Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Toby Young has his own self to blame for his kids not having the childhood he had.

55 replies

MrButtercat · 21/07/2013 08:46

In ref to Daily Fail Toby Young essay on the childhood his kids won't have.

In a nutshell Toby you give them too much screen time and spend too much money on them.Many kids of broke, sensible parents will have the childhood you describe.

My dc are the kids of an software coder if they can get by with an hour of screen time a day and amuse themselves for the rest of the day without needing £££££ sent on them any kid can.

My kids(twin boys 9,9 and dd 8) have been to Legoland once as we simply don't have the money for petrol to drive there let alone the entrance fee- they survive.We took sandwiches as the food you describe is waaaay out of our budget(and foul I'm sure).

They don't stamp their feet for expensive days out or loll about doing nothing during the holidays.Yes we're lucky to live in Devon(in a busy market town with the same traffic risks as everybody else) however my kids amuse themselves on a budget of zero because they have to.They love cubs and their summer will be an extension of that.Fire making in the drive using magnifying glasses,hours of hop scotch,tennis matches over a chalk line,reading,water pistol fights,bike riding up and down their road,local park,pop up tent pretend camping,playing with the mountains of boards games and craft stuff we have etc,etc.

Days out will be the beach with sandwiches,free bike rides,woods,streams and moor rambles.

Yes w're lucky however I reserve my sympathy for the parents of kids stuck in apartment blocks on a zero budget or those that have to work on a low budget not the parents of spoilt middle class kids who have the money and time to take their kids to Kenya.

Buy a lock for your screen gadgets,get library cards (your kids will read more when bored)and stainless steel water bottles so you never need buy expensive plastic bottles of drink again.

You are the organ grinder of your dc's childhood and having an awful lot more cash and facilities than the maj of parents are perfectly well placed to give your kids the childhood they desire.

OP posts:
squoosh · 21/07/2013 14:22

Everything Toby Young has ever said or done or will ever say or do is unreasonable.

YANBU though.

Xihha · 21/07/2013 15:30

The guys an idiot, surely everyone knows the best way to get children to go and play in the garden is to put nice clothes on them and ask them to try not to get too messy, hey presto, they'll make some mud cakes, have a water fight and rip their clothes climbing on something and if you put the clean sheets on the washing line to dry and they'll soon be building camps in the flower beds which are now super muddy from their water fight!

As for it being impossible to take them out without spending vast sums, I find taking a packed lunch and saying no to them occasionally helps!
Some of the best days out I've had with my kids have cost nothing or next to nothing.

cory · 21/07/2013 16:30

Xihha Sun 21-Jul-13 15:30:01
"The guys an idiot, surely everyone knows the best way to get children to go and play in the garden is to put nice clothes on them and ask them to try not to get too messy, hey presto, they'll make some mud cakes, have a water fight and rip their clothes climbing on something and if you put the clean sheets on the washing line to dry and they'll soon be building camps in the flower beds which are now super muddy from their water fight! "

True wisdom. This is where Mumsnet delivers and the Daily Fail does not. Grin

cory · 21/07/2013 16:42

As for teenagers, the beauty of them, surely, is that they can arrange their own picnics, trips to the beach etc?

Dd went to Bournemouth on the train with her friends the other day. If they couldn't have found the money for the train fare, they would have had a picnic locally. Today she is lolling.

She doesn't need an organ grinder at 16.

ubik · 21/07/2013 16:56

Ha ha

I knew there would be a thread about this! I chortled all the way through it - complaining about the cost of water and then the killer line about holiday in Kenya!!!!

That's what we should do everyone -go to Kenya so that our spoilt children don't endlessly demand treats and bottles of water.

I live in a flat, I have a low budget. My kids are currently having a whale of a time in a caravan in Scotland- charging about with cousins, pond dipping, swimming in sea, eating chips.

Sadly I am currently at work paying for it.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page