Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to give up a secure council tenancy..................................

61 replies

SlowlyWakingUp · 27/03/2013 14:32

We were 'given' a 3 bed 2nd floor (no lift) flat a year ago after spending 2 years stuck in temporary housing (a 3 bed house).

We did not want the flat (got massively flamed on here) but were told we would have to take it or we would be evicted from the temporary house. We have 4 DCs, one a toddler and yes I was pregnant BEFORE getting into this position, and this has really been the hardest time of my life as we have no garden for the DCs to play or to dry washing, have to lug kids, bags and stuff up and down 2 flights of stairs etc. It has meant that the mental health issues that I have had caused by the circumstances of us being homeless in the first place, have been exacerbated and prolonged.

We had to wait a year for the tenancy to become secure and now we can request a transfer. Only I have been told that we will have to wait 3/4 years for a house.

We can try to swop but what family would realistically move from a house to a grotty 2nd floor flat?

I really can't face the thought of another summer stuck inside (there seems to be a constant police presence here and the DCs have been called 'cunts' etc on the few times they went out to play alone) and the neighbours swear up to the ceiling about the noise the DCs make, nothing excessive just normal kids noise but also have noisy parties and massive rows in the street so I am constantly on alert and trying to keep the DCs quiet which is stressful in itself.

I really feel that we no option but to try to privately rent again to get out of here even though the cost is prohibitive and we were 'moved on' from 3 privately rented houses in 3 years before we became homeless and after we lost our OWN home and the insecurity was a nightmare and that is my biggest problem with doing it again.

I just cannot do this for another 3 years! I am so envious of people who live in houses and can't get my head round that as I always lived in one until now and never even thought about it. AIBU???

OP posts:
LazyMonkeyButler · 27/03/2013 23:10

Good god NettoSuperstar, I can just imagine how long someone deemed to be a low priority might have to wait!

shesariver · 27/03/2013 23:32

I think I remember your thread OP, was it the one you got flamed for having a trampoline?

rhondajean · 27/03/2013 23:34

I remember your last thread.

The problem is, your ideal situation which would help your mental health and quality of life is a secure tenancy on a council house in a nice area.

You are highly unlikely to get that quickly.

You know all the options. You are perfectly entitled to take whatever one you think will be best for your health and for your family.

Can you write out a list of pros and cons for staying and waiting/trying to swap/moving to private let etc? If I recall correctly you aren't on HB which helps a little in some ways and hinders in others too.

MrsRochestersCat · 27/03/2013 23:51

It is very difficult to fall in love with a home that you haven't chosen and wouldn't choose if you had the choice. Swap your home, don't give it up - by swapping you are able to take better control of your own life by choosing what and where you live.

FYI - I swapped from a detached home, garden etc into an upper level flat. I hated the hassle of the garden (no green fingers here!), prefer the security of being off the ground and the secure entry system (massive fear of burglars...), lower heating bills and the extra sunlight and prettier views as the windows are not as obscured. ...don't judge your home/situation by your own standards.

JustinBsMum · 27/03/2013 23:52

I wonder how old Dcs are - once toddler older and able to walk then getting up and down might be easier. Also are there parks around where DCs can play?

Are there neighbours on the ground floor who can keep the buggy? Just wondering if things might be better in a year or two. Also relationships with neighbours might improve as DCs get older and maybe quieter.

expatinscotland · 28/03/2013 16:08

'The problem is, your ideal situation which would help your mental health and quality of life is a secure tenancy on a council house in a nice area.

You are highly unlikely to get that quickly.'

Yep. Doesn't everyone?

whattimestea · 28/03/2013 16:56

I started the thread regarding how difficult it is for me to get a private rental on housing benefit.

Im having a nightmare and am on the verge of tears constantly. I just burst out crying all the time. Im filling up now typing this. I can safely say that i do not know what the immediate future holds for my family regarding a place to live. Its a horrible and frightening situation to be in. We cannot afford to stay where we are, we CAN'T find anywhere else. Nothing on housing association-most private rents are astronomical in price and/or they don't want to know us as we claim housing benefit.

I would say this - i would chew my right arm off to get a housing association property right now. The affordability and security that come with it is at the moment something i can just dream of. Obviously OP i don't know your personal circumstances. Maybe my view would be different if i walked in your shoes for a while? But i would think long and hard before you give up a secure tenancy i really would. If you regret it you could find it takes years and years to get back in there. But from someone who's losing sleep with worry over housing i really feel with you right now. Good luck OP.

OhLori · 28/03/2013 17:03

Why should you be entitled to a house?

Regardless, if you hate somewhere, its best to move.

LynetteScavo · 28/03/2013 17:10

I remember your thread (and your flaming) from last year.

You seem to have two options

  1. stay where you are, which you think is crap, but you won't be moved on.

  2. move to a privately rented house, and risk being moved.

This is one of those questions I cannot answer, as I'm not you, living your life. I know people on benefits, who manage to rent a nice 3 bed semi, and stay there for years, so obviously it is possible.

As someone who rented a nice 4 bed detached house, and was then asked to move out when the owner wanted to move back in, I will tell you there are no guarantees when you are renting privately.

expatinscotland · 28/03/2013 19:16

What last thread?

expatinscotland · 28/03/2013 19:51

Also, if you lost your home through foreclosure your credit score may make it hard for you to get a private let unless you have a guarantor.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread