Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Need a bit of advice on how to resolve a family issue

75 replies

Jill1978 · 02/02/2014 08:11

Before I start, I'll apologise for what is likely to be a long(ish) post.

My hubby's brother and his wife-to-be are getting married in late April. They've decided to get married in a really nice (but expensive) resort in Southern California and in Autumn sent out invites to friends and family.

To set the scene, they're both in their late 20's, have good jobs, with good salaries, no kids and a small flat (with a small mortgage). By comparison, my Hubby and I have 2 pre-school kids, a decent mortgage and I only work part time. We're by no means struggling but we're not rolling in it...

When the invites came out we spent a couple of weeks most evenings searching online to see how we could make the trip work financially and practically with a young family. The upshot of our searching was that to take 4 of us nearly 1/3 of the way around the world and stay for the wedding was costing ~£7,000, involved a 16 hour flight (with 1 connection) and when we got there an 8 hour time difference. We just can't afford to do it and really don't want to put the kids though it either. After a lot of thought we said that we wouldn't be going, We didn't mention the cost because we didn't want to make them feel in any way guilty about deciding to go abroad - it's their wedding afterall, and really expected them to understand - how wrong could we be....

The wife-to-be went ballistic, totally spat the dummy, said we were ruining her big day and it if was her sister who had let them down she would never ever talk to her again! At Christmas where we all gather at my mother-in-law's she didn't say a word to either of us all day and was really short and cold with the kids which upset me. Hubby's brother pulled her aside and had a word, but it's become apparent over the last 3 months that he's very much under the thumb and she rules the roost. To add insult to injury, her father waded into the argument and even suggested that we get a personal loan from the bank to cover it since "it's a once in a lifetime event and bank rates are low at the moment".

Its been quiet over the last month and both my hubby and I were beginning to think that her behaviour (which seemed quite out of character) was maybe as a result of wedding stress etc and that the worst was over. However, I've now since discovered that I've not been invited to the hen night but unbelievably, we've been issued with a wedding gift list from John Lewis, where the cheapest item is £95! Seems we've fallen out of favour but not enough that we can't buy them a gift!

Really not sure what to do, obviously don't want to stoke the fires and cause more friction but this rift is really dividing the family. Hubby's parents are now siding with us and giving her the cold shoulder and my poor brother-in-law's caught up in the middle which I think is having an effect on his relationship with my hubby which up until this nonsense was really close......

Any ideas? It's really getting under my skin and upsetting my hubby and I, finding that it's always on my mind and has started keeping me awake at night.

OP posts:
FunkyBoldRibena · 02/02/2014 08:52

Your husband needs to tell his brother that £7k is outrageous to spend on his wedding, as it could pay for about 3 years of holidays for your family.

And you are to say nothing. Nada. Apart from 'we will be here BIL when you finally see sense and ditch the witch'.

curiousgeorgie · 02/02/2014 08:54

This exact situation happened to my DH and me with his brother and soon to be wife.

They were getting married abroad, we absolutely couldn't afford it for various reasons and I was due to have a C Section a few weeks before the wedding.

Most of the family sided with them. We tried to compromise and left my weeks old baby with my mum (sob sob!) and went to the wedding to try and make peace (as by this time they hadn't spoken to us for about 4 months and had made my pregnancy hell.) But we only went for one night to keep costs to a minimum.. (One of the reasons it was so pricey is because my DH is a contractor, and of he doesn't work, he doesn't get paid, and they had expected us to go for a week.)

They used every opportunity to make us feel like shit. My DH ( who was demoted from best man) was joked about in the speech, they made us sit at the back of the church, about six rows behind where people ended! They sat us on a table with a few sets of her cousins who completely refused to speak to us and served us different food than everyone else.

I'd say, don't go.

It's now been almost a year since they spoke to us / us to them.

Goldmandra · 02/02/2014 08:55

Send the cheapest gift (quickly before someone else chooses it) with a note saying you're sorry you won't be there but are looking forward to seeing the photos.

Then you've done everything you can to keep the relationship intact. If it's thrown back in your face you can shrug and move on.

rookiemater · 02/02/2014 08:55

That's awful curiousgeorgie, what horrible people.

Jill - personally I'd get them something from their wedding list, gives them one less thing to grouse about and shows that you are trying to play ball.

kitbit · 02/02/2014 08:58

My whole wedding cost half that!
No way would I spend £7k on something that wasn't for me or my family, we'd get no lasting benefit from and that would put us financially in a difficult position. Neither would I expect my friends and family to do the same.

Se is unreasonable, bridezilla and a loon.

londonrach · 02/02/2014 08:58

Just buy something you can afford, a nice card and put something in the card along the lines 'we look forward to seeing the wedding photos and video on your return'. Maybe you could do a special evening with special food, wedding clothes and show the photos.

I would also be there for your bil in case he needs you. The way its going i question why they getting married but whatever you do dont mention that to anyone!!!!!

kitbit · 02/02/2014 08:59

...and for a gift buy them a goat.

sparklyma · 02/02/2014 09:02

Yanbu to not go. She sounds loopy. However is it really going to cost 7k? I flew to America last year and it cost £700. I paid around £600 for accomodation for a week. The room would have fitted 4 people. I know different prices for different cities and all that but if mine was £1300 why such a HUGE difference? 4x700 flights =2800+ accomodation at 600 = 3400.

SlightlyDampWellies · 02/02/2014 09:04

Good on your DH for going ballistic.

I think this is a classic 'tell them fuck them' situation.

marmitecat · 02/02/2014 09:11

Get them something fron the gift list, send them a card with a lovely message wishing them all the best and breathe a sigh of relief that you're spending much less than 7k. Tbh it often costs more than £100 to attend a wedding in the UK so I wouldn't deliberately go for something off list unless you really can't afford £100. It kjust gives them something else to complain about. At least if you appear to go along willingly with everything but the wedding you have the moral high ground.

Blondieminx · 02/02/2014 09:13

Good on your DH! Grin

Maintain a dignified silence on the issue, do not engage at all or she will try further crap. I cannot believe she got the dad to suggest a loan Shock

Send a card with a JL voucher perhaps - but otherwise sit back and watch as she makes it evident to everyone as to what a nasty grabby bitch she is!

bearleftmonkeyright · 02/02/2014 09:15

I am so shocked by this post and also curiousgeorgies. Wtaf! Are there really people in this world that act like this? Yanbu, it is all me me me, look Daddy, I'm a fairy princess. It's got sod all to do with marriage. I am sure its like Simon Callow said in Four weddings and a funeral. People like this get married in this way so they will have something to talk about for the rest of their lives.

Morgause · 02/02/2014 09:17

Love self absorbed, vacuous and frivolous.

I shall try to remember that one.

wowfudge · 02/02/2014 09:19

I think things are well past the point of seeing whether you can travel to the wedding more cheaply. That is still a huge amount of money.

Given the behaviour of the happy couple, sod 'em and stick to your guns.

JamNan · 02/02/2014 09:20

Get her a John Lewis voucher and tell her to buy her own bloody present. What an unpleasant woman cheeky bitch.

PlasmaBall · 02/02/2014 09:22

She's being ridiculous but you know that.

Dh needs to have a proper talk with his brother to make sure he at least understands your position.

I don't actually think its that off not to invite future sil to the hen night; especially if youre not really friends so i would ignore that "slight" and see it as a lucky escape.

Work out what you would have spent on attending a normal wedding and buy them a really lovely present from the list with that.

quietlysuggests · 02/02/2014 09:23

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

bearleftmonkeyright · 02/02/2014 09:26

Quietly has made a good suggestion.

Gladvent · 02/02/2014 09:28

My brother got married abroad in expensive place - we didn't go - he totally understood - no one fell out.

Tell your SIL to be that that ^^ is how it works in Reality Land.

Iwannalaylikethisforever · 02/02/2014 09:30

I would not spend £7k to see anyone get married. They are taking the piss.
You should just tell me it's too expensive.

Iwannalaylikethisforever · 02/02/2014 09:31

I mean them. Tell them it's too expensive.
They are acting like spoilt shits.

FrontForward · 02/02/2014 09:35

Your SIL is unreasonable. Ignore and live your own life. You will never win with her so don't bother trying

Electryone · 02/02/2014 09:36

Of course its a huge thing go miss your brothers wedding, which is the risk people take when getting married abroad! Its a hell of a ling way to go for only a few days and its still a lot of money oyt of a family budget. Really don't understand how people can be so horrible, instead of just accepting not everyone will be able to afford it.

Pigsmummy · 02/02/2014 09:36

Send DH on his own, then he will be able to maintain a decent relationship with his brother and you are not £7k out of pocket.

Pigsmummy · 02/02/2014 09:38

Sparklyma I agree with you, £7k for the US sounds unlikely,