Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For being p*ssed off at this unreasonable request?

65 replies

MummikinsOopNorth · 26/07/2010 14:32

My sister and I are close. Always have been really, apart from the usual childhood sibling fighting.

She has teenage children from a previous marriage and they're good kids.

She married a Mexican man 5 years ago and he seems to really dislike us (all her family), is sexist and talks to my neices and nephews like sh*t really. They have tried incredibly hard and have been much more open and willing to accept their stepfather into their lives than I ever would've at their tender ages, and treat him with respect, but he gives nothing but rudeness and disrespect back to them. He has been most rude to me and now when I visit my DSis, he blanks me totally. All because I have told him in the past that he should respect my sister a little more. We basically say hello to each other, and then he will move to another room while I spend time at my Dsis' home.

My sister was recently ill with a virus-type bug and he still had her cooking his meals and never helped once with the housework, so while she should've been resting in bed, she was keeping on top of the house and making him his food. Her kids offered to cook for him so their mum could rest in bed, but he refused to take their offer.

So background bit over, my sister is a doormat, we all know that, all the family have tried to tell her he's such a horrible person but she is in love. She sides with him over her DC, and has fallen out with several family members over them telling her some home truths and suggesting he's a user.

So, the thing is that her DH's mother is now dying in Mexico. He is very close to her and lived with her until he moved to this country. He has little money because he sends the majority of his wages over to his large family in Mexico and they use it for living expenses and food.

As they have very little money and already have loads of debt, DSis has asked me to take out a bank loan for £500 to pay for a flight for her H to go home to see his sick mother. I refused politely, but when I visited her again yesterday she said for me to think about it, and was literally begging me to 'just take time to think about it', so i'm left in a very difficult place. Of course, I don't want to upset my sister. I feel so sad for the situation she is in, and since she got with him, looks so downtrodden and sad. So do I or don't I help her out?

OP posts:
anonom · 26/07/2010 16:06

No way - don't do it. There's a limit to how much you can help somebody. My sister is also married to a kn**bhead and I do totally understand how difficult it is. But I wouldn't lend the money even if he was nice - what if it puts your family at risk of finance problems. It's a very unreasonable request and I think your sister is probably asking for it not because she wants to go but because she is afraid of her husband's reaction if he doesn't get to go.

FindingMyMojo · 26/07/2010 16:18

so he is working then? Buy his own bloody ticket. Hopefully he won't come back. Sounds like total tosser.

I was 13 when my Mum moved new man in - he was a hateful man & she did everything to please him, over & about the feeling of her traumatised children (not traumatised re new man, but because he was a horrible misoginistic fucker). The damage that did to our relationship took years to heal - I'm talking in my 30's!

There's no talking to some people though - I hope she enjoys a break from him (he'll get to Mexico without your help don't worry about that) and realises she's better off without all his grief & issues.

LittleMissHissyFit · 26/07/2010 16:18

sorry to say, but MY money's on BigBadMummy's theory. Sis is just a means to him staying here and earning money to send there. He's treating everyone like shit, cos he's living off them. He's a parasite and a cheating one at that. Tell them you've been refused and there's no cash available at all.

porcamiseria · 26/07/2010 16:24

another NO
NO NO NO

thesecondcoming · 26/07/2010 16:46

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

prozacfairy · 26/07/2010 16:52

If you have to take out a loan yourself for the £500 then I assume you can't actually afford to lend them this money?

Rule number 1 of loaning money: Never lend money you can't afford to never get back. If they're skint they can't pay you back.

YANBU to not lend your DSis this money. You haven't put her in a difficult situation, she has done that herself, with the help of her selfish "D"H.

Lovesdogsandcats · 26/07/2010 17:47

thesecondcoming, could not agree more. You have said in one sentence what I am sure everyone thinks.

AvrilHeytch · 26/07/2010 19:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

CreepyFunbags · 26/07/2010 20:12

I have some sympathy for someone whose parent is dying on the other side of the world, and for someone who may want to send money back to relatives living in a sort of poverty that we can't imagine in the West.

But I still think no, you shouldn't take out a loan for this man.

To be frank, if you move thousands of miles, you have to be aware that this might happen at some point. He should have saved up over the 5 years he has been here and missed out a prior trip in case of a future emergency.

Also, you certainly shouldn't take out a loan for someone else, someone you don't even like or really trust. It's too risky.

RunawayWife · 26/07/2010 20:29

Do not do it, it is his mother it is his problem. He does not sound like a nice person so please do not end up £500 in dept for him

RunawayWife · 26/07/2010 20:33

If he has been here 5 years surely he must be able to get his British passport soon then he can fuck off, unless your sis is too big a meal ticket.

I feel sorry for her kids TBH

nagoo · 26/07/2010 20:44

Agree with secondcoming....

You are a fool if you do. Give it a few days to look like you've tried, then just tell her you can't get a loan.

Bechka · 26/07/2010 21:37

Please do not do it.

I understand you are in a tight spot, and it is awkward, but you simply can't trust this man to pay you back.

If you feel you cannot just say 'no, sorry but that's not going to be possible', then think up something along the lines of 'sorry, I'm unable to get a loan'.

I am sad that your sis is downtrodden, but really, after a certain age, people have to look after themselves. My mum is downtrodden and walked all over too by her awful husband, and it is horrid.

Rockbird · 26/07/2010 21:48

Absolutely no way, don't even consider it. It's not your problem. I would advise against even if he was a lovely bloke but to get into debt for a tosspot, not a chance. Their mess, they sort it.

FakePlasticTrees · 26/07/2010 21:53

Don't do it. I wouldn't lie that you can't get a loan, tell her you won't and that's final.

If you have any spare cash - put it to one side for her DC wanting to go to uni.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page