Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think mil could buy dd1 present for bday

40 replies

familyfun · 26/06/2012 14:23

mil spoils my dds all the time, she visits weekly and 9 times out of 10 brings bags of presents, books, cbeebies magazines, craft sets, teddies, it is endless and we have asked her not to bring so much as it spoils dds but she says why shouldnt she while she can.

last week dd1 had early bday party for classmates, we invited grandparents to watch which they kindly did, mil came and started shouting dd1 from softplay slides with her friends to come over for a bag, she said it was a present so i presumed bday present and said all dds presents were on table but she wasnt opening them till her bday so should i put it on the table for her, no it wasnt a bday present, it was a magazine and teddy just as a gift for dd1 and she expected dd1 to stop enjoying her party and come and take the bag and look at it. dd1 rushed over quickly looked in bag said thanks and carried on playing.

so why wont mil buy dd1 a bday present? some weeks ago when we were ordering dd1 some small presents dp asked mil if she wanted us to order some lego off her for dd1 bday. she said no she was thinking of getting her something else, fine. then last week she said she was going to give me some money to buy her something, but didnt say how much or waht to order, this week she has given me a tenner but will give me a bit more next week when she can, i said thats not necessary but she insists and fil says he will give some too when he can.
so the week before dds bday i have a tenner and have to go shopping when i ordered all presents and wrapped them weeks ago, then a day or 2 before dds bday i am getting more money but dont know ho much and need to shop again, then wrap these things.
eveery other week she can choose toys/books for dds but not for her bday Hmm

im ungrateful i know but she drives me mad.
1st xmas she gave her a tenner in the card and moaned that it dropped on floor and dd1 ignored it, she was 6 months old and didnt know what a tenner was.
2nd xmas she bought a bag full of toys round xmas eve all unwrapped with no paper so i sat till midnight wrapping them all as dd enjoyed the unwrapping at 18 months.
3rd xmas i ordered what she wanted as mil asked me to and then waited forever for the money.
4th xmas she gave me the money a few days before xmas and told me to get toys with it, she didnt want it saving as she wanted dd to enjoy it now and she didnt want dd to choose things after as she wanted her to have them at xmas, she didnt understand why i refused to go shopping 2 days before xmas with dd1 andbaby dd2 in tow when id done my own shopping in advance and wrapping while dd1 was at nursery.

long and ranty i know, i should be grateful she buys her things ans visits but why can she buy stuff all year, including boys outfits for dd2 cos she thinks she is a tomboy and clothes too small all the time and craft sets to keep me busy as she loves to say but suddenly is incapable at bday and xmas.

aaaagh

OP posts:
rhondajean · 26/06/2012 14:26

I'm sure someone else will save me the effort.

gothicangel · 26/06/2012 14:27

why not just give the money to DD and let her pick something herself :) after her bday

x

BettySwollocksandaCrustyRack · 26/06/2012 14:29

I'm with Rhonda

squeakytoy · 26/06/2012 14:29

you do sound the sort of person who wouldnt be happy with the present either, and maybe your MIL senses that..

MustStartExercising · 26/06/2012 14:34

i wouldn't go shopping again, I'd relabel something I'd already bought and use the money for DD in the future.

ErikNorseman · 26/06/2012 14:35
Confused
familyfun · 26/06/2012 14:36

would love to let dd1 pick herself something after with the money but mil insists she wants her to have a present, she just wants me to get it a few days before with no notice of what to get and then wrap it for her, its just laziness i think.
mil knows dd loves drawing so nay pens/pencils/paper and she would be happy, also any books, she sees dd weekly and knows aht she likes.
i am happy with any thought out present, im not too happy with clothes 2 sizes too small or boys clothes or complicated knitting things "to keep me busy" when i cant knit and have toddler to loof after too.

OP posts:
familyfun · 26/06/2012 14:37

muststart, thats a good idea, i might just relabel the lego i got and keep the money for dd when we go on hols.

OP posts:
Pandemoniaa · 26/06/2012 14:38

You are coming across as very difficult to please. Which makes me wonder whether your MIL has stopped trying. Also, it's not so unreasonable to shop a few days before a birthday is it?

familyfun · 26/06/2012 14:38

i presume the rest of you think im ungrateful and i dont mean to be.
if she was uncapable of getting out to the shops id understand but they are out every day with a car, why not save a few of the books they buy weekly and give them to her on her bday?

OP posts:
NinaHeart · 26/06/2012 14:39

AYBU? Pretty much so.

I wonder what yout MIL would say about the same events? Perhaps how she tries her best and offers alternatives, but whatever she does is not seen as good enough or right?

familyfun · 26/06/2012 14:40

its not too bad a few days before hr bday as she is at school but at xmas its a nightmare the shops are busy and i have 2 kids to take with me thats why i do mine early and offer to get hers early for her but no it has to be last minute

OP posts:
NinaHeart · 26/06/2012 14:41

Two further words.
Internet shopping.

familyfun · 26/06/2012 14:43

i dont think she does try her best though nina, why doesnt she buy her soemthing herslef, or ask me to fetch it, or give me the money a few weeks before so i have time when its convenient to me rather than having to miss dd2 swimming class the day before her bday to go shopping, or let dd choose soemthing herself the week after?

OP posts:
RecursiveMoon · 26/06/2012 14:43

family, I can see your point. I would definitely relabel a present that you already have for her, and save the money for her. It sounds like she'll have lots if presents anyway. And I'm afraid that you'll have to talk to your MIL about scaling down the constant presents too.

familyfun · 26/06/2012 14:45

done all mine on internet with time for it to arrive. mil doesnt have internet but yes if i knew how much to spend i could order something. as it is i have a tenner and have been told to expect some more off mil and fil when they can?
might just order soemthing for a tenner and let dd have the rest to spend herself

OP posts:
familyfun · 26/06/2012 14:47

we have =nt bought her much, just 2 lego sets, a dvd and some felts, she only asked for a party and lego. i will relabel a set of lego.

OP posts:
Ephiny · 26/06/2012 14:51

I'm not sure I understand...you asked her not to buy so many gifts, and now you're complaining that she hasn't bought a gift?

Though actually she did bring a gift to the birthday party, but for some reason that doesn't 'count' as a birthday gift?

Sorry, I don't get it Confused. Am tentatively going with a YABU though...

freddiefrog · 26/06/2012 14:54

I can see your point too.

I have something similar with my MiL.

She starts asking what my girls want for Christmas around the end of August.

I give her suggestions - books/colouring/craft stuff/clothes/games for their DSs/etc.

She decides she doesn't want to buy any of my suggestions and gives me ideas - winter coat (by Christmas we've usually already got that one covered), swings for the garden (we have some), etc, etc.

She then throws a massive hissy fit as the kids are "spoilt"

She then gives me money and asks me to buy and wrap them something

This carry on plays out from the end of August until 2 days before Christmas when I'm then expected to go last minute shopping

I won't do it anymore, I just give the girls the money and they spend it after Christmas in the sales

Repeat for birthdays

familyfun · 26/06/2012 14:54

we asked her not to buy gifts weekly as dds are starting to expect it and i dont want them spoiled.
i want her to buy a small gift for her bday rather than ask me last minute.

the present at party would have been a lovely bday present, but it was unwrapped and given to dd in her hands and she was told it wasnt a bday present, just a gift for that day off ehr nan who had bought her 2 things the day before.

OP posts:
oopslateagain · 26/06/2012 14:57

Family, I do understand and - going out on a limb here - YANBU.

At that age it's nice to have lovely presents to unwrap, a toy handed over in a bag just isn't the same. Half the fun of birthdays is the unwrapping. And seriously, does nobody else think that it's reasonable to expect someone to either (a) buy a present, wrap it, and hand it over, or (b) give money but with no restrictions on what/when to do with it?

I had this with my mum, she would always buy DD a toy, magazine, cake, sweets, something like that, whenever we went out, which was fine. But if DD pointed at something my mum would buy it for her. I had to stop her, because DD was starting to expect lots of things to be just handed over on a whim. I wanted gifts to be a treat, something to look forward to and enjoy, not something to just look at, go "ok" and shrug, which was what DD was starting to do whenever she was given something.

familyfun · 26/06/2012 14:57

thansk you freddie, yes mil has told dd1 several times she knows what she is getting her and it will be a surprise but hasnt actually done anything.
we have also asked her to be fair as she gives dd1 stuff but not dd2 so she now has started giving dd1 3 books and a top and dd2 a boys t shirt??

OP posts:
Sirzy · 26/06/2012 15:27

I would just tell your MIL you are going to give your DD the money and let her go shipping herself for the present. If your MIL doesn't like that she should go and buy it herself. I used to love getting birthday money and going shopping for presents.

Joiningthegang · 26/06/2012 16:14

I think I get your point but you really sound like hard work :(

Just relabel fgs

Journey · 26/06/2012 17:12

I find your post totally contrary. As joiningthegang says you sound like hard work.