Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to give it to her anyway...

51 replies

flyingspaghettimonster · 06/03/2012 18:46

This is a bit silly and I am long-winded, so I apologise in advance. The brief version for those that don't like to read much is this:- I made a sodding huge diaper cake for a friend and am worried it is far too OTT and will make me look crazy if I give it.

Background:- I am an obsessive gift-buyer and giver, always have gone overboard on every birthday, Christmas etc for my near and dear. Most people are used to it. One of my worst over-gifting situations is baby showers.

So the problem is this:- a friend is having a baby shower this weekend. I like her very much - I don't do close friends, but if I did I would probably make more effort to see her often - she is a lovely person and I know she has wanted this baby for a long time. So I have been planning her baby cake for several months... I wanted it to be my biggest yet. I must have been to 40 shops in the hunt for the perfect items, I wanted it to be full of useful things I found good with my three kids. I also just inherited some money so must confess I spent more than I would ever have spent normally as I wasn't really counting what I spent on each thing... I just bought anything that fitted the theme and that I liked.

Unfortunately, I went totally overboard. She sent an email when I was halfway through building it, asking me not to go over the top or spend too much as it would make her uncomfortable. I felt terrible as I had already done this, but we talked about it and she said she was very excited about the cake, and just didn't want me to think I had to make a big deal because she knows I always do. She said it would be fine, just to promise not to buy anything else. I haven't...

I finished the cake yesterday. I feel sick looking at it - it is like my own personal albatross sat there on the table blocking the light as it pretty much fills the window. I covered a 2ft by 2ft plywood board in silver paint and cellophane to look like a cake board - and the cake hangs over the edges of it :-(

2ft squared at the base, and the same height as my 3 year old. It is crazy. Every inch of it is covered in stuff - 180 diapers are inside, and there are enough toys for a daycare, everything from nappy cream to cool gel breast pads, blankets, outfits, towels, bath stuff... it is insane. I made a list of everything on my computer as I built it, for the 'recipe' - it is 3 pages of word document. 12pt. Single spaced list.

Now I am faced with my creation I can no longer deny my total shopaholic tendencies or obsessive over gifting. It is sat there judging me. I know if I take it to the shower there is no way I can pretend I didn't spend too much - it is very clear that such a large cake with those items has cost hundreds of dollars. I will have to have a friend with a truck deliver it as it is too big for our car. Two people will struggle to carry the fecking thing.

If I take it the shower it will dwarf everyone else's gifts. It will steal attention from everything. I don't want that. It is the sort of a gift the expectant grandmother might give if they were particularly excited about the baby... not something you would expect from a casual friend you see maybe once a month. It was so crowded I had to put the 22 pairs of socks I made into sock roses on a separate wreath for decorating the front door, because there was no space for them on the cake.

What to do? I can't face pulling it all apart and couldn't return half the stuff as tags were removed/been two months since purchase etc. I could maybe save half for another baby shower, but it is all themed to this cake so hard to split.

I want her to have it, but feel I have to apologise and am scared it is going to make her feel forced into a closer friendship than we have right now. I had already made it clear I am happy to help out with babysitting anytime as her husband is Navy so away a lot. I don't want her to think I am forcing my way into her life. It was meant to just show I like her and am happy for her, but it seems to say more that I am lonely, bored, baby obsessed and unhinged.

What should I do? I already think if I do give it to her I will do so after or before the shower, not at it, so it won't be on display when everyone does the gift opening. Probably everything everyone else brings is on the fecking cake anyhow.

OP posts:
McHappyPants2012 · 06/03/2012 19:30

op you need to tone that down alot if it is like the one you posted

HappyCamel · 06/03/2012 19:30

Do, please, split it and only give her some. One of the fun bits of having a baby is shopping for it. In some ways you are taking rather than giving by denying her the opportunity to choose so many of the things her baby will first use, all the early photos will show the baby in stuff you chose, not her.

You have my sympathy though, you have clearly learned a lesson. From now on choose a budget and stick to it.

flyingspaghettimonster · 06/03/2012 19:42

Manicpanic... glad I am not alone in my nuttiness. Wouldn't you feel embarrassed if anyone made an effort for you though? I get very flustered if I am given gifts... I much prefer giving than receiving. Just the thought of getting given this makes me shudder...

I agree that when it gets to the point that I am ashamed of it, it is too far. I also love the itemised price list and fridge idea although I wouldn't want my DH to actually know the real price. I do have it all itemised on my word document though and might have to look at that in future situations.

McHappypants - no, not really like that as you can see all the diapers and I make mine with the diapers hidden inside the blankets, then add the extras on the outside. Although it is jungle themed (monkeys). If I am happy with it afterwards I might upload a picture. Here is a link to the one I made for the craigslist guy. He gave a few items for it with a Winnie the Pooh theme, I bought a bunch of other matching bits and made the cake for him. sphotos.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-snc6/184868_10150212620258636_684228635_9214043_5895685_n.jpg

OP posts:
flyingspaghettimonster · 06/03/2012 19:47

oh - one thing, I never include first baby clothes. Everything is 6months plus. I have been to a lot of baby showers so know everyone always gets newborn and 0-3 months, so I avoided that. Only the swaddlers were 0-6 months. She hates shopping - I went with her on her first baby shopping trip and she really didn't enjoy it or have any interest in looking at the useful stuff, which was why I went with those things.

I can lose 50% of the toys easily... nobody needs that many rattles and teethers.

Does anyone think I could just email her and be honest? I was thinking I could email and say 'look, I went mental on the cake even by my standards, would you like to help me pick out which bits you want to keep and we can give the others to a charity of your choice?'

OP posts:
MadameChinLegs · 06/03/2012 19:48

Why not sell it?

iFailedTheTuringTest · 06/03/2012 19:57

Flying
That suggestion if yours sounds good.

Invite her over th see the beast, have a giggle together at your creation in its glory, let her chose what she wants and the rest go to her favorite charity.

Win win win

Ps I hate shopping and got a massive nappy cake jointly from my 4 best mates, still using stuff from it 2 yrs later, and it was fab not needing to buy towels, weaning spoons teethers etc. To me buying was just a chore I could do without. You sound lovley. Can I be your friend?

hickerybobp · 06/03/2012 21:19

Leave it on her doorstep... Ring the bell... and run....

Coconutty · 06/03/2012 21:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

YusMilady · 06/03/2012 21:30

You sound great, OP. Why not just give it to her. Style it out.

PfftTheMagicDraco · 06/03/2012 22:20

I would take it apart, recreate a modest sized one, and save the other things as other gifts for another time. You will look completely over the top.

Raggydoll · 06/03/2012 22:36

Noooo , you have to give it to her, you went to so much trouble and like previous posters have send the odd friends are the ones we love the best. Sounds like you have a rep anyway so it won't be completely unexpected - I like the idea of inviting her over to see the beast to have a private giggle on how ridiculously ott you have been and giving her the option to select/donate as she sees fit.

emsyj · 06/03/2012 22:45

I would imagine that the issue for her is likely to be that your level of effort is a pressure and makes her feel that she has to reciprocate. If you are able to be honest with her and say, 'look, I really enjoyed making this and I had some money to spend and I have loved doing it, but please don't ever think I want or expect you to do the same in return' then just do that and give it to her - but perhaps privately.

Or contact some of her other friends and ask if they want to club up and put their name on the card so that it's a gift from a group?

crazygracieuk · 06/03/2012 23:05

Can you save any bits for Christmas, mum to be's birthday or after the birth?

HoneyandHaycorns · 06/03/2012 23:14

OP, I think you sound lovely. :) Completely barmy, but thoughtful, generous and kind. It does sound like you might need to work through this issue, not least because of what it's costing you, but I think your friends are very lucky indeed.

I think your idea of sending an honest e-mail to your friend, telling her that you have gone completely OTT and inviting her to take what she wants before giving the rest to charity is a fabulous idea. She will get to appreciate your creativity in all its glory, and she will be able to pick out exactly what she wants. She'll also have a fab story to tell her dc in future years about the gigantic diaper cake that was made for them. Go for it!

And please, please do post some photos after she has seen it! Grin

flyingspaghettimonster · 07/03/2012 02:22

well, I will do after the weekend when I have figured what to do. I appreciate everybody was nice about what a freak I am - I fully expected a good beating with a rattle...

Hubby thinks we should offer the other grad students to go in on it with us and make it a joint gift. If no-one wants to then I will do the other option and have her come see it and decide what to do.

OP posts:
TheCraicDealer · 07/03/2012 02:51

I would either keep some bits by for Christmas and birthdays, or sift through what you have and see what's returnable. I'm sure you still have some receipts! If you're less fussed about the money than apparent social death, then a local charity would probably love such a generous donation. You did it with the best of intentions and sound lovely; how many people would help a randomer they met on Craigslist like that? Don't beat yourself up, but stick to those budgets! Smile

CaoNiMa · 07/03/2012 02:58

Have you thought about maybe addressing your overgifting problem?

ButteryBiscuitBase · 07/03/2012 02:59

You sound lovely op! wish you were my friend. This was done with lovely intent so I'm sure she will be touched. Invite her over to preview it and let her decide if she wants you to bring it.

Seriously there is money to be made here! I have just had a thought, "my big fat gypsy babyshower!" And I'm not even joking!

Aribura · 07/03/2012 03:16

This is a compulsion and you need to get help. I'm sorry but the posters who are telling you that it's nice are trying to be sweet, but they aren't helping you. You risk getting into serious debt if you can't control your purchases.

I go crazy on my other half and love to treat him, but even I wouldn't go to that limit. With my other half. Let alone a casual friend.

CrockoDuck · 07/03/2012 03:18

Awwww....I think you're a total sweetheart. Please don't beat yourself up about this - we all have our little quirks, and as quirks go yours is rather a nice one.

I don't think you necessarily need therapy - but I do wonder if you have self-esteem issues. Over-giving can be a sign of this.

I think what the others have suggested is perfect - 'fess up to her. She's obviously fond of you and knows you of old - and will probably be hugely touched by what you've done. I know I would be - although I'd also give you a bit of a telling off too :)

Aribura · 07/03/2012 03:18

Just to add that hundreds and hundreds worth of stuff is what you win in a big competition, not what you get given as a gift. I'd be uncomfortable if my mother gave me so much stuff.

Everyone else, please stop enabling this behaviour.

CrockoDuck · 07/03/2012 03:22

Actually, having read your post again, I think Aribura is right. You are clearly a lovely person - but your spending is clearly becoming a problem for you, and problems need to be sorted.

Squiglettsmummy2bx · 07/03/2012 03:55

I wish you were my friend! Give her the cake. If you made it for me I would feel so happy to have someone make so much effort. My baby is 4 weeks old now & other than one friend who has been a lifesaver no one did much at all Sad & I would have loved something so thoughtful Smile

Penelope1980 · 07/03/2012 05:00

I think you should keep it somewhere you can look at it whenever you are tempted to go overboard with a gift again. It may be the reminder that you need!

lifechanger · 07/03/2012 05:29

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Swipe left for the next trending thread