Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to give it to her anyway...

51 replies

flyingspaghettimonster · 06/03/2012 18:46

This is a bit silly and I am long-winded, so I apologise in advance. The brief version for those that don't like to read much is this:- I made a sodding huge diaper cake for a friend and am worried it is far too OTT and will make me look crazy if I give it.

Background:- I am an obsessive gift-buyer and giver, always have gone overboard on every birthday, Christmas etc for my near and dear. Most people are used to it. One of my worst over-gifting situations is baby showers.

So the problem is this:- a friend is having a baby shower this weekend. I like her very much - I don't do close friends, but if I did I would probably make more effort to see her often - she is a lovely person and I know she has wanted this baby for a long time. So I have been planning her baby cake for several months... I wanted it to be my biggest yet. I must have been to 40 shops in the hunt for the perfect items, I wanted it to be full of useful things I found good with my three kids. I also just inherited some money so must confess I spent more than I would ever have spent normally as I wasn't really counting what I spent on each thing... I just bought anything that fitted the theme and that I liked.

Unfortunately, I went totally overboard. She sent an email when I was halfway through building it, asking me not to go over the top or spend too much as it would make her uncomfortable. I felt terrible as I had already done this, but we talked about it and she said she was very excited about the cake, and just didn't want me to think I had to make a big deal because she knows I always do. She said it would be fine, just to promise not to buy anything else. I haven't...

I finished the cake yesterday. I feel sick looking at it - it is like my own personal albatross sat there on the table blocking the light as it pretty much fills the window. I covered a 2ft by 2ft plywood board in silver paint and cellophane to look like a cake board - and the cake hangs over the edges of it :-(

2ft squared at the base, and the same height as my 3 year old. It is crazy. Every inch of it is covered in stuff - 180 diapers are inside, and there are enough toys for a daycare, everything from nappy cream to cool gel breast pads, blankets, outfits, towels, bath stuff... it is insane. I made a list of everything on my computer as I built it, for the 'recipe' - it is 3 pages of word document. 12pt. Single spaced list.

Now I am faced with my creation I can no longer deny my total shopaholic tendencies or obsessive over gifting. It is sat there judging me. I know if I take it to the shower there is no way I can pretend I didn't spend too much - it is very clear that such a large cake with those items has cost hundreds of dollars. I will have to have a friend with a truck deliver it as it is too big for our car. Two people will struggle to carry the fecking thing.

If I take it the shower it will dwarf everyone else's gifts. It will steal attention from everything. I don't want that. It is the sort of a gift the expectant grandmother might give if they were particularly excited about the baby... not something you would expect from a casual friend you see maybe once a month. It was so crowded I had to put the 22 pairs of socks I made into sock roses on a separate wreath for decorating the front door, because there was no space for them on the cake.

What to do? I can't face pulling it all apart and couldn't return half the stuff as tags were removed/been two months since purchase etc. I could maybe save half for another baby shower, but it is all themed to this cake so hard to split.

I want her to have it, but feel I have to apologise and am scared it is going to make her feel forced into a closer friendship than we have right now. I had already made it clear I am happy to help out with babysitting anytime as her husband is Navy so away a lot. I don't want her to think I am forcing my way into her life. It was meant to just show I like her and am happy for her, but it seems to say more that I am lonely, bored, baby obsessed and unhinged.

What should I do? I already think if I do give it to her I will do so after or before the shower, not at it, so it won't be on display when everyone does the gift opening. Probably everything everyone else brings is on the fecking cake anyhow.

OP posts:
McHappyPants2012 · 06/03/2012 18:50

perhaps give it to her after the party when every one has gone home.

LadySybilDeChocolate · 06/03/2012 18:51

Can we see a picture? Can you make is smaller? It does sound very over the top. I'm sorry, I wouldn't give it to her.

TheOneWithTheHair · 06/03/2012 18:52

Take one thing out to give at the shower, give her the cake another time and explain why then go to the gp about your compulsion before you get into trouble debt

Your friend will be pleased though:)

aquafunf · 06/03/2012 18:53

dont really know what a cake is in this context- assume that it is a way of displaying gifts.

solution; buy a large basket. Put the nicest items in there,tastefully displayed.

Put another note in saying " I hope you like the items, I have also made a donation to the local hospital/ womens refuge/insert name of local charity"

take rest of stuff to womens shelter/church/whoever you trust to make sure it goes to someone who needs and will value it.

Take and keep a photo on your phone for the next time you go into a frenzy.

dont be too hard on yourself

IAmBooyhoo · 06/03/2012 18:54

take it apart and do it again. only option.

Coconutty · 06/03/2012 18:54

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LadySybilDeChocolate · 06/03/2012 18:55

aqua has a good plan. Smile Take off anything that you can and put them inside a small basket.

DeWe · 06/03/2012 18:56

Will you have friends who will also have "baby showers" in the next year or so. If so divide it into several smaller "cakes" and choose which one to give her.

Take a photo and then go and get help.

QuickLookBusy · 06/03/2012 18:56

Agree with everything aqua said.

seaweedhead · 06/03/2012 18:59

You could make a business out of it! make massive diaper cakes and sell them for a profit.

With this one it looks like you'll have to scale it down a bit if its going to make her feel uncomfortable.

Badgerina · 06/03/2012 19:01

Aquafunf said it all.

tiredteddy · 06/03/2012 19:06

How long until the baby shower? If its is a while away could you email some of the other (if not all) people invited and suggest a joint gift of said diaper cake that you have made and will bring? Others may not yet have bought gifts? It sounds like it has everything covered. From a group it would not be overwhelming and people could give you a donation back towards the cost.

If that would not work. I agree with the other posters that you will have to scale it down in some way.

My MIL is like you with gifts and it can be very overwhelming but I know in my heart she just cares so I try accept things with good grace.

ManicPanic · 06/03/2012 19:09

I do this too, flyingspaghettimonster. I may not make huge cakes, but I certainly over buy for friends birthdays and spend too much on them... I have reined myself in for the past few years as I've found it's alienated people more than anything, though obviously that was never my intention.

I think you and me should become best pals and then we can shower each other with gifts and handmade stuff Wink

DinahMoHum · 06/03/2012 19:12

have you thought about getting therapy?

When it gets to the stage that you have spent so much and gone to that much effort over a gift that you are actually embarrassed and remorseful and it makes other people uncomfortable, then im wondering who is benefiting here?

lisaro · 06/03/2012 19:12

I'm with coconutty, too much. Not even a close friend, I know you mean well but it's a bit weird.

NarkedPuffin · 06/03/2012 19:13

You know what you need to do. You will make it uncomfortable for her and upstage everyone else if you turn up with that.

Take it apart. Give her a basket/make a new 'cake' with a selection of items that's not more than 25% of the current mega 'cake'.

Keep the picture of it and make a list of everything you put into it with estimated prices. Total it up and write the cost on the picture. Pin it to your fridge.

NarkedPuffin · 06/03/2012 19:18

Once you've costed it out you take DeWe's suggestion and make it up into several cakes, then sell the spares as Seaweedhead suggested.

igetcrazytoo · 06/03/2012 19:18

Personally, I like my nutty friends the best and you sound truly wonderful.

Can you ask a mutual friend their opinion? and to brave the way for you.

FlossieTeacakeShouldFakeIt · 06/03/2012 19:22

Please upload a photo! Please?

I think it sounds wonderful and I don't see why you shouldn't give it to her. She is having a baby shower FFS, people don't have baby showers if they don't like lots of presents.

If you are known for going OTT, it won't be a big surprise. And people do go crazy with baby presents, I did over my best friends gifts, it was a good excuse to go cute stuff shopping!

BigGirlInASmallWorld · 06/03/2012 19:23

I get you are lovely genorous but OTT.

Aside from that i haven't a clue what diaper cake is Confused

I agree with aqua

x

imogengladheart · 06/03/2012 19:25

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

flyingspaghettimonster · 06/03/2012 19:25

I don't really want to post pics of mine because a) someone might link to it and show the intended recipient - thus taking any decision about down sizing out of my hands b) there are always folks on the internet who would be very rude and say how hideous it was, and I don't want that. I did google 'giant diaper cake' and found this link:- physioprof.wordpress.com/2008/05/30/diaper-cake-thats-just-fucking-wrong/ - the first picture there looks vaguely comparabe in size, at least if you compare to the window behind. Picture that, but every tier covered in proper brand items like sophie giraffe, Burt's Bees, Safety 1st kits etc. You'd get the idea. I actually didn't see any on the interwebs as big as mine so maybe I should enter the bastard into Guiness Records...

Yes, I am fully aware I have a mental problem here. I cannot go to the doctors about it as our insurance is poo and I can't justify thousands of dollars spend on being told what I already know. I usually control it within my budget, this time I went beyond normal parameters and I do realise that, which I think is a good sign that it is controllable in future. I am so horrified at this I know it has been a sharp awakening.

I love the idea of just giving one thing off the cake, or maybe just the top two tiers? And then give the rest separate?

OP posts:
McHappyPants2012 · 06/03/2012 19:28

www.lilbabycakes.com/5-tier-safari-giraffe-diaper-cake.html

is it something like this

Tirana · 06/03/2012 19:28

It sounds fantastic!

Really even if it's OTT I would just think you were really sweet to have made such an effort.

I would give it this time at this party, when you're invited to another remember to reign it in a bit.

flyingspaghettimonster · 06/03/2012 19:29

I have made them and given to charity before - I donated one last year to a police woman from her dept, and another to a man I picked from craigslist to give his wife when he couldn't afford a gift for her shower. I did briefly consider makinmg it a business, but nobody wants fancy expensive diaper cakes to buy - htey want them to be cheap as possible. People don't want to spend more than about $60 on a cake and I can't bear to make them with dollar tree stuff and useless tat - they have to be useful. Also I am not allowed to earn money here or be in breach of my visa.

I will make a basket of some of the outfits and toys and give that away - I could remove one layer at least like that... great suggestion... it does still need to be big because she knows it is my biggest cake yet and has seen the others... but I could definitely trim it a bit!

Feeling a bit better about this now... maybe it is fixable...

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread