Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if MIL wants to get to know DS better then she should do so, or stop saying it?

61 replies

stopcomplainingthen · 28/11/2011 12:11

Bit of brief background. I have 3.5yo DS with DH. MIL is definitely of the 'hands off' GP variety. Fine. Not the sort to be chatting to children or take any interest in what they're doing. Again fine.

Despite this backdrop, MIL, since I've known her, has repeatedly lamented how she'd like to her her GC more (DH also has 2 elder children). Until our DS was born, this was easy enough for her to say because DH has limited access to the children. We've offered MIL on many occasions (including before DS was born, and since) that she is free to do stuff with the children/take them out whatever if/when she wants. She has never taken up this offer (btw she is active and able-bodied and doesn't work).

But what is incredibly annoying is that increasingly, she is recognising that DS barely knows here. It has always been obvious to me that he would hardly know her. After all, to him, she's someone who he sees fairly infrequently and when he does, it's over a mealtime in either her house or our's, where the conversation is of an adult nature and tbh, fairly boring.

As I said, MIL has never taken us up on the offer of doing stuff with the children. The only 'together' time she is interested in is either inviting us all up for dinner, or coming down to our's for dinner. If this is what she wants, then fine, but why oh why does she then seem to complain that DS barely knows her Confused.

So for example over dinner yesterday. She was talking about what she'd been doing, film she'd just seen, what did we want for xmas, etc. I mentioned DS had been to the theatre with nursery. She just said 'oh that's nice' and kept talking about adult stuff. Then I mentioned his part in the xmas play and that he was really excited about it. She said 'oh' and kept talking.

Actually in writing this, I think that maybe when she next says this I should say something - maybe that he would know her better if she spent some time getting to know him? But this is likely to cause issues with DH as he doesn't like to 'rock the boat'.

OP posts:
DeckTheHugeWithBoughsOfManatee · 29/11/2011 12:32

I didn't get to know my grandmother till I was 19. To be fair, she was pretty intimidating and we were all terrified of her as children and teenagers including my parents so it did take getting a bit older and finding we had interests in common to unfreeze that a bit.

gramercy · 29/11/2011 12:46

Dh confronted mil with her lack of interest. It resulted in a HUGE fight with fil going mad that dh had upset mil.

The final straw for dh was when he took ds aged 7 to see them and ds was decked out in his new cricket outfit which he was very excited about. Mil did not mention it at all, but started going on, "Oh, cream, yes, I have a new cream blouse. It's a top make you know... we went to John Lewis and......"

As I said, the only result was that fil bawled dh out and mil still didn't get that all that was expected of her was to show a teensy bit of interest in ds.

Mind you, I don't think she'd recognise dd in a line-up of 8-year-olds; in fact I'm quite sure she wouldn't.

Treats · 29/11/2011 14:26

This is ringing a lot of bells with me too.......

My PILs have refused our invitation to come and spend Christmas Day with us - meaning that they'll be spending it alone in their own home. They're turning down the opportunity to be with their favourite son (my DH - I feel REALLY uncomfortable about the blatant favouritism), their lovely GD who's just understanding about Santa for the first time, and their GS who will only be a few weeks old (he was due on Saturday!) and celebrating his first Christmas. The reason SEEMS to be that they don't want to share their precious GCs with the other GPs (my parents).

I hear a lot of gripes about how often my parents see them, but the reason is because my family make a lot more effort. My parents and siblings have all been on standby to help with babysitting when I go into labour and calling every day to see how I am - my PILs chose to go on holiday to India for a few weeks around my due date. My dad made a rare phone call to me to wish me all the best and tell me he was thinking of me - my FIL just said 'Hello Tubby' when he saw me Angry

Previously, the PILs have turned down invitations to DDs birthday party, to join us for a day at the beach about 20 minutes from their home, to come with us last Christmas on a train ride to see Santa. I find it incomprehensible. The only explanation I have is that they have a very narrow definition of what it means to be a GP, and they won't take part in anything that doesn't fit their version of it. But they never offer to take DD out, or babysit, or invite us anywhere. So I really don't know what it is that they expect.

Incidentally, I've occasionally strayed into Gransnet and see quite a few threads there from MILs who think their DILs are keeping their GCs from them. Although there are some genuinely heart rending stories, I'm sometimes totally Shock at the level of entitlement some people seem to have towards their GCs.

Treats · 29/11/2011 14:27

Sorry for lengthy hijack - lots to get off my chest!

EssexGurl · 29/11/2011 14:30

Ask her to look after DS for a specific period of time - say for an afternoon while you go Christmas shopping. My PIL are like your MIL and we don't see them that often but when we do, DH and I make a point of going off shopping or for a coffee for an hour or two to give them time together. If you do this but she makes excuses then, then stop bothering. But I think you need to engineer it to ensure it happens.

TheLastChocolate · 29/11/2011 14:39

Treats I liked what you said about the GPs having a certain pov about what a GC and GP relationship is like and if it doesn't fit their version of it then they aren't interested.

That rings true for my experiences too. :(

Treats · 29/11/2011 14:48

Sorry to hear that Chocolate. Someone else said further upthread that it's what people DO that make a family, rather than what they say, and this rung a bell with me too. Totally accept that different families operate in different ways and that you've always got to make an effort to fit in with how your OH's family operates - but I do think it cuts both ways.

BerthaTheBogBurglar · 29/11/2011 14:54

OP, I think your own suggestion of replying to her moans with "well, what would you like to do about that?" is a good one. She'll probably fob you off with an excuse, or another moan, but if you repeat the same line every time she does it, she'll gradually stop doing it.

It isn't just ILs - my parents are hopeless. They want to view the children regularly but not talk to them or anything. Which is no surprise, given how they were with me as a child. Fortunately my ILs are great, so my dcs have one set of lovely grandparents.

Treats · 29/11/2011 15:46

You just need to watch that this doesn't result in you having to do something that you don't want to do, just to keep them happy. Since my ILs decided that Christmas with us wasn't what they wanted to do, my DH asked them what they DID want to do, so now we're hosting them and DH's brother on 28th December in addition to our own celebration with my family on Christmas Day. Did I mention that I'm due to give birth any day now? So I'm obviously up for hosting two Christmases.........

BerthaTheBogBurglar · 29/11/2011 16:37

Good point. But "No" is a complete sentence. Or you can go for "oh, I see. No, sorry, that doesn't work for us. Oh well, you don't want to do what we want and we don't want to do what you want - guess we'll have to agree to differ!".

Treats, send them a list of jobs that they'll be in charge of when they arrive. Or wait till after the birth and then say "actually, that knocked me for six, I'm really not well enough to host Christmas twice or even once. Change of plan!". Anyone who loves you would accept that ...

stopcomplainingthen · 29/11/2011 19:35

Goodness Treats, I'd nip that one in the bud well before xmas. You'll go nuts. Agree with Bertha, just say no

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page