to say, yet again, that Pfish food despite the STUPID name is the best ice cream?

[StealthPolarBear]

Actually you know what this is my thread and so it will be one of those ones where anyone who agrees is instantly in an all-consuming clique, and anyone who disagrees is told They Are Wrong, bullied off the thread and indeed the board

So AIBU?

MMMMMMMMMMmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

Hagan Daaz Baileys Cream is yum, but sicky if you eat more than a bowl full.

Did we cross post DooinMeClanin Do you mean the same one? (and did you eat it all to yourself in one sitting also?) :)

Dulche de leche

The Tesco caramel one? No the bastards ate half of it before I got to it

I made sure I got the next one though because I bought and ate it all while they were at school/work

I could go a tub of it right now, but tesco order not due until next Sunday and all I have in the freezer is tesco finest madagascan vanilla which is a) a bit meh and b) belongs to DH

I will put a vote in for the cinnamon oatmeal, which they seem to have discontinued , now that was ice cream, can't stand phish food for some reason.

Although the strawberry cheesecake and banofee pie hagen daaz are pretty yummy too.

They used to do one called The Full Vermonty, which was pecans and maple syrup. Mmmmmmmm. Nothing's ever come close since for me

You are all wrong with your phish love. B and j fairly nuts and haagen fax strawberryv cheesecake are the winners. M and s do an excellent nutty one if b and j is not around. trust me.

What about Karamel Sutra.

TotallyMissesThatFlavourTiggaxx

YANBU this is by far my favourite ice cream. The little fish make it perfect!

You are all wrong! Coconutterly Fair is the best flavour ever!! Second is half baked.

Cherry Garcia
Phis food
there's a coconut one too but cant remember the name of it.
Half Baked

Mmmmmmmm I'm in heaven.

Fairly Nuts! That's it!

B&J is all over hyped, over priced, over sweet, over sickly, over gimmicky, over ingrediented, over everything. Most bought ice cream is either of that ilk or of the Mr Whippy persuasion. I can't think of a single decent one but I still eat it anyway.

YABU

YABU. choc fudge browny one is best and I should know, I regularly eat a whole tub, only when breast feeding. Didn't touch ice cream for two years between children. Now I've got a new one I'm right back on it

So, is it wrong to eat the whole tub? I find it a bit like a bottle of wine. By the time I've had enough to sate my appetite there's not enough left to be worth leaving, so I finish it (obv not wine while bf)

All this crappy supermarket ice cream talk is making me feel queasy.

Now Cream O'Galloway Chocolate To Die For on the other hand...

(OK so I know it's a niche market being in SE Scotland, but all you B&J lovers just haven't lived)

doh, SW Scotland not SE.
Back of beyond but worth it, good ice cream is worth it, dontcha think?

I love the new coconutterly one - my new fave!

Just reading through the thread: other faves are B&J fairly nuts, HD strawberry cheesecake (i think B&J do it too) and choc fudge brownie.

you are all wrong. Sidoli's Turkish delight ice cream is the best ever ice cream in the whole world.

Closely followed by Phish food, and then caramel chew chew