Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be less than impressed with SIL letting her DC open presents from us as soon as they arrive?

70 replies

Tenebrist · 24/10/2011 15:36

Bit of background: we live in a different country to BIL (DH's brother) and his wife. They have three DC aged from 5 to 9 who are our DC's only first cousins. DH has a longstanding arrangement with his DB that we will exchange presents for the kids at birthdays and Xmas, but nothing for adults - suits us all fine.

We have to post the packages and we try to post them in plenty of time so they don't arrive too late. It's become clear to us recently that SIL has been letting the kids open their presents as soon as they arrive, well before their actual birthday or Christmas. DH mentioned this to his DB a few months ago and BIL seemed pretty embarrassed and said it was SIL's decision to let them do it.

Now it's clearly up to them what parenting decisions they make generally, and they certainly do a lot of things very differently to us. I imagine they (or at least she) disapprove of certain things we do as well! But letting them open the presents immediately seems to be rather disrepectful of the effort we have gone to in choosing and sending them. We were both brought up with the idea that children should learn to wait for certain treats or privileges rather than thinking they can rip open a present the moment it arrives. We're certainly not fuming about it - it's a relatively small matter in absolute terms, but it leaves us with the feeling of 'why should we bother with nice Xmas prezzies?'.

So, would/do you let your DC open presents immediately if they are meant for another purpose, or would you feel that the present you've sent is being dissed if the recipient doesn't wait.

In the interest of full disclosure: there's always been a bit of tension between SIL and DH/myself in the 15 years since we've known her. We've tried to keep it under wraps for the sake of the children, but I'm not sure here if our feelings about the presents are connected to the dislike we already have for her, or if it's genuinely disrespectful behaviour on her part to open presents straight away.

OP posts:
AMumInScotland · 24/10/2011 16:02

We always tuck birthday or Christmas presents away till the actual date, but I wouldn't consider it rude or disrespectful of others to do things differently. There isn't a single rule on what's "right" in this situation.

In some ways opening your presents when they arrive will make them more remembered and special than having them on the same day as several other presents. They will be quite clear that they are getting their present from "Auntie Tenebrist" and will see it and associate it with you, whereas in the scrum of Christmas day children often can be quite vague about which tag came from which gift, and not really appreciate them fully.

RussAbbotDancer · 24/10/2011 16:03

Oh come off it, OP hardly suggested she expected a gift-earning scheme, just said she was miffed and I think YANBU to be so. We might not give gifts with rules attached but we do give them with expectations. By far the majority of Xmas and birthday presents are opened on Xmas day and on birthdays - I don't think this is culturally relative, bar the odd Christmas eve opening in some places. Gift-giving is nuanced stuff. Consider this: if you delivered them in person in advance of the birthday or Xmas, would she still let the kids open them? Doubt it. BECAUSE SHE KNOWS.

Dozer · 24/10/2011 16:03

YABU, obviously.

But come on OP, please spill, what are the other issues with your SIL? We're all eager to know!

TheFallenMadonna · 24/10/2011 16:04

Yep - this is definitely because you have other issues with your SIL.

Dozer · 24/10/2011 16:05

Russabbotdancer, yes, in OP's defence maybe the OP's SIL is doing this as a passive-aggressive thing to wind up the OP. But would need more info to ascertain whether this is the case .

Georgimama · 24/10/2011 16:06

My brother lives in Australia so we have to post well ahead of time and so do they, and I know that as we do, they save presents until the correct day.

I don't think YABU to have the opinion that presents should be opened on the correct date but it's not an opinion you are entitled to enforce on someone else, nor do I see that opening them early is disrespectful of the effort you have gone to. It's actually evidence that they simply cannot wait, which is nice if you look at it like that.

hardboiledpossum · 24/10/2011 16:08

YABU
"leaves us with the feeling of 'why should we bother with nice Xmas prezzies" So you would punish the children by not giving them nice christmas presents because their parents let them open them early? Bizzare.

Maryz · 24/10/2011 16:08

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ravenAK · 24/10/2011 16:14

I sometimes allow this if it's a chance for the dc to open gifts in front of the donor - eg. we have the same 'kids only' agreement with my BIL & SIL, but they often come to visit in November/early December, bearing Xmas presents. I let the kids open these because part of the fun for BIL & SIL is seeing them do so (& in BIL's case, usually having a go on whatever it is...Grin).

When they've posted things instead I would hide these away until the date, so I suppose I can see where you're coming from in finding it a bit odd that she hands them over immediately.

Definitely not worth getting annoyed by it though.

hauntedstateofmind · 24/10/2011 16:16

Please put me dozer out of her misery Tenebrist!

hauntedstateofmind · 24/10/2011 16:20

None of my family manages to get parcels here on time for the DCs to open on their birthday or Christmas. It had never occurred to me that they might be worrying that the parcels might be being opened early Grin.

LadyMontdore · 24/10/2011 16:25

YANBU - they are birthday and christmas presents - for their birthday's and christmas! Can't believe I'm the only person who thinks it's rude to open presents ahead unless the giver says to 'please open now, while I'm here'. I didn't realise people actually did this.
And yes OP I totally get what you mean about it being a bit disrespectful.

Fifis25StottieCakes · 24/10/2011 16:26

No i wouldn't let mine open them, they would be long forgotten by xmas. I would put them away as they are intended for xmas.

sickofhideousneighbours · 24/10/2011 16:27

I agree with you actually, Xmas presents should be saved for Xmas and birthday presents for birthdays, if our DCs get anything in the post I usually intercept it anyway and put it away for the relevant occasion.

eaglewings · 24/10/2011 16:28

Congratulations on sending presents to your family, only one of my kids 5 Aunts and Uncles ever remembers to do this, and she is often late. They don't even send cards, but I know they all love my kids so I'm not complaining. They do do Christmas though
You say your sil is unlikeable, your bil must have liked her once!!

grumplestilskin · 24/10/2011 16:29

what? why? disrepstful how? we get gifts from abroad and always open when they come! makes them more exciting/special for DS than it would if it were put away for 3 weeks and lumped in with the birthday/christmas pile!

this way he's more likely to remember who gave him what and appreciate it. Too many presents at once is not always the best idea

Tenebrist · 24/10/2011 16:30

Sorry Dozer, I really can't spill the beans on what else went on because the circumstances were pretty unique and would out both of us straight away. Much as I'd like to vent though...

"the OP's SIL is doing this as a passive-aggressive thing to wind up the OP" - no, I really don't think that's the case at all. I don't think we feature high enough on her radar for her to do anything specifically to wind us up - she doesn't care about us enough. And I'm really not wound up or annoyed by it. Perhaps one step down from annoyed, admittedly.

This has been really useful to me, though, in clarifying how my feelings about her generally are clouding all sorts of issues. AIBU is an excellent form of therapy! And normally only my kids get to call me odd!

OP posts:
sickofhideousneighbours · 24/10/2011 16:31

Also it's a good lesson to teach kids, that they can't have everything right now, sometimes you need to wait for things!

grumplestilskin · 24/10/2011 16:34

if you intercept and put it away at the first pass, it it's not really THEM waiting for it though....

Blu · 24/10/2011 16:38

I would make mine wait, afaik it's normal in this English speaking country to save presents for the day, but even within that context YABU to get het up (even to a small degree) about what anyone else does, or to take it so personally that you consider not taking so much trouble.

Which kind of suggests to me that you are capable of contributing a teensy bit to the tension between you!

grumplestilskin · 24/10/2011 16:39

and I just generally cant stand people who give gifts with conditions! I'ld rather not have em and have told people that in the past!

WhoseGotMyEyebrows · 24/10/2011 16:40

I have no idea why this angers you or why you would consider not sending presents just because the kids down wait to open them until the day you think they should open them. This is incredibly petty.

You say that other things have gone on and I get that, but find it hard to believe that it won't be equally as petty.

You seem to like things done the way you do them, open your mind a bit and try to see that not everyone is the same.

I also doubt that your BIL was embarrassed like you say, probably more "oh here they go again, getting upset about nothing and trying to dictate to us how to do things!"

dippydoodah · 24/10/2011 16:42

I would definitely keep them til the right day, but that's just my choice I suppose.

alwayspoor · 24/10/2011 16:43

yabu. I sometimes let my dc do this, is nothing to do with the sender, feelings about them etc. Hmm

RitaMorgan · 24/10/2011 16:45

Utterly bizarre that you would rather not send a nice present than have children opening it on the wrong day! Are you always so controlling?

YABtotallyU