Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect a thank you for a wedding gift

55 replies

Bingersandtoes · 21/10/2013 12:38

DH and I have been to 8 weddings over the past 2 years. Each time we have bought a present off the list / donated cash as requested by a bloody stupid poem

We have received 2 thank you notes.

AIBU in being surprised by the fact that 75% of our aquitances (the 2 thank yous came from people I'd class as friends) are rude and ungrateful???

Please tell me it is still 'normal' and expected to write a thank you note??

OP posts:
notadoctor · 21/10/2013 13:31

I'm always pleasantly surprised to get a thank you card. I give presents - and attend the weddings - to celebrate the happiness of people I love and care about and wish them well for the future. Personally, I don't feel like I need any thanks for that - it's a pleasure.

Beccagain · 21/10/2013 13:35

Oh lighten up Gingingin

I was making the point a tad forcibly I agree, but really, the number of threads/posts on here where weddings are causing everybody concerned no end of heartache, must surely indicate that it's not all flowers that bloom in the spring tra la la; not nowadays anyway when things haver become so competitive/stylised/it's all got to be perfect and cost a fortune (I think someone made this very point about two posts in.

The public declaration of joining of two lives/families together, lovely. The hoo-ha that goes with it...not so much.

GinGinGin · 21/10/2013 13:44

Lighten up yourself becca.

DH & I put an awful lot of thought into our wedding - we made sure we had a separate room for the kids & toys for them to play with, presents for our parents etc, talked with all the guests, had the wedding in an easily accessible place, helped to organise accommodation. I would be really annoyed if someone had thought as you did tbh, but maybe that's just me.

HeadsDownThumbsUp · 21/10/2013 13:48

I find it sweet and slightly amusing to receive thank you cards.

They're going the way of calling cards and dance cards. Do you expect them too?

Beccagain · 21/10/2013 13:57

They're going the way of calling cards and dance cards. Do you expect them too?

I think the point has been made (several times) that it is not the card per se, but taking the trouble to say thank you by any up to date medium,. To take your rather patronising point to its logical conclusion Heads would you think it okay for someone to just drag you onto the dance floor, or not to let you know they'd been in touch?

But in any case business cards (the 21 centurt version of calling cards) are as prevalent as ever!

And Gin your own description of your wedding sounds a bit stressy to me. Obviously I don't know, but I wouldn't be remotely surpsrised it at least some of your guests weren't there to make you, rather than themselves, happy. And what's wrong with that?

Love your REALLY smart comeback by the way! Must use it myself sometime!

Bingersandtoes · 21/10/2013 14:02

No, I don't Heads (sounds like fun though!)

But, in all honesty, I do think it's sad not to receive a thank you in any way for a gift (be it verbal, written on card, texted or emailed.) I think surely that is only good manners to do so if someone has taken the time and effort to give you a present, be it for your birthday, wedding or Christmas. My son is only 2 but he helps to make thank you pictures to send to those who give him gifts. I feel this is an important message to teach him. Perhaps, as you suggest, I am old fashioned. So be it.

OP posts:
HeadsDownThumbsUp · 21/10/2013 14:13

What's patronising about saying that I find them sweet and slightly amusing? I like to get them. But I do think they are quite anachronistic and I don't expect them, or feel slighted if I don't get them,

If I gave a child or an adult a present I would expect them to say "thank you" to me when I gave it to them. I think that sending post just to say thank you is quite old fashioned.

There's nothing wrong with being old fashioned. It's nice. But you can't expect everyone else to be old fashioned too.

Beccagain · 21/10/2013 14:15

What's patronising about saying that I find them sweet and slightly amusing

Nothing....I misinterpreted the tone. Mea culpa Grin

MogwaiTheGremlin · 21/10/2013 14:18

YADNBU
I couldn't attend a friend's wedding but sent a nice gift/card and she never once thanked me. People are rude!
Personally I enjoyed writing my thank you cards and remembering my wedding day and the friends who were there to share it.

Famzilla · 21/10/2013 14:20

YANBU.

This whole wedding culture is ridiculous. DH and I got married on Friday, the whole thing cost about £500 and we specifically said no gifts. People brought gifts & cards anyways and I have already hand made and posted the thank you cards. I also printed some of the photos from the day and have bunged a few of the relevant person in the relevant card. It wasn't difficult.

Then again, I was genuinely so thankful and felt so cared about that day I practically wanted to burst.

WaitMonkey · 21/10/2013 14:22

YANBU. I have never not received a thank you note after a wedding although one did arrive about 8 month's after the wedding. I'd worry that the gift had been lost if I didn't receive a thank you.

CoffeeTea103 · 21/10/2013 14:30

Yabu, when you went for the wedding did the couple thank you for coming? That should say it all really. Why do you expect a special thank you?

Justforlaughs · 21/10/2013 14:30

I am Shock that so many people seem to think it is normal, if not exactly acceptable, to NOT say thank you for a gift! I'll admit that I'm not a big fan of writing thank you notes for birthday presents and tend to rely more on a phone call than a written note, but I certainly posted notes to everyone who gave us a wedding gift, and when we had our children. I would accept that emails and text messages are becoming the norm but not to acknowledge at all is plain rude.

enriquetheringbearinglizard · 21/10/2013 15:05

I don't think good manners are old fashioned.
If someone takes the time to bother giving me something, or do something special for me, I take the time to thank them properly, not just a verbal thanks in passing.
We've brought up our DCs to be the same, but I don't know if they'll keep it up as the years go by, particularly not if the people they socialize with don't bother.

cantthinkofagoodone · 21/10/2013 15:15

I've always received a thank you. It's the done thing in our group and recognises the effort your guests have made

Beccagain · 21/10/2013 18:42

Famzilla.....many many congratulations. You sound lovely! Your wedding sounds lovely! Flowers

DontmindifIdo · 21/10/2013 18:54

YANBU - but I've obviously got polite friends/family as I've always had a thank you card/note.

That said, I have a seeking suspicion we didn't thank everyone for gifts from our wedding, I gave dh a list of people who were clearly "his side" and we agreed he'd write those cards. He promised me he had and sent them, but I had far too many stamps left over after all were done and suspect he just texted/emailed some of them...

anon2013 · 21/10/2013 18:56

YABU and YANBU. After our Wedding my FIL and MIL were aghast when we didn't know about thank you cards. We sent them as soon as we could after, maybe it's not as big a tradition as we think?.

PrincessWellington · 21/10/2013 19:38

Yabu - while it is polite to send a thank you in any gift situation I find it very rude to 'expect' anything in return for a gift. Even more rude - when you are reminded you have not written a thank you note.

petitdonkey · 21/10/2013 19:48

I am surprised when people don't send a thank you card - DH and I both wrote quite a lonf message on all of our wedding cards, it wasn't just about the gift but the effort that people made to travel to our wedding and make it special.

I must live in a parallel universe though as I get thank-you cards for everything - every dinner party, sunday lunch, friend's birthday gift etc so I'm always in a panic keeping my correspondence up to date. Bearing in mind we worked out last week that we have only had two whole weekends in this year (fri & sat) that is a lot of thank you cards!! Last year after DD's birthday we got a 'thank you for inviting me to your party' letter (before I'd even sent out her thank you cards) and last week I got a 'thank you for having me over to play' - proper card posted!! Lovely but blimey, I can't keep up!!

Tinlegs · 21/10/2013 20:02

My generation (40s) I received a written thank you for every wedding we went to / sent a gift for. However, recently, showing my age, we have gone as friends of the mother of the bride (3 times, 2 families, mother widowed). In the "less posh" family we got a lovely card with a photo of the bride and groom, a couple of sentences about the day and thanks for the gift. In the "very posh and always a stickler for doing the right thing family" - nothing from either wedding. We sent a gift for one wedding which we could not attend as we were away and sent it 3 weeks after the wedding - some silk from India where we had been on holiday which we had arranged to be woven to a specific colour scheme - nothing.

I actually think not saying thank you is really, really rude. I write to thank people for dinner, for any gifts, for parties, weddings etc and am ensuring my children do the same. Yes, it may be by text, email, Facebook or post (love the post) but it is good manners.

I think even large weddings (and ours was 200 people) it doesn't take long to write a few lines to say thanks for the 100+ presents we had and to thank people for the effort of turning up often at considerable expense. Also, it is usual to send a gift if you can't attend and, in this case, there is not always the option of verbal thanks.

What I really, really, really hate, however, is the grabby table of gifts on display. My worst wedding (actually, no thanks for that one) was when we all had to return the next day to "watch and admire" as the bride opened the gifts. Like a really bad Christmas where you get nothing......the groom's sister kept muttering about how "common" it was! Our gift (in a card) was ignored as well.

Rant over.

HeadsDownThumbsUp · 21/10/2013 20:10

we all had to return the next day to "watch and admire" as the bride opened the gift

That's customary in lots of parts of Europe.

HeadsDownThumbsUp · 21/10/2013 20:11

A thank you card for Sunday lunch? For "having me over to play"?

FFS, it costs 50p for a second class stamp alone. How much are people spending on these bloody cards and postage?

ReindeerBollocks · 21/10/2013 20:16

I sent thank you cards out when I saw people, unfortunately we tend to only do big family gatherings once a year - so that's when some guests received their thank you cards.

Oddly I had wrote them all out a couple of weeks after the wedding - but then DC1 came down extremely ill and going to the post office slipped my mind (then I forgot about them Blush).

I think it's nice to receive a thank you note, but it doesn't make me think less of a couple if I don't receive one.

summerlovingliz · 21/10/2013 20:29

I agree with you completely OP.. It is shocking that some people don't make the effort to send thank you cards.