Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be mad at bossy headmistress about my children walking home from school?

56 replies

Coinky · 22/11/2011 16:33

My children are 9 and 6. They are both very mature, sensible and independent. The school they both attend is a 2 minute walk from our home. There is one small road to cross directly outside the school, however there is a lollipop lady who supervises crossing on this road.

I first allowed my elder child to walk to school alone aged 7 (end of year 3) but didn't let him walk home until about a year later (which the school HATED and would claim he was "nervous" which was rubbish, especially as they asked all the parents to allow their children to walk home alone from an after school activity, including my child who has done this since year 3). I always took the younger child to and from school, until recently when I began allowing him to walk to school with his brother, as it is so close and both are very sensible. I still always picked the younger one up and had noticed recently the elder child had been ordered to wait for me also (which I didn't say anything about).

Last week however I broke my toe. I cannot put much weight on it as it is painful, but also it won't help the healing process if I do. Because of this I am struggling to walk and have to walk on my heel. This is incredibly uncomfortable and also very slow, plus if I knock into anything it hurts and my balance is dreadful, particularly up and down slopes.

I telephoned the school the day after this happened to tell them of the situation. I explained that not only could I no longer pick them up for lunch (they are now on school dinners instead) but I would struggle to pick them up as part of the journey is on a hill. I'll try to explain it better; to get to the school you come out of our door into a small car park and then down a small alley which leads to a hill. At the bottom of this hill is the school. The school entrance is clearly visible from the end of the alley.

So I asked if it would be possible to - instead of attempting the hill - to stand at the end of the alley where the children could see me form school, cross with the lollipop lady, and then walk up to me where I would be waiting. The receptionist was very nice and understanding and thought it would be fine.

However I got a phone call a few minutes later from the receptionist saying she had checked with the headmistress with it and she "wasn't happy with it". The headmistress had said she would allow it for one day only, but the rest of the time I would "have to get someone else to pick them up".

I don't have someone who could do this every day! My partner doesn't finish until 5 every day. He can take a shorter day on Friday but we kind of need the overtime money right now. Besides this is just one day. My mother can also do one day, a Thursday, which is a day she doesn't work and does things with the children anyway. But the rest of the time I don't have anyone who could do this, and anyway I don't understand a.) what the problem is and b.) why she can't talk to me about this herself.

The stupid thing is they allow the children who do after school activities to all walk home alone with permission slips and minus the lollipop lady so it feels very hypocritical. I am not even asking for them to walk all the way home anyway, and they will never be out of my sight. But to be honest it seems a little ridiculous when they are allowed to walk TO school alone. I have seen other children walking home alone as well, and I guess if I hadn't ASKED they would never have said anything about it.

Consequently I was extremely late picking them up, I didn't want to compromise the hill until it was a bit clearer, both due to embarrassment and also safety, my balance is terrible on slopes plus a lot of the children tear out of school and along the paths on scooters yelling "BEEP BEEP" or "MOVE" to anyone who happens to be walking "in their way" - (no parents with THEM I notice).

I really want to rant at the headteacher but I don't now if perhaps it is me that is somehow being unreasonable and would like to hear other outside points of view before making a decision.

-Thanks

OP posts:
jamdonut · 22/11/2011 20:42

Is the school expecting or just had, an OFSTED? Trust me, the attitude will all be to do with "safeguarding children".(Been there,done that,got the T-shirt). Sad

ErnesttheBavarian · 22/11/2011 20:51

it's absolutely bonkers.

my dc walked to kindergarten and back alone (also in Switzerland) from age 5. Now in Germany. ds walks to school alone - 2 roads to cross, 1 with zebra crossing. Almost all the kids walk to school alone, very few parents there, a handful in the whole primary school.

Bizarre world

NotQuiteSoDesperate · 22/11/2011 20:53

OP, I am a lot older than you - left school 36 years ago! But, my own DSs walked to school and back from the age of 6 - we had no choice. I can understand that traffic is worse these days, but it does seem silly to me that schools are being so overprotective.

FredFredGeorge · 22/11/2011 21:35

Why do they (or the council) waste money on a lollipop lady when every child has to be met by an adult anyway? Surely that money would be better spent on something more useful.

jasper · 22/11/2011 22:36

the world has gone mad, partly due to the fact stupid people , encouraged by irresponsible lawyers, will sue others at every turn.

Places like schools have to follow guidelines which are based around watching your back should anyone find an opportunity to sue you.

The head's hands are tied. She probably is perfectly happy for the sensible arrangement you suggested , and won't actually mind you doing as you suggested. She just has to follow procedures.

TroublesomeEx · 23/11/2011 07:54

OP - don't be cross with the school, it's not their fault they've ended up doing this. Behind closed doors they are probably as frustrated as you about the whole situation.

The problem is the litigious society we live in now means that schools are scared to let the children do all sorts of things.

In the time I've been on MN there have been all sorts of complaints about negligent schools - reception children being allowed access to scissors, someone falling over in PE and hurting a toe.

There was a high profile case on the local news a couple of years ago where a teenager on a school trip had ignored the teachers instructions to stay away from the water, there were signs everywhere saying "stay away from the water". What happened? The girl (I think it was) thought it would be a laugh to go for a swim, drowned and the teacher received a 2 year suspended sentence for their troubles.

That is why schools make such a fuss over this sort of thing.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread