Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be less than impressed with SIL letting her DC open presents from us as soon as they arrive?

70 replies

Tenebrist · 24/10/2011 15:36

Bit of background: we live in a different country to BIL (DH's brother) and his wife. They have three DC aged from 5 to 9 who are our DC's only first cousins. DH has a longstanding arrangement with his DB that we will exchange presents for the kids at birthdays and Xmas, but nothing for adults - suits us all fine.

We have to post the packages and we try to post them in plenty of time so they don't arrive too late. It's become clear to us recently that SIL has been letting the kids open their presents as soon as they arrive, well before their actual birthday or Christmas. DH mentioned this to his DB a few months ago and BIL seemed pretty embarrassed and said it was SIL's decision to let them do it.

Now it's clearly up to them what parenting decisions they make generally, and they certainly do a lot of things very differently to us. I imagine they (or at least she) disapprove of certain things we do as well! But letting them open the presents immediately seems to be rather disrepectful of the effort we have gone to in choosing and sending them. We were both brought up with the idea that children should learn to wait for certain treats or privileges rather than thinking they can rip open a present the moment it arrives. We're certainly not fuming about it - it's a relatively small matter in absolute terms, but it leaves us with the feeling of 'why should we bother with nice Xmas prezzies?'.

So, would/do you let your DC open presents immediately if they are meant for another purpose, or would you feel that the present you've sent is being dissed if the recipient doesn't wait.

In the interest of full disclosure: there's always been a bit of tension between SIL and DH/myself in the 15 years since we've known her. We've tried to keep it under wraps for the sake of the children, but I'm not sure here if our feelings about the presents are connected to the dislike we already have for her, or if it's genuinely disrespectful behaviour on her part to open presents straight away.

OP posts:
SheCutOffTheirTails · 24/10/2011 16:52

My DCs always have to wait until the "right day", the poor sods, because DH has a real bee in his bonnet about this. His whole family does.

It's not how I was raised, and I can't see how waiting makes a present any better or more fun. If anything, it turns presents into some big hoo-ha rather than a nice little surprise.

I can't believe you care what happens to presents you send by post, as long as they are received and appreciated.

LoveBeingAWitch · 24/10/2011 16:56

Try thinking if it in terms if the kids will apricate you and your presses more as they won't be lost in the big pile.

MadameCastafiore · 24/10/2011 16:57

Oh dear, thought this was about me!!!

DS's birthday isn't until November and I have let him open his present from SIL as he was with me when we collected it from the post office!!

No harm to aanyone as far as I am concerned.

exoticfruits · 24/10/2011 16:58

I always hide them away to make the day special, but I can't say that I am bothered what others do with things that I send them.

BOOareHaunting · 24/10/2011 17:02

I let DS open presents from his Dad (if he sends them!) when they arrive.

For selfish reasons though that if his father bought him a cheap hot wheels car it would be the 'best thing ever' and probably trump the one thing 'he really wanted!' that I'd saved months for. Wink

Maryz · 24/10/2011 17:12

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

mynewpassion · 24/10/2011 17:26

So really its not about the early opening of presents but dislike of her SIL.

Why didn't you say so in the first place?

colken · 24/10/2011 17:53

I sometimes post appropriately wrapped birthday or Christmas presents abroad. I pack them in a box so that they are unidentifiable on the outside as such and address them to the parents. I know that they will be kept until the event for which they were sent.

banana87 · 24/10/2011 17:58

Does it really matter when they open them? As long as they know who they are from (and write a thank you card if old enough)?

PicaK · 24/10/2011 18:28

I'm in the camp that opening on receipt is more special - makes sure they know who it's from.
BUT - I think your bil is big wimp. Imagine conversation where parcel arrives, sil says "shall we wait or give it to them now?" Bil shrugs shoulders, kids spot parcel from their aunt - all excited, sil shrugs,smiles at her kids and says "oh go on then.

A nice scenario - no evil intent or blatant disregard of anyone's wishes.

But by bil saying "she wanted to do it" it would easily take it out of context.

Maybe I'm being too generous but equally you are letting past history cloud your judgement.

catchafallingstar · 24/10/2011 18:41

You did say in your openIng post that you have slightly different parenting styles - can't you leave it at that?
Maybe they want to 'spread' the gifts out? I know mine get WAY too many all at once (on one day) and by opening when receiving they actually play with the gift and appreciate it, rather than it being under a pile of twenty other gifts and ignored or even forgotten about?

Tenebrist · 25/10/2011 08:10

Maryz "You are no fun "

Sorry for that. I was taking AIBU rather literally as a forum for asking a question which would help me solve a problem, getting an answer, and thinking, oh ok, fair enough. I'd forgotten about its far more important function as a public bunfight spectator/participation sport on a par with gladiatorial combat. [hsmile]

Actually the only thing I objected to was the post calling me controlling, which I don't honestly think is true, but some people do rather leap to conclusions and I think it says more about them than the person they're talking about, TBH.

I'm going to try really hard to think the best of SIL she can't help being a silly cow and BIL he can't help being a wuss for the sake of our DC's relationship with their cousins. Thanks for some of the tips for helping me to see how opening presents early can be meant well or can have positive effects.

OP posts:
marriedinwhite · 25/10/2011 08:27

What relationship do the cousins have anyway when you live in different countries? I think you are over thinking this. Our DC's cousins live on a different continent. My DC would never chose them as friends and I wouldn't encourage it if they did. I don't even send them presents any more as nothing ever came back the other way excpet a message via MIL "next time x says could you make sure if you send a vest it's pure cotton because x doesn't want synthetics next to baby's skin". Not even a personal message so that was the last time I ever sent a present. But I don't get all het up about it or post on here about it.

seeker · 25/10/2011 08:34

But it's so wonderful to get a parcel the post! Are you saying that even if the children are the when the parcel arrives you still expect it to be taken away and hidden til the birthday or whatever? Now that is seriously bizarre!

But you were automatically unreasonable for saying "prezzies".

Maryz · 25/10/2011 08:41

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

JamieComeHome · 25/10/2011 08:43

OP - I'm like you in that I would have my children wait for the event in question before opening the present. This thread has made me see that actually, you could see it as making that particular present more special.

exoticfruits · 25/10/2011 08:45

Just accept that once it goes in the post you have lost control.

scaryteacher · 25/10/2011 08:54

I've just made ds (16) wait for his birthday presents, even though he chose them and was with me when I bought them. He has to wait at Christmas as well.

Mardymwahhaha · 25/10/2011 09:05

I think it's wrong because it makes the birthday less special as there are fewer presents to open. YANBU

MrBloomsNursery · 25/10/2011 09:07

Who cares?!! The point is you send the children presents. Doesn't matter when they open them. It's from you. It's not like SIL tells them the presents are from her or someone else!! Or maybe she does Hmm....

New posts on this thread. Refresh page