Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not hand over one of DD's birthday gifts?

73 replies

WelshMaenad · 24/07/2012 19:31

it was dd's birthday last week, she was six. We received a parcel and separate card in the post from DH's older brother.

However, it was my son's birthday back in April and he received nothing from the same uncle, no card or even call/text etc. We haven't really heard from thus brother for months, he lives quite far away from us, and we in turn live quite far from the rest of DH's family.

I sent him a text saying that we'd received dd's gift but were surprised we hadn't heard from him at ds's birthday months ago. No reply, but the following day he left a message on my voicemail saying they were sorry, he just forgot, awernern't deliberately treating them differently.

Thing us - he IS, because there's been nothing forthcoming for DS. No belated card, gift, or anything. I'm not materialistic, I'm more about the thought than a gift, and I'm just as annoyed that on realising he'd forgotten, which he must have done, he didn't make the effort to acknowledge it, to ring and apologise or send him a wee card. It took me confronting him to get a reaction.

I have not given dd the gift yet, and tbh I just want to send it back to him, because in my eyes you don't give to one without the other. WDYT?

OP posts:
DontstepontheMomeRaths · 24/07/2012 20:20

Oh dear I could be your DH's brother. I have 10 nieces/ nephews now and can forget. I don't send anything if I realise too late but just leave it Blush

I am crap at remembering, it's not deliberate.

DontstepontheMomeRaths · 24/07/2012 20:22

Actually I have 4 brothers and some of them are rubbish at remembering my kids birthdays too. Perhaps it's just my family that are like this? Grin

chocoluvva · 24/07/2012 20:23

We have an auntie who does this too. Her DC never say thankyou for the gifts we give them. It really irritates me, but we try to just make a joke about it. We live remotely from all the rest of the family too. I can't imagine her forgetting any of the other nieces or nephews birthdays, but hey ho - we're nicer. Karma and all that? Hope you get some comfort from the idea of karma.

chocoluvva · 24/07/2012 20:25

Dontstep, have you thought about getting an engagements calendar or putting a reminder into your computer, or maybe an app?

WelshMaenad · 24/07/2012 20:26

I'd struggle with ten, but he only has my two!

OP posts:
firawla · 24/07/2012 20:26

What an overreaction! Can't believe you actually confronted him about the 'missing' present for your son - You are really rude.

DontstepontheMomeRaths · 24/07/2012 20:28

Does he have kids himself? I was so ignorant about how important gifts and thank you cards were until I had my own.

Yes I should get around to an app on my iphone for birthdays. Too true Blush

WelshMaenad · 24/07/2012 20:29

Well, firawla, I guess I was just channelling his own attitude. Because he had a go at me for not wanting to make a 400 mile round trip for a pub lunch for his mother's 60th, three weeks after a c section. Birthdays were REALLY IMPORTANT then. I guess I was querying why they aren't any more. And I really wasn't rude, but I don't suspect you actually care!

OP posts:
DontstepontheMomeRaths · 24/07/2012 20:30

Oh he now sounds like a complete jerk Welsh.

WelshMaenad · 24/07/2012 20:31

No, he and his partner are childfree. My two are the only kids in the immediate family.

OP posts:
WelshMaenad · 24/07/2012 20:33

I know. It's hard to give significant backstory without sounding like you're on Jezza. I don't dislike him, I just find him and the PIL completely baffling. The younger one's an absolute gem!

OP posts:
OutragedAtThePriceOfFreddos · 24/07/2012 20:35

A childless man in that barely even sees your dc?

I would give him credit for remembering one of your dcs birthdays, let alone being bothered enough to buy, wrap and send a present on time.

He has apologised, accept it with good grace.

WelshMaenad · 24/07/2012 20:39

I obviously have wildly different expectations of family than is the norm. I guess this illustrates how very lucky I am WRT my own family, if nothing else!

OP posts:
Floggingmolly · 24/07/2012 20:45

Your dd received a gift and you rang to admonish your brother for not sending one to your son????????

WelshMaenad · 24/07/2012 20:48

No. He's not my brother. I sent him a text. And it wasn't the lack if gift do much as the complete lack of contact (card, call, text message to say "hope he has a nice day", any if which would gave sufficed). I didn't admonish him, I told him we were surprised we didn't hear from him, which indeed we were. I'm the sort of person that says this chit instead of letting it fester. You find it refreshing and open or you think I'm a bitch, there's rarely middle ground. I'm never bothered either way.

OP posts:
WelshMaenad · 24/07/2012 20:50

Incidentally I'm also the type of person with fat fingers who types too quick on an iPhone. Good luck making sense of the above.

OP posts:
Floggingmolly · 24/07/2012 20:51

I wouldn't find it in the least refreshing, actually, but each to their own Smile

WelshMaenad · 24/07/2012 20:54

Fortunately for humanity, flogging, a close personal friendship with me is a voluntary endeavour undertaken only by those who find me charmante.

OP posts:
ll31 · 24/07/2012 20:55

yabvu and rude. can't believe you texted him about forgetting ds birthday. very rude and grasping

KingofHighVis · 24/07/2012 21:26

I would expect dp to deal with it.

GhostShip · 24/07/2012 21:29

Just give it to her for gods sake.

wherearemysocks · 24/07/2012 21:41

YANBU, I'm surprised by the number of people calling you petty and rude. Whilst it may not be the biggest deal in the world I don't think asking your dc to be treated equally is unreasonable.

WelshMaenad · 24/07/2012 22:00

That's all I want, wherearemysocks. I couldn't give a monkeys if he didn't get either of them a gift, or a card, as long as he thought of them BOTH. like I said, a quick call or a text on both their birthdays would have made me happy. He rang the night of dd's birthday to check gift had arrived etc. Just made me very sad for DS, I know be wouldn't know any different but I was sad for him all the same.

OP posts:
pigletmania · 24/07/2012 22:39

I would give te present, after all it's for her. I am glad you mentioned it to your BIL and he is aware. I would keep an eye on things if this is not the first time he has been treated differently to your dd

maddening · 24/07/2012 23:34

it's not your brother to cut off - how does your dh feel about you causing a rift with his brother?

Swipe left for the next trending thread