to say, yet again, that Pfish food despite the STUPID name is the best ice cream?

[StealthPolarBear]

Actually you know what this is my thread and so it will be one of those ones where anyone who agrees is instantly in an all-consuming clique, and anyone who disagrees is told They Are Wrong, bullied off the thread and indeed the board

So AIBU?

MMMMMMMMMMmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

At our local cinema you can have the fish as an extra topping - although it's too ridiculously overpriced to actually do it I do think it's a nice idea.

mmm thanks Grumpla
I actually don't care that they're pre licked, not fussy, me

God I heart phish food! Its half price in the co-op this week and so far I eaten 3 tubs rather a lot!

Oooooh, yes, that marshmallow swirl.

I got a tub once that was about half marshmallow... I cried with joy.

No no no no no no no no no no no. Oh deary me no.

Haagen Daaz Bailey's flavour is the best icecream.

1,000,000 flavours still only available in Canada I think but sounds gorgeous - choc and vanilla ice creams, choc chunks, peanut butter, choc coated almonds...........

I've never had Cookie Dough

The name conjures up a kind of squidgey, floury soggy pastry like flavour
as opposed to Phish food which would probably bring to mind...multicoloured peely skin flakes of ice cream had I not already experienced it.

it's too cold for ice cream now anyway
it should be made illegal unless the temperature is over 23 degrees.

came on here to be distracted from thinking about late night snacks.....failed!

YANBU!

But can I ask. WIBU for convincing my ex, whilst he was drunk, that it contains real fish, just so he wouldn't offer to help me eat it?

YABU

Cherry Garcia FTW

Caramel chew chew and Half Baked are the best. Phish food is good if the other two are out of stock.

And only £2.22 a tub in Morrisons at the moment so way cheaper than own brand crappola even!

ooh yes half baked
In fact I think that every time I start a thread about pfish food I come away with the realisation that I prefer half baked - best bits of both
But I have the memory of a goldpfish so go out and buy more Pfish food

Y
A
B
U

I still can't decide-

I love pfish food, baked alaska, cookie dough, half baked in equal measure, I could happily sit with all four and a spoon.

Ben and jerrys are gods

I have yet to meet a tub of Ben'n'Jerry's I didn't like but this week I have discovered tesco's Caramella.
It lives in a Carte D'or style tub and is exactly like a giant McDonalds caramel sundae. (I ate the whole tub in one sitting)

YABU

Heston's salted caramel popcorn one at Waitrose is my current fave.

But not the phishes though, those stupid phishes.

pish food is nice but cookie dough is far better.

Tesco do a great own brand caramel one.

Kelly's clotted cream is the King (Queen?) of all ice creams.

Phish food for the win. I must admit to singing "I'm gonna get you little fishes" a la Cat from Red Dwarf, every time I open a tub.

Jerry Garcia is a close second though

Prefer the frozen Yoghurt over the icecream

Yup cherry garcia is nicer. Sorry but Phish food is sickly.

I agree on that salted popcorn one, that is just lovely.

The frozen yoghurt by B & J is also great, and low calorie

YABU - Ben and Jerry's is nothing special. I prefer Haagen Dazs Belgian chocolate or Dulce de leche...

I love Phish Food, and DH isn't keen so I get it all, bwa ha haaaa!

www.benjerry.com/flavors/feature/schweddy/
Their new flavour, sweaty balls :o

Dulce de leche...

In my own private universe I would have bespoke Dulce de leche, with twice the caramel.

Ooh balls sounds good. They had a chilli chai type tasted at the B&Js factory in Vermont, that is best avoided.

Hagan daz is too eggy for me.