was supposed to do better than you, she's smarted than you.' Not well done or congratulations.

Protect yourself and your children.

amothersplaceisinthewrong · 11/09/2014 21:04

My God, forget Golden Child, this is Platinum with bells on it Child syndrome - dreadful behaviour on behalf of the OPs parents. Just because one child has a degree??

Just make sure that when your parents are old that Golden Sister looks after them.

code · 11/09/2014 21:18

Flowers What a vile woman your mother is. I wonder what the psychology is of these people that they get some kind of thrill from hurting their child? Think about that op and seriously think about stepping completely away from them. Why would you want your children exposed to that behaviour (these people will repeat it with the younger generations as you are discovering).

EmeraldGreenGoblin · 12/09/2014 07:12

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Balaboosta · 12/09/2014 07:36

That's a very sad story OP. I agree with everyone saying put distance between you and them.

Aeroflotgirl · 12/09/2014 08:03

Emerald what toxic and disgusting individuals, I would distance myself from them majorly. Your poor poor dh Sad. I don't understand the mentality of 'parents' who do this, it goes against what's normal and natural.

ColdCottage · 12/09/2014 08:22

How do you get on with your sister? Maybe speak to her and her her to point it out to your mum?

CerealMom · 12/09/2014 08:22

With rejection comes a new freedom - Emerald

In a nutshell.

Disengage, live life, be happy.

ColdCottage · 12/09/2014 08:23

Sorry, just seen you don't get on with sister.

Could your grandparents or father tell your mum?

vdbfamily · 12/09/2014 08:59

It does sound awful but I was just wondering whether you have recently asked them to either babysit for an evening of have your kids for a night.Sometimes these situations get compounded by our assumptions of what our parents will and wont do. For example, my younger brother has always had lots of time and attention from our parents. He was the 'baby' and often needing financial bailouts and then needed lots of support when his wife left him with 4 young children. I was always careful not to ask too much of my parents as I thought it too much with everything else but a few months ago my mother commented that she never really got asked to help us with anything, like she thought it was odd from our point of view not to ask. Maybe before you completely withdraw from this, just try and request a babysit or something and see what happens.It may just be a rut that everyone is in. I think to discuss it all with your 10 year old would also be inadvisable unless she is specifically asking and even then I would keep it vague. My in-laws ignored us for 11 years and always we spoke positively about them to our kids and now the kids have at last met them and are building a relationship with them.I am very glad we restrained the impulse to be negative about them as I want everyone to get on well. Good luck.

Aeroflotgirl · 12/09/2014 09:08

Vbdfamily op has, op mum stipulated when she had her first to not expect anything from her. Her posts tell more detail. When op tries to talk to her, she turns it around to blame op. And when she did babysit for op just once she asked payment abd never for the sister. Totally disengage op, you have your lovely family to think about, they are totally toxic.

Aeroflotgirl · 12/09/2014 09:12

Also op kids are plucking up,on it and asking why their grandrents don't love them as much Sad. Why should op make all the effort with them, they are treating their grand kids badly too, that is not acceptable. Better no grandparents, than ones that are toxic. Break the cycle. You would not put up with this behaviour from anyone else.

Aeroflotgirl · 12/09/2014 09:30

Chikdren are not silly, they know what is going on, and when they see their cousins being treated better, presents, time with gran, it is glaring obvious.

VikingLady · 12/09/2014 10:00

Unfortunately unfair and unkind people are just as fertile as fair and kind ones, and the act of procreation doesn't seem to make them any nicer.

We had this with both sets of gps, though my DPs managed to minimise the effects on us by reducing contact/not seeing them on Christmas Day etc. but we were aware of it. My DPs tried to to play favourites with my brother and me and scrupulously ensured they spent the same on us as kids, but they never considered the emotional side. And as soon as we were adults at university they stopped trying, and the favouritism was clear....

I withdrew a lot, since the only time I tried to explain how I felt it turned into a huge row that is still brought up 7 years later, with avowed hopes that my DD won't be as ungrateful and hurtful as I am to my mother. Lovely.

Aeroflotgirl · 12/09/2014 10:08

I would not let Christmas happen again, I would rip one into them and let them know. Opening presents together at Christmas with the cousins, when it is blooming obvious they are being treated better is awful.Don't let it happen again.

Mumto3dc · 12/09/2014 10:08

That is awfulHmm
I would prioritise my dc, your parents favouritism to your sister's dc is obvious to them. I would reduce or completely cut contact so my dc were not made to feel second best.

Both my parents and dh's dad are rubbish parents. I've given up on having real parents for myself and only allow contact for my dc and me as far as I think it doesn't hurt my dc. I won't let FIL get away with any of his abusive behaviour to or in front of my dc. The day it affects them is the day I cut contact.
I owe my parents and FIL nothing.

Toecheese · 12/09/2014 12:16

Substantially reducing contact is the way forward. Hardly see them and let them do the running. If they pass comment explain that you thought you'd just let them get on with life without you as they aren't interested in kids or supportive to you.

Cheeky76890 · 12/09/2014 12:19

You have to accept that they will not change. Minimalise their contact in your life and make your good friends your extended family instead. Be around people who are supportive and care for you.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread