Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother 'hopes to god I'm not having a girl'

57 replies

abayababe · 30/01/2011 15:30

First time posting but been a lurker for a long time, please be gentle, I'am expecting number 3, and have a lovely dd and ds aged 4 and 2, have always kept the sex a surprise, so mother was on the phone the other day speculating what I was going to have, due in April, then she came out with I hope to god you are not having a girl, do you know why? beacause X (dd) will kill her just like you used to kill your younger sister and that the age gap would be the same between my dd and this new baby as the gap between me and my younger sister which was about 5yrs, now me and my sis used to kill each other, usual sibling stuff and really only became close in our late teens and we often joke about what we used to do to each other now. Now mother is a bit of a narcissist and probably looking back I did crave attention as a child and my younger sister did get doted on and obviously I acted out alot, but I put that down to bad parenting on their part and hope not to do the same with my kids. I'am just really upset that my mother has this opinion of my dd, she has a very strong personality and is quite fiery but gets on great with her little brother and is very loving with him, this has just been driving me mad all weekend, I just think its a horrible thing to say, if I brought up how upset I was with her and the reason why, she would probably deny she ever said it or accuse my of being hormonal, she just came out with it out of the blue and quite honestly right now I wouldnt care if I never spoke to her again. aibu???

OP posts:
Arneb · 30/01/2011 18:35

McHobbes
I do know that I will never ever tolerate anything approching its likeness in my home. Ever.

That I can agree with whole heartedly - I do not understand why some parents stand back or positively encourage negative interactions between their own DC or DGC.

blueshoes · 30/01/2011 20:45

McHobbes' brother at 13 years old should know right from wrong even if his own parents did not point it out to him. At some stage, the responsibility transferred squarely from his parents to his brother.

It is making excuses from that point on.

EdgarAleNPie · 30/01/2011 20:50

erm yeah. my DD and DS never fight...

runs away screaming

Arneb · 30/01/2011 22:05

blueshoes
It is making excuses from that point on

If he got away with it for x year prior to that is that still so clear cut? I am not saying it is right but parents can and should still intervene still at that age and should have set boundaries prior to that before anyone could start viewing it as 'normal' behaviour in that family.

As an young adult I suffered an unprovoked physical attack from an older sibling while we were both guests in our parents house. Obviously mainly pissed off with sibling but found our parents condoning attitude and criticism of me for being upset about the incident equally annoying and hurtful and unacceptable.

FabbyChic · 31/01/2011 01:17

Not all siblings fight. My sons never did five years difference.

I do believe it is parenting.

abayababe · 31/01/2011 07:21

Ladies I have found your comments really helpful and i think i agree with certain things in nearly everyones postings, I also had three older brothers so I got roughed up along the way a little myself, all fairly normal sibling stuff, likewise between me and my sister, and we very close now, my mother is tactless and likes to play one off the other even to this day, which we joke about amongst ourselves, and most of the time I dont get as wound up as I have this time, but maybe when its my own child that she tries to label, then its a different matter, I can't change my mother but I'am certain i wont be anything like her as a parent:)

OP posts:
cory · 31/01/2011 09:53

I think you are both wrong:

she for projecting her own problems with her children onto a child that isn't even born yet

you for assuming that your parenting will decide everything your children ever do or think

you can set boundaries and you can be a good role model, but you will not be able to control everything they do when you turn your back

having said that, what they do may be absolutely charming

there is no knowing

and fwiw I was far more critical of my older brother than many sisters are of each other- sex or age gap doesn't decide everything, personality counts for a lot

New posts on this thread. Refresh page