Plenty of women with "objectively unattractive" faces are with decent loving partners starting families.
I wonder if you'd be better off being more rather than less picky? What made you think someone unemployed was a suitable match for you?
You're corporate and successful and well-educated with good social skills.
There are definitely men who only want to meet women with those qualities.
Its more unusual in my experience to see corporate guys marrying a glamourous shop assistant than with a woman the same professional job status as them.
Its important they have a partner who fits in with their university friends and has comparable earning power.
Dating apps have a lot of weirdos and timewasters for everyone but they can be useful.
For photos, I'd select nice clear natural ones which are as accurate and recent as possible and in similar dress to what you normally wear. Don't wear make-up or take from different angles to minimise your features.
A lot of people are specifically attracted to certain strong features, if you try to minimise them you'll screen out genuine admirers.
I'd ABSOLUTELY highlight your education levels, achievements, and if having a serious relationship, children and a family is the goal.
A lot of men want an intelligent woman to be the mother of their children and will be at the same stage as you so you want to attract those who want the same thing and can move quickly.
They look for a good education, goal-orientated, someone who will fit in with their own professional background.
They're too busy with work to do endless dating so you want the signal to be clear.
Majority of "active users" on dating sites - the guys who message everyone (or the guys who actively chase after women in person) are weird or desperate or looking for women 20 years younger.
Its absolutely nothing to do with your looks or attractiveness.
Everyone gets approached by these guys so just block or delete them as soon as you see they're dodgy.