Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I don't have to like my MIL just because we are related?

59 replies

littlemisssunny · 20/08/2012 20:50

My husband seems to think I should like my MIL just because I'm related to her!

Don't get me wrong I can be in the same room as her but she drives me bonkers! We are complete opposites and she winds me up the wrong way.

I can just about be polite to her but I find it really difficult to do that sometimes!

Anyway rant over, my FIL on the other hand is lovely, I get on really well with him and we have the same sense of humour so at least that's something!!

OP posts:
Mrsjay · 20/08/2012 22:23

IS it just DIl who hate their MILs Confused cos I will have SILs i hope my dds dont talk about their MIls like some do on here. I had a tough time in the begining with my MIL she was infact a bit bonkers but it was not me she disliked just any woman who took her precious away from her, of course you dont have to like your MIl but you do need to be tolerant and nice to her , she is husbnads mother and childrens granny after all

SundaeGirl · 20/08/2012 22:25

YABU, just tell yourself you like her, look for the good. Really, it will make life so much more bearable.

nokidshere · 20/08/2012 22:32

I hate that saying "a sons a son until he takes a wife etc etc"

I have every intention of being the perfect MIL when (if) my boys get married! I will not lose my sons over their choice of partner. Even if she is horrible (which I am sure they wont be) I will be the model of calm, supportive and kind, never interfering even if it kills me.

cocolepew · 20/08/2012 22:34

You shouldnt look at how a man treats his mum to see how he will treat you, thats shite. My DH treats his mum completely differently to me because she is nasty, hateful, and self centered narcissist and I'm not Smile

bubalou · 20/08/2012 22:40

We must have the same MIL.

I want to start a permanent thread for those that have MIL issues. We know what our MIL r really like - it just gets suggested to me that's it's my fault when I rant about her on here Hmm

Mrsjay · 20/08/2012 22:40

"a sons a son until he takes a wife

My Mil matra that was sigh she was quite difficult took years and a baby to settle into a good relationship with her, oh and we got married so that settled her down a bit ,

amybelle1990 · 20/08/2012 22:49

You don't have to like anyone :S

perfectstorm · 20/08/2012 22:55

nokidshere, I suspect every mother (or most) think that. The problem is, you very naturally want to be closely involved in your son's life, but most men don't do the emotional labour of family. Women do. So MIL know this rich, busy life is happening, which more often than not involves the other MIL far more closely because it's her the DIL usually turns to when the kids arrive, and feels excluded. And it's always going to be easier to think it's the DIL, instead of that your son has moved on in life and isn't really close in the way he once was. So MIL start to apply pressure to be included more, to know more, to see more, and the DIL is the one feeling that pressure, so she pushes back to try to feel less taken over. The MIL feels even more insecure and needy and so it goes on. I think a healthy MIL relationship needs the MIL in question to accept that the bonds are going to loosen with her son, and that she will usually be secondary to the DIL's own mother, if the DIL is primary carer of any kids, and the marriage is a successful one. Breaks my heart, as mother to an only son. But I think it's the case.

And it doesn't help that a lot of MIL are so used to being the son's mother in a very involved, active, domestic sense that they can't stop, even though they are undermining the wife by it. They're accustomed after a lifetime of being their son's primary woman to that role, and are not willing to surrender, even if (and it's a big if) they are to share. And being the primary woman in her own home and marriage isn't a role the DIL is prepared to share, let alone surrender, either.

I accept that I may not get on with my DIL, simply because my son is so hugely important and precious to me, and she will be hardwired to want to establish her own family, and not to have a MIL assuming that that history really means very much to a woman who wasn't there to share it, or that she can assume an intimate family relationship with as stranger. And almost all families are pretty weird in their own ways, ways to which the members are usually oblivious, but any outsider would be likely to Shock about. The DIL, usually, has all the power. And the MIL, again usually, can't accept the bonds loosening, which I think they need to.

If these relationships were simple, in-law problems would be rare. They seem to be almost the norm. It can't be that all the mothers in law are awful to everyone in their lives and just terrible people in general, or the DIL unreasonable, jealous and controlling. It just seems a relationship that is almost impossible to manage well, because otherwise, threads like this wouldn't be so commonplace.

Krumbum · 20/08/2012 22:58

That's not really related. Although you don't even have to like people you are actually related to! I do not like my grandfather and some of my aunts and uncles. Your dh must just really want you to like eachother because your both important to him.

skateboarder · 20/08/2012 22:59

I dont like my mil. I tolerate her as best i can. It's not easy as we dont like each other and i find her behaviour questionable.
She probably thinks the same about me as we couldnt be more different if we tried. So whoever said men marry their mothers, you are incorrect.
The only thing i have learnt from her is how to be a good mil. I will be the polar opposite to her!

perfectstorm · 20/08/2012 23:01

"Your dh must just really want you to like eachother because your both important to him."

That and it makes his life easier/lets him off the hook for managing the conflict. Sorry, but I think an easy life is a primary concern with all the men with tricky in-law situations I know of.

skateboarder · 20/08/2012 23:02

Good post perfect

Krumbum · 20/08/2012 23:03

Oh ok then, if that's the case he needs to deal with issues. Actually thinking about I wish my dp would stand up for me more when his mother is being rude and passive aggressive.

perplexedpirate · 20/08/2012 23:05

My mil is lovely to talk but we have VERY different ideas about pretty much everything. I think it's quote important the your DH does any 'dirty work' so to speak, or resentment does build.

I don't think I am related to my pils.

louisianablue2000 · 20/08/2012 23:26

Of course you don't have to like her. Even if she is a nice person you could have nothing in common and so nothing to really talk about. MIL is by no means a bad MIL and she does try really hard at times, and I suspect I'm not the best DIL in the world but she does drive me crazy. Partly because of some of the reasons above, e.g. she has, during each of my pregnancies, made some comments to me about how she is concerned about DH because he looks thin or tired or ill. How I feel when pregnant is of no interest to her, I'm purely a vessel providing a grandchild.

I don't think a difficult relationship is inevitable though, my SIL gets on very well with my Mum but naturally I think Mum is fantastic and she does a lot for DB and SIL (they live next door to her) but she is sensitive to how SIL feels and doesn't make comments that could be misinterpreted (like the above comments by MIL, they aren't terrible but they are insensitive). Plus SIL knows that Mum was absolutely delighted when DB and SIL got together (we tease them it was an arranged marriage because the families are friends and both lots of parents wanted a match) which must be a good start to a relationship, whereas I have had to negotiate different religions, family styles, social background etc etc. There was definitely a feeling when DH and I got married that I was not the ideal DIL from the PILs viewpoint.

PomBearWithAnOFRS · 21/08/2012 00:01

I dislike my MiL (in fact I have quite hard feelings towards her over a remark she once made about "my" son, who isn't "our" DH and mine son iykwim that I will never forgive her for) but DH doesn't know it. Or at least he's never mentioned it by word or deed if he has cottoned on. I just make sure that I am in the room with her on an average of once every 2-3 years or so and that's fine by me. Last time I saw her was when she turned 80 and that was either 3 or 4 years ago in January Grin
DH takes the "our" DCs to see her once a week minimum, and phones her sometimes in between and she phones him if she wants any messages running or a lift anywhere, but that doesn't affect me at all. I'm not sure she even knows the older "my" DSs names tbh, but they don't seem bothered any more now they are adults.

MrsUppity · 21/08/2012 08:28

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Diddydollydo · 21/08/2012 08:45

Men marry their mothers? Utter nonsense!

I really like my mother in law, we have nothing in common but have a reasonable relationship because we both make the effort. DH, on the other hand, doesn't like her at all!

shesariver · 21/08/2012 09:16

A son's a son till he gets him a wife, a daughters a daughter for all of her life.... hence some tricky MIL relationships.

No hence some tired old stereotype that some people like to believe. Hmm

charlottehere · 21/08/2012 09:19

No of course not! Can't stand mine and no I'm not making pretty with them, they are arses. Humpffff

KellyElly · 21/08/2012 09:55

You aren't related to her. She's your inlaw Confused

Ephiny · 21/08/2012 10:00

How are you related to her? Presumably not too closely, if you've married her son!

Of course you don't have to like her. Normally I'd say you should make the effort to be polite to her, though if she's actually nasty and unpleasant to you, your husband should be taking your side and standing up to her.

littlemisssunny · 21/08/2012 10:06

She isn't related in any way other than I married her son, I always thought that meant you were related?

OP posts:
KellyElly · 21/08/2012 12:44

littlemisssunny I don't think so as if you got divorced you wouldn't still be considered relatives. Same as you aren't related to your husband (coz that would be illegal :)). Your DH and kids are her relation. Family obvs doesn't have to be about blood though and some people who have a bond with MIL call them mum and do see them as family but in your case your get out of jail free card is that you aren't related Grin.

diddl · 21/08/2012 12:58

I don´t like my MIL.

I don´t dislike her either, but can´t say that I´ve ever enjoyed spending time with her.