Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

arrangements for christmas meal. am i being fair?

57 replies

shelsco · 15/12/2011 23:13

My parents book a panto every year and take me, dh and 4 dc out for a meal afterwards. they pay for everything and it is lovely. we are very grateful as we couldn't afford to do it. usually they come back to our house and socialise for a bit. This year they asked when to book it and we chose a date which we thought would be fine. They said money's a bit tight this year so could we get a take away instead after the panto and of course i said we didn't EXPECT a meal and we would pay for a take away instead (feeling terrible inside and wishing we could afford to take us all out). Now dh's parents have booked a meal for us all on the same date for his brothers birthday. Brother is usually away but has decided to come home this year. Dh wants me to tell my parents that we are going out with his parents that night and to forget the take away and ask them to babysit as well! I feel like this would be using them, to go to panto which they have paid for then disappear, leaving them with the kids! Dh says, as his parents never ask us and my parents always do (they are often here helping out with kids etc) it is unfair on his parents. Aibu? I feel that the reason we see more of my parents is because they are here all the time helping out. His parents do help us too (we are lucky, i know) and we go to theirs either once or twice a week. We hardly ever go to my parents but they come here three times a week (once for a visit and twice because they have come to look after the kids). I am trying to be fair but.... well what do you think? Don't want to snub anyone but in my book, if something's arranged already you can't just unarrange it!

OP posts:
fluffy123 · 16/12/2011 12:31

How about having the meal after pantomime with your parents at your house. Either a takeaway or heat up a few buffet bits and send DH of to have dinner with his family .Asking him to explain you had pre existing arrangements.

GnomeDePlume · 16/12/2011 12:38

Your husband is an ill-mannered oaf and his parents sound no better. I guess that was where your DH learned his charm.

shelsco · 16/12/2011 12:55

Well gnome the way i'm feeling now, i'm inclined to agree with you. Angry I will be honest with my parents, just feel bad for them that's all. They will miss ds1 being there.

Only DS1 is invited as nephew who is close in age is going and they want someone to keep him company!! (Well that's what i think anyway!) but problem is DS1 wants to go as the idea of a grown up meal with the grown ups (he's 13) is very appealing. I think that its rude to invite one dc and not the others. tbh, i think if dh had just told his parents the truth at the start they would have been fine about it and just changed the booking so we weren't included. It's him who's being a shit because his family never go out together and so this is a chance for them to be together.

Don't think his family would be that bothered, well at least not bothered enought to change the night and include other kids!!

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 16/12/2011 13:03

Sorry to be so blunt shelsco.

I find it strange that your DH thinks that it is okay to be so rude to your parents when they help you so much.

I would be ashamed of him and telling him so.

mayorquimby · 16/12/2011 13:07

I'd say it's incredibly rude to go to the panto and then go off for something better while they baby-sit.
I'd try and sort something out so you all can go to the meal or else politely decline because you have already made plans for that evening.

pingu2209 · 16/12/2011 13:16

I think that with any of these situations, you have to go with the person you booked with first. This is nothing to do with parents etc, it is polite social etiquette.

MerylStrop · 16/12/2011 13:17

Your DH is stuck between a rock and a hard place

I think you have to stick with plan A
And DH and DS go out with brother and pils
Everyone's happy enough then, surely?

I would normally say that a pre-existing arrangement trumps any subsequent offer - generally, but it seems like his brother's visit is kind of out of his control and a special exception - you've said it yourself "his family never go out together and so this is a chance for them to be together". Your parents, I am sure would understand, especially if you explained it was all just a bit of a cock up.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page