Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to hate my sister for walking out on her kids

69 replies

Rosyloo · 19/05/2011 02:53

Hi. So i'm 6 months pregnant with my second kid and I could never fathom doing to my kids what my sister did to hers. She walked out on them, and her youngest daugter was hit the hardest. She went into depression for 10 years, all of her childhood basically, had recurring dreams about her mum's funeral, was bullied etc. She seemed to get things back on track- I live in Leicester and she's at university, so I tend to keep track of her via my ex brother in law (her father). Recently I found out that during the summer she miscarried. Now, why she was even pregnant at 18 is beyond me! Anyway, the miscarriage apparently hit her hard, and despite hiding the pain, I know she must be feeling all the crap she felt when her mum walked out. Anyway, recently, as in this year, she had a major health scare and she sunk into a short but sharp depression, and she was told that she could intercalate, but for her, being at university symbolised her victory over her mother, and that she has beaten the odds. She has a few people she can talk to, and I spoke with her the other day for the first time in ages, and I can't help but feel that behind the smile, the pain she feels is still there. Does anyone know how I get through to her on a personal, emotional level. I mean, I've had a student come to me after their mum died recently, but this is very different. Any ideas people? And do I have a right to pass judgement on my sister for this?

OP posts:
Rosyloo · 19/05/2011 18:58

I've just been told she's still living in my birth town! I did a little research! What do i do? Should I try building a relationship with her- my hubby thinks not! Would that be right for my niece? Ahhh too much confusioN!

OP posts:
Rosyloo · 20/05/2011 13:11

I rang my niece earlier..! She was crying and I feel like I made her cry! She didn't want to speak about her mum at first, but then she said that she hated her mum! Not my words! I told her it's ok to feel that way, and then she was like 'but no it's not, the one person I should not hate left me hurt and broken'! What do I say to that? I feel so out of my depth! I am having this child, and I don't want her to feel like I'm leaving her as well! What do I do? Sorry, I don't want to come across so needy! :/

OP posts:
ShoutyHamster · 20/05/2011 13:27

Why don't you think about asking your neice to stand as godmother to your new baby?

Would that be a way to cement your closer relationship now, and to celebrate the fact that despite the rocky past, you and your neice have come to be close and loving family? And to show your neice that you value her as a good person in her own right?

Rosyloo · 20/05/2011 13:36

Ahh that sounds like a really great idea!! I don't know that she'd accept though- she already has 2 Godchildren and 2 nieces herself- she has a big old family! There's no harm in trying though! :)

OP posts:
Selks · 20/05/2011 18:26

Rosyloo, you don't need to feel that you have to provide the answers or solutions to your niece's pain...you wouldn't be able to do that anyway, no one person could. So don't worry if she says things that you don't know the answer to or how to respond to. Just be there for her, give her love, and that will be enough. I'm sure she values the relationship with you, and if she talks about her feelings about her mum then that's going to be helpful for her.

If it's any help, I work professionally with young people who may have suffered abandonment by a parent, and for the young person to have very strong mixed feelings of anger, mistrust and love for their parent is totally normal in that situation. She may benefit from having counselling, if it's something that she would consider.

Rosyloo · 20/05/2011 19:45

Yes, I guess you're right! I think she's more upset that it was her and not the kids that take everything for granted!!! She's always been caring of others, and I just think she's finding it hard to accept it!
I think I'm going to go and speak with the counselling service where I am and get their advice, and possibly tell her that if she wants to take some time out over the summer she can come up here! Ohh..so much drama!

Thanks for your kind advice!

OP posts:
northerngirl41 · 20/05/2011 21:15

YABU - if people were more accepting of not having kids then there would be less unwanted children. Unfortunately as a society we see them as being a meal ticket, "what people do", the inevitable... I hate thinking of kids like that - I want all kids to be truly wanted by their parents and for parents to understand what being a parent is about BEFORE they get pregnant (is that a stupid fantasy?).

And I'm not singling out women in this - men are just as bad, if not worse. If you don't want them, don't have them.

troisgarcons · 20/05/2011 21:24

Now, why she was even pregnant at 18 is beyond me! Anyway, the miscarriage apparently hit her hard, and despite hiding the pain, I know she must be feeling all the crap she felt when her mum walked out.

You dont know anything of the sort .... you are projecting pregnancy hormones onto a situation

I spoke with her the other day for the first time in ages

Well, you've hardly filled a gap in this girls life have you?

You, sadly are looking to validate your role as a 'perfect mother' and using your sister and niece to do this. What will you do if your child gets pregnant at 18? It happens, by default or design, in the best and worst of families.

Rosyloo · 21/05/2011 04:13

I understand what you're saying! I am being selfish, but I want to be there for her now! Is that so bad? I'm about to have a second child, and I understand now how much I should have been there for her when she needed me the most!

OP posts:
Rosyloo · 21/05/2011 20:43

Thank you guys all so much for your kind advice! :D

OP posts:
glassofwhiteanybody · 23/05/2011 19:38

Best of luck with all this. Perhaps try to meet up with your niece and ask her how she would like to take this forward in terms of building bridges with you, and who knows, perhaps her Mum too?

Rosyloo · 23/05/2011 23:36

yeah i guess that does sound like a great idea! I just don't want to come across as over crowding her! I just wish all of this had never happened!

OP posts:
working9while5 · 23/05/2011 23:42

troisgarcons that was uncalled for

Rosyloo · 06/06/2011 00:04

Ok...so update on the situation!
I spoke with my niece recently and she sounds exhausted! She's just finished her exams and is going home for the Summer! Should I invite her to come and stay in Leicester for a while, or should I just continue as we are, taking it bit by bit. I can't help thinking that she is still utterly fragile (even though she says she's fine) and I don't want to push her too far. What are your thoughts?

OP posts:
suburbophobe · 06/06/2011 00:13

Rosy, don't beat yourself up for what you did or did not do at the time, you cannot carry the whole family guilt stuff and what went on with your sister.

None of it was your fault!

Lovely that you are there for your neice now.

SouthStar · 06/06/2011 00:35

Rosyloo, I would try and look forward and go into this new relationship with your niece without the frustration or guilt of everything that went on in the past.

My mum got intouch with her long lost brother about 10 yrs ago, it isnt a happily ever after story. We all tried for years to rebuild some sort of relationship but in all honesty he is a racist, small minded pig so me and my mum no longer have any contact with him but my auntie does. The getting to know eachother stage wasnt easy but these things may help you..... It was easier when we all met in a place that wasnt ours or his iyswim. So days out together so noone felt out of their depth.
Myself and my cousin got friendly (and still are) which gave my mum and her brother something to talk about that wasnt their past or their dad (the reason they all got broken up)

I would say yes to offering for her to visit you but ask it in a way that if she really doesnt want to then she wont feel bad saying no. Like maybe say your always welcome to come and stay here for a little break, that way its out there and she can either make an excuse without blatantly saying no or will happily accept.

I hope it all goes well

Rosyloo · 06/06/2011 20:48

this is such great advice- thank you for sharing your little story with me! It's helped me to gain a little perspective. :)

OP posts:
ledkr · 06/06/2011 21:06

Men do it all the time.

Rosyloo · 13/06/2011 01:01

Ahhh Ledkr so true!! I wish saying that to my niece would lighten her load! Oh well- she's back with her family for Summer vacation now! Hopefully she will be more peaceful there :) Thank you for all of your lovely lovely words and advice

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page