Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to stick two fingers up at my extended family?

63 replies

Woofsaidtheladybird · 21/05/2012 11:25

Right. Long winded and boring, but I'm in a quandary.

It's my Aunt's (Dad's sister) 75th birthday party on Saturday, and we (myself, DH, DD3, DS5m) have been invited. It's being organised by my uncle (her brother) and my aunt (his wife) and the lunch is being hosted at my cousin's house (my uncle's son) about an hour's drive away.

When I was pregnant with DD in 2008 my Aunt disowned me and stopped talking to me. I'd been seeing DH (then DP) for 8 months, and was doing a PhD (which I had to eventually quit). We knew we were going to have a future and wanted children, but as I wasn't that young in the scheme of things, plus had had ovary problems, we decided to be more lax with contraception. Of course, I conceived straight away. My Mum told my Aunt and she said 'how disappointing'. We saw my Aunt on Boxing Day that year at my parents, and when DP went to shake her hand, she quite pointedly ignored his hand, and refused to speak to him for the rest of the lunch, and also myself. We were severely disappointed, as I'd always loved my Aunt very much - she is also my Godmother. She is also a Vicar, and we wanted her to do our wedding ceremony for us, the following October. After that day, we clearly decided not to, and as my parents were doing a lot of the wedding organising, she wasn't invited to our wedding either, which made me quite sad, but I felt it was the right thing to do. She has stopped sending me birthday cards, and Christmas cards are just addressed to 'woof and family'. I got a brief congrats card when DD was born, and also for DS. Nothing else for them, no little 'welcome' kind of presents, never anything for their birthdays or Christmas.

So. I have 2 older brothers. One is divorced - 2 children from first wife - left her to be with my current SIL, and they had a baby before marrying. My aunt doesn't ignore them, showers his boys with gifts, lavish hampers at Christmas, the works. My other brother and his wife (no children) we don't talk to (he rented my flat off me last year and was a complete arsehole and messed me about when I was heavily pregnant - refused entry to estate agents trying to sell it, left drugs around, promised to keep it tidy but didn't, didn't pay rent on time, left me out of pocket, you name it). For some bizarre reason my aunt idolises him. She was my brothers' guardians when they were at boarding school when we lived overseas when we were younger.

Anyway. Both brothers, I have discovered since yesterday, are going to the party. I saw the invite as a kind of olive branch, and had decided to go. I do NOT want to see my arsey brother at all (DH reckons his blood will boil if we see him, and he doesn't want him around our children as he's off his face half the time). I kind of want to see my Aunt and show off my lovely children, and show her and her partner what they are missing out on. (Btw, she has no children, she has lived with her female friend for the best part of 50 years - no-one knows what the relationship between them is, and no-one gives a hoot anyway) I do want to see my uncle and cousin, and other cousins going. My parents aren't going, as since the Boxing Day debacle, they haven't talked to my Aunt either.

WTF would you do? I'm tempted to say bugger off to all of them, but its faaaamily innit. I'm especially sad as it's DD's birthday today, and no-one from my family (apart from my parents and my uncle - mum's brother) have sent her a card ('nice' brother says his is in the post.) DH's family - great aunts, great-great aunts, random 2nd cousins twice removed - have all sent cards.

The issues that bug me are:

  • She's a vicar. Be nice, FFS!
  • Why ignore me, and not my brother, when we've both had babies outside marriage??!!
  • Why is my other twatty brother still existing, and bugging me so much?
  • If I go, I'm the youngest cousin and will be treated as such. I'm bloody forty in a few months.

Either way, I need to call my uncle today and tell him yay or nay.

Arse. I'm so angry thinking about it all. Angry. Have told DH I'm getting a MN opinion on it all..
Sorry its long!

OP posts:
doormat · 21/05/2012 11:30

so your parents have backed you up on what aunt did to you on boxing day.....

i would tell her to eff off, vicar or not....her atitude stinks...she doesnt deserve a niece like you nor your children in her life...leave her to get on with her sad, mudane existence

TheHappyHissy · 21/05/2012 11:31

Don't bother, go out with your mum and dad! Good on them for sticking up for you!

2rebecca · 21/05/2012 11:37

It sounds as though it's only really this aunt and 1 brother you dislike and don't get on with. The aunt's behaviour towards you sounds odd and unkind if you previously got on well.
Up to you if you go or don't go, but if you go be prepared for aunt to continue to be a bit frosty. It sounds as though there are enough other people there you like to make going enjoyable, and in the long term scheme 1 party won't make much difference to your life. Aunt may have thawed in which case things will be better, but she may not have. Your parents are on your side and that's a major plus.
WRT your daughter's birthday it sounds as though your husbands family are a bit OTT with cards with great aunts and random cousins sending birthday cards. Grandparents remembering and aunts and uncles being well intentioned but often a bit late is more normal in my experience.

oldraver · 21/05/2012 11:37

I would go and hold my head high, just show you are proud of your lovely family. If you dont go it will give them reason to be crtitcal behind your back.

FWIW my BF has always been considered the black sheep. We live a quiet life just doing family stuff, but they totally ignore this and always make reference to DP's so called misbehaviour in the past. It does make me not want to be around them as they are like a broken record and its also very expensive to go up to see them and I'm not sure they appreciate that, but we will be going to the next family gathering and holding our heads up and going home form the party early to get DS into bed while they get pissed up

bibbitybobbitybunny · 21/05/2012 11:41

I wonder why they invited you? If I were your Aunt I probably would have considered myself cut off from your branch of the family when I wasn't invited to your wedding.

CheshireDing · 21/05/2012 11:45

Who has actually invited you? and if it's not the Aunt (which presumably it's not) do they know about the Boxing Day incident?

I wouldn't go, as already said sod the fact she is a Vicar. Why do you want to go to the Birthday party of someone who was rude and not very nice to you? Just because someone is related to you doesn't mean you have to stay in touch if they are not nice people - that includes your Brother.

Go out somewhere with your own little Family instead on the day.

Woofsaidtheladybird · 21/05/2012 11:46

Bibbity - she was the one that cut off contact when I became pregnant, pre wedding....

Yes, tempted to go and hold head high and would be prepared for frostiness. We'd planned to go until I found out my brother was going - yet another spanner in the works...

OP posts:
Oogaballoo · 21/05/2012 11:48

Well, since you asked...I wouldn't go. I understand you want to show her that her judgment was unfair and that you have a family you love and she didn't get to see, but the scenario you hope for- where she might realise that she was wrong- probably won't play out. It's more likely that something will happen that will upset you (she'll continue treating the brother that messed you about like a golden child or will be rude in some way) and you'll wonder why you showed up at all. She doesn't sound pleasant and she's treated you very badly, as have some of your other relatives. I wouldn't give her the time of day, let alone go to her party after her behavior.

RaPaPaPumPumBootyMum · 21/05/2012 11:49

I'm sorry this has happened and that such a rift has been created between yourself and your Aunt.

However that's her responsibility to put right and not yours. I am so glad your parents are backing you up on this, your Aunt has behaved very badly.

I think if it was me I would deny the invitation. It is a celebration of your Aunt's birthday and if it were me, I don't think I would be able to enter into the spirit of the event with a glad and easy heart. I would probably feel and also look resentful and it would be a waste of my time. And I would probably feel as if I was saying her rejection of me 4 years ago was okay with me and that bygones were bygones... Whereas I am pretty sure I wouldn't feel like that at all.

That said, your Aunt is 75 and may not have many years left. I know you said she used to be very dear to you. So only you can decide whether you feel you need to be there at this birthday. Again, if it were me, I might decline the invitation and instead contact my Aunt directly to see if we could meet one-on-one to talk things out. Might she have mellowed in the past years and be open to the idea of a reconciliation? Or, if she is as firmly entrenched in her negative point of view then you know she is probably best avoided.

Anyway OP, best of luck! It sounds as if you're in a very good place now with lovely DH, DD and DS.
Oh and that brother of yours [with the drugs and unpaid rent] sounds a waste of your time and company too!

Woofsaidtheladybird · 21/05/2012 11:50

Cheshire - its my uncle who has done the inviting, but mean-aunt would have said who to invite. I don't know if he is aware of the boxing day incident but the whole family knows something is up as my parents don't attend anything / keep in touch. All 'my fault' apparently, acc to my mum!

DH wants to go to the zoo.. Grin

As for all the cards - lets just say MIL is a very proud grandma (DD is the first grandchild - nuff said)

OP posts:
toofattorun · 21/05/2012 11:50

I am sorry but F* HER (not literally. Obviously). She doesn't deserve your attention. Don't be sad. She chose to be a bitch. Not you.

bibbitybobbitybunny · 21/05/2012 11:51

What do you mean by cut off contact, though?

I understand that you haven't forgiven her for the Boxing Day incident and presumably that is why you didn't invite her to your wedding ... but that was 3 years ago.

I just wondered why you were invited? Who invited you and has the 3 year rift been mentioned?

Personally I wouldn't go. If you were going to "make it up" as it were, then you would have/should have done so a long time ago.

lostInMyHouse · 21/05/2012 11:57

I'd go to the Zoo and enjoy the day - after ringing and apologizing to your uncle and perhaps sending a present and card as on olive branch.

Other wise you risk being upset by the Aunt and your brother and having a horrible day and being really upset afterwards. I'm not sure a reconciliation with audience, perhaps audience trying to engineering with no reference to said Aunt, is going to work it could well turn into a massive fight.

Plus how would your parents feel about you going when thye've stood up to this aunt for you?

Woofsaidtheladybird · 21/05/2012 11:58

Bibbity - I have sent Xmas and birthday cards, gifts etc, but we have been ignored - and bonkersly lavish gifts have been given to my nephews.

OP posts:
Woofsaidtheladybird · 21/05/2012 12:00

Lost - my parents have said its up to me but think I'm mad to do so.

DH doesn't want to go, especially cos of twat-brother.

OP posts:
lostInMyHouse · 21/05/2012 12:02

I suspect if you've tried sending cards and gifts before then that this Aunt has no wish to get back on good terms with you.

Probably your uncle either does not know what went on or trying not to get involved and assumed if there was bad blood you'd refuse the invite rather than cause trouble.

bibbitybobbitybunny · 21/05/2012 12:03

Oh I'm probably being incredibly dense but I can't get past the not inviting her to your wedding thing. This suggests to me that you didn't want to continue a relationship with her - how could it not?.

bibbitybobbitybunny · 21/05/2012 12:03

Yes, her family are probably inviting you because it is the correct thing to do, rather than actually wanting you there.

lostInMyHouse · 21/05/2012 12:04

I can understand your DH not wanting to be wound up by your bother or wanting to have you upset and made unhappy by your Aunt possible for quite a while afterwards.

CheshireDing · 21/05/2012 12:11

Ah go to the zoo then, sounds far more fun Grin

Woofsaidtheladybird · 21/05/2012 12:15

Bibbity - her family is also my family. And I actually did want to invite her, but my parents were doing the official inviting thing and my Dad refused to invite her. If someone refused to shake your dp's hand and ignore everything he said, would you want her around? No. I'm just a softie and miss her. A bit.

My brother can go jump.

OP posts:
diddl · 21/05/2012 12:28

Why would you want to celebrate the birthday of someone who dislikes you & whom you also dislike?

WhereYouLeftIt · 21/05/2012 12:30

Have you ever thought about going to the party, and putting her on the spot? How well do you get on with non-twat brother, could you do a pincer movement?
e.g.
DBro : My DC were thrilled with , DSis. So what did auntie get your children for Christmas?
You : Absolutely nothing, just like on their birthdays.

Said in the middle of listening relatives.

BerthaTheBogBurglar · 21/05/2012 12:38

Who is going to be at the party, that you want to see? What are you missing out on if you don't go?

The family members that you get on with all think you shouldn't go (but aren't going to be horrid to you, if you do go). So there's no fallout from not attending.

The only thing I can see is that you're hoping Auntie-Vicar will have a change of heart, tell you she loves and misses you and start treating your children like beloved relatives? You know that isn't going to happen, don't you? And if you want to make steps towards a relationship with her, this party probably isn't the time.

Woofsaidtheladybird · 21/05/2012 12:39

Hm. Maybe Bibbity is right and I'm just being invited as its the done thing rather than actually be wanted there Sad

FFS.

Non twat brother wouldn't do that. He is actually twat brothers identical twin so also has a bit of twattishness in him, but to a lesser extent. Especially since he had children. Anyway, both brothers pander to her - I'm clearly more stubborn Sad

OP posts: