Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Pay for School Damage

59 replies

humanoctopus · 21/03/2011 07:23

My 14 year old ds plays footie at school break time with his friends. No interest in girls at all, just kicking a ball around every break time!

I got a call from the school secretary on Friday to say that he was involved in damage to a car and that we would be receiving a note home with him that day. She couldn't comment on what type of damage, so I was expecting something huge.

Anyway, home he arrives, and hands me the note. Due to over spill, staff cars are now parked in the end of the basket ball courts, and while playing football, my son's game led to a wing mirror of a car parked in this area, being broken. There were three of them playing, so the principal requested that we split the cost of the mirror.

I was so relieved that it was only a wing mirror, I instantly googled the cost, only 30 quid, so getting off lightly.

I popped ten pound (a third of the cost) into an envelope and he will hand it into the office today.

However, at a match yesterday, one of ds's fellow culprit friend's mum came up to me and said that she would not be paying, and hoped I wasn't going to either. Her reason was that they were playing in a basket ball court, and that if cars need to park there, that's their risk, not our problem. There were alot of other parents from the school nodding in agreement with her.

AIBU to pay for my son's part of the damage?
I feel that its important to let him know that you have to have responsibility for your actions, even if it was a mistake, even if the car shouldn't really be there, etc.

I have to go to work now, so will be back later, thanks.

OP posts:
thisisyesterday · 27/03/2011 09:25

maybe they were told to park there!

the fact is, they damaged the car. and instead of trying to blame it on other people they should pay up.

i haven't missed any facts, and I stand by my opinion

OutOutLetItAllOut · 27/03/2011 09:30

So is that not them passing the blame as well? They were told to do it so they did? When was that a decent excuse for something? If its your property its up to you to make sure that you take all precautions to insure its safety. They parked somewhere potentially dangerous, they have to take some responsibitly.

MollieO · 27/03/2011 09:34

I wouldn't have paid and I think you are lucky that the teacher hasnt said thanks for the £10 where is the other £290?! Your Ds did nothing wrong assuming the school hadn't fold them they weren't allowed there. Is there somewhere else they should have been playing football. When I was at school the hard courts were out if bounds for ball games - those were played on the playing fields.

caughtinanet · 27/03/2011 09:36

If the boys were playing in an area where they were allowed to play then much as I might feel sorry for the teacher I don't think I would feel any responsibility to pay.

Would you have felt the same if the damage was £100 or £1000?

I can see why the other parents are annoyed but it would be very childish of them to take it out on you.

thisisyesterday · 27/03/2011 10:00

the cars parked there were presumably told to do so.

it was special circumstances. the car park was full and they were told to use the end of the basketball courts.

the children, on seeing this, should have thought "oh, look, cars... let's play away from there"

not "hey, they shouldn't be there so it doesn't matter if we break something"

thisisyesterday · 27/03/2011 10:01

and i am confused by why adults have to take responsibility for their car and somehow, magically, stop anytrhig ever happening to it

and yet 14 year old boys apparently can do as they please as long as the other person is "in the wrong".

beggars belief.

pointydog · 27/03/2011 10:08

Cars are very easy to spot. The lads should take responsibility for playing too close to the cars.

caughtinanet · 27/03/2011 11:48

Unless I've missed it we don't know exactly how far away the cars were. At my DCs school the car park is only separated from the play area by a fairly low fence and could get damaged at any time but I don't suppose any of the pupils ever give it a second thought and there's no restriction on football.

The boys didn't deliberately damage the car as far as we know, any blame would appear to lie with the school for not making sure that no ball games were played near the temporary car park.

pointydog · 27/03/2011 12:54

Lots of people nowadays look to blame the state/system/employer now and so remove much responsibility from the individual.

Just a sign of the times.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread