Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cut and past this anti-competitive parenting post that somone posted on faceache

121 replies

LEMisdisappointed · 12/09/2013 20:06

Written by a Pre-School Teacher – It says it all!
I was on a parenting bulletin board recently and read a post by a mother who was worried that her 4 1/2 year old did not know enough. “What should a 4 year old know?” she asked.

Most of the answers left me not only saddened but pretty soundly annoyed. One mom posted a laundry list of all of the things her son knew. Counting to 100, planets, how to write his first and last name, and on and on. Others chimed in with how much more their children already knew, some who were only three. A few posted URL’s to lists of what each age should know. The fewest yet said that each child develops at his own pace and not to worry.

It bothered me greatly to see these mothers responding to a worried mom by adding to her concern, with lists of all the things their children could do that hers couldn’t. We are such a competitive culture that even our pre-schoolers have become trophies and bragging rights. Childhood shouldn’t be a race.

So here, I offer my list of what a 4 year old should know.
She should know that she is loved wholly and unconditionally, all of the time.
-He should know that he is safe and he should know how to keep himself safe in public, with others, and in varied situations. He should know that he can trust his instincts about people and that he never has to do something that doesn’t feel right, no matter who is asking. -He should know his personal rights and that his family will back them up.
She should know how to laugh, act silly, be goofy and use her imagination. She should know that it is always okay to paint the sky orange and give cats 6 legs.
-He should know his own interests and be encouraged to follow them. If he could care less about learning his numbers, his parents should realize he’ll learn them accidentally soon enough and let him immerse himself instead in rocket ships, drawing, dinosaurs or playing in the mud.
-She should know that the world is magical and that so is she. She should know that she’s wonderful, brilliant, creative, compassionate and marvellous.
-She should know that it’s just as worthy to spend the day outside making daisy chains, mud pies and fairy houses as it is to practice phonics. Scratch that– way more worthy.

But more important, here’s what parents need to know.
-That every child learns to walk, talk, read and do algebra at his own pace and that it will have no bearing on how well he walks, talks, reads or does algebra.
-That the single biggest predictor of high academic achievement and high ACT scores is reading to children. Not flash cards, not workbooks, not fancy preschools, not blinking toys or computers, but mom or dad taking the time every day or night (or both!) to sit and read them wonderful books.
-That being the smartest or most accomplished kid in class has never had any bearing on being the happiest. We are so caught up in trying to give our children “advantages” that we’re giving them lives as multi-tasked and stressful as ours. One of the biggest advantages we can give our children is a simple, carefree childhood.
-That our children deserve to be surrounded by books, nature, art supplies and the freedom to explore them. Most of us could get rid of 90% of our children’s toys and they wouldn’t be missed, but some things are important– building toys like lego and blocks, creative toys like all types of art materials (good stuff), musical instruments (real ones and multicultural ones), dress up clothes and books, books, books. (Incidentally, much of this can be picked up quite cheaply at thrift shops.) They need to have the freedom to explore with these things too– to play with scoops of dried beans in the high chair (supervised, of course), to knead bread and make messes, to use paint and play dough and glitter at the kitchen table while we make supper even though it gets everywhere, to have a spot in the yard where it’s absolutely fine to dig up all the grass and make a mud pit.
-That our children need more of us. We have become so good at saying that we need to take care of ourselves that some of us have used it as an excuse to have the rest of the world take care of our kids. Yes, we all need undisturbed baths, time with friends, sanity breaks and an occasional life outside of parenthood. But we live in a time when parenting magazines recommend trying to commit to 10 minutes a day with each child and scheduling one Saturday a month as family day. That’s not okay!

Our children don’t need Nintendos, computers, after school activities, ballet lessons, play groups and soccer practice nearly as much as they need US. They need fathers who sit and listen to their days, mothers who join in and make crafts with them, parents who take the time to read them stories and act like idiots with them. They need us to take walks with them and not mind the .1 MPH pace of a toddler on a spring night. They deserve to help us make supper even though it takes twice as long and makes it twice as much work. They deserve to know that they’re a priority for us and that we truly love to be with them.

OP posts:
friday16 · 12/09/2013 21:38

Glad to see others noticed the shocking distinction between "real" and "multicultural" instruments. And I'm still puzzling over "types of art materials (good stuff)" - could someone fill me in on what are "bad" art materials that I should avoid?

It's just another boasting list. A different one. But a boasting list. It's essentially "oh, my child runs free and plays all day with sustainable sourced hand-made toys we buy from our local co-operative, but like all you nasty working class oiks with your Nintendos" middle-class one up-manship. For example " to have a spot in the yard where it’s absolutely fine to dig up all the grass and make a mud pit" which is "live in a flat? bad parent" made more touchy-feely.

WorraLiberty · 12/09/2013 21:39

I'd like to see her hand that list to an Ofsted inspector Grin

AmberLeaf · 12/09/2013 21:45

Im working class and my children spent their early years living in flats in inner city London.

I managed to do lots of the things on that list and really can't take offence at any of it.

'Surrounded by nature' go to a park, grow things on your window sill.

No garden to dig a hole in, but I do now and my 16 yr old is obviously making up for the missed opportunity as he has been digging a hole for the last two years!

The sentiment is right on the whole.

SeaSickSal · 12/09/2013 21:51

And ironically it's just another form of competitive parenting really isn't it? 'Look how creative my children are, look how we love our children so much more than other people, look how man BOOKS, and INSTRUMENTS we have, aren't we superior to people who have plastic toys?'

JamieandtheMagicTorch · 12/09/2013 21:55

I agree with it.yes, you can nit pick a few lines of it but I fail to see that much of it is controversial

JamieandtheMagicTorch · 12/09/2013 21:57

It doesn't say that you should not buy nintendos etc. it says that children don't need them as much as they need other things.

RedHelenB · 12/09/2013 21:57

Always American trite crap that gets copied & pasted on FB _ yes YABU!!!!

teatimesthree · 12/09/2013 21:59

Jamie, I guess what is a bit irritating is that it is so insistent that children need your time and patience. Hard to argue with, but they are in short supply for many!

JamieandtheMagicTorch · 12/09/2013 21:59

How very prejudiced

JamieandtheMagicTorch · 12/09/2013 21:59

Xpost.

My last post was to RedHelen

happycrimblechuckie · 12/09/2013 22:12

My DC are 20 and 18 and all they ever talk about when reminiscing with us are the times we have done things not the things we have bought them. That is a fact and it cannot be questioned. Ask any parent of adults and they will say the same. My son loved the play station I made him from a shoe box and told me so only the other day. We did not have a pot to piss in when my DC were small but what we did have was a library and a toy library and we almost lived there on a weekly basis choosing and swapping toys etc we went out every day even in the rain and we got soaked and muddy but they remember EVERY bit of it.

RedHelenB · 12/09/2013 22:13

Appeals to some but not to me so imo it is unreasonable!

Mintyy · 12/09/2013 22:19

I think its horribly overdone but I do very much agree with the thinking behind it.

I dare you to post it in the Primary Education Topic on Mumsnet though! They seem to be mainly nutters over there Grin.

mrsfrumble · 12/09/2013 22:19

Fair points Amberleaf. I guess it doesn't take much to make me feel rubbish about my parenting.

I appreciate the sentiment of the piece for that reason (that the author is trying to reassure parents) but I do think it ends up being a bit prescriptive despite the good intentions.

AmberLeaf · 12/09/2013 22:22

I know what you mean mrsfrumble.

exoticfruits · 12/09/2013 22:23

It does indeed say it all.

intitgrand · 12/09/2013 22:23

patronising shite

DameDeepRedBetty · 12/09/2013 22:38

I do like it a lot more than most FB trite stuff that comes through. And I can see why it might make some of us feel guilty - it is being slightly prescriptive in the assumption that all of us have a (US) backyard (UK) garden for our children to fart-fanny about in, for instance. But the main ethos I do think all of us can agree about - that childhood is the only time that any of us get to be truly carefree, and part of our (ENORMOUS) job description as parents is to do our best to ensure this should be the case.

mumofthemonsters808 · 12/09/2013 22:41

Really like this

ToysRLuv · 12/09/2013 23:19

Sigh.. Competition comes in many forms.

Vagndidit · 12/09/2013 23:32

Nice. It only took a page and a half for someone to blame the Americans for this one.

I think it's a great message, to be honest, as someone who was witness to a gang of unhinged Y1parents tear into the teacher this afternoon for sending home "inappropriately" too easy leveled readers with their obviously Oxbridge-bound snowflakes. The level of tutting was insane.

Elsiequadrille · 12/09/2013 23:38

I'm in agreement with it being bilge! It really is.

SamHamwidge · 13/09/2013 00:06

to use paint and play dough and glitter at the kitchen table while we make supper even though it gets everywhere

Just the thought has me practically running off for the Flash and wipes.

That's what Play and Stay is for, isn't it?

(disclaimer - I am trying to be a bit less anally retentive about mess since I do have a toddler after all but I just...argh...hate it....)

Mumoftwoyoungkids · 13/09/2013 00:19

vagndidit But it is American.

"ACT scores" - American College Testing. (That was my first clue!)

Thrift store, yard, mom, realise, smartest are all also American.

Not that it really matters. It would be just as smug and trite if it was talking about A Levels!

daisychain01 · 13/09/2013 04:18

I definitely agree with making lots and lots of daisy chains

Cheesy and schmultzy it may be, but there are some good messages in there! Thanks for sharing.