Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

How people talk about only children

57 replies

oneandonlygreg · 05/09/2024 19:19

I work with children. There's one child that is an only child, and they're also a bit of a handful at times. Nothing awful, they're very sweet, but just quite intense.
What I find most upsetting is how people attribute every negative quality of this child to them being an only child.
Today I've heard "when you realise they're an only child, it all makes sense" and "they've spent all summer with no one to talk to, so they've come back and taken it out on xx" and "their parents try really hard to make up for the fact they're an only child, so that's why they're like this".
It's not just this situation, I've noticed a trend.
I worry for my child as I have been told I can't have any more children. Why do people treat only children like they're some kind of alien. There are other children I've encountered who are much worse behaved that have siblings.
Has anyone else noticed this?

OP posts:
ramonaquimby · 06/09/2024 12:00

LeontineFrance · 06/09/2024 10:40

Horrible woman said to me recently 'Shame you only having one child'. Joke is only children have all their parents' attention, have been language skills, have a better awareness of self protection (they don't have anyone else to fall back on), are more discerning in their choice of friends and situations, again from being able to make better choices, tend not to get so involved in needing other people because they have had to survive on their own, may be introverted, benefit from parents' good fortune and not having to share with numerous siblings, may be more willing to compromise in a marriage and thus get a better deal. etc, etc. How do I know because I am one, have one, and am married to one! We are all happy, well adjusted and successful and yes, virtue signalling!

But you're just doing the same implying all the negative attributes of families with more than 1 child!

I think it's all bollocks myself. People are individuals, shaped by their upbringing whatever that might look like.

twoforj0y · 06/09/2024 13:04

It's the same shite for second child, or eldest child stereotypes. Or even girls v boys "boys don't get bullied, they sort it out themselves"... a second child is not a competitive child, oh on and on...

BobbyBiscuits · 06/09/2024 13:10

I was just talking to my mum the other night about how much I loved being an only child. I never ever felt my mum's attention was on anyone else so I didn't have to compete. I lack competitiveness as a person generally. I love sharing things and I think when I was little I never felt different BC I didn't have siblings.
I did feel different BC of my parents being much older. But that's nothing to do with it really. I did have a brother and sister who died during childbirth, they would've been 15 and 20 years older. But I always think if they were here then I probably wouldn't be. But that doesn't bother me at all. I'm just really happy my mum got to have a child as that was her greatest wish.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

LeontineFrance · 06/09/2024 13:20

ramonaquimby · 06/09/2024 12:00

But you're just doing the same implying all the negative attributes of families with more than 1 child!

I think it's all bollocks myself. People are individuals, shaped by their upbringing whatever that might look like.

Implying - for you because that is what you want to read into it from your own background and experience. And, no, people are definitely defined by their upbringing and heteroglossia that they bring with them to each situation. Why do you think there are so many screwed up individuals in our world?

DitchTheDodo · 06/09/2024 13:51

I'm struggling with this so much at the moment - my daughter is 3 and the comments are coming thick and fast. Most of her nursery friends mums are pregnant or just had another baby. I had such terrible PND that the thought of doing it all again fills me with such dread but I also feel dread at the thought of her being bored and lonely her whole childhood like some people claim she will. Or that I 'overcompensate' to make sure that she isn't and that makes her spoiled.

LostittoBostik · 06/09/2024 14:20

DitchTheDodo · 06/09/2024 13:51

I'm struggling with this so much at the moment - my daughter is 3 and the comments are coming thick and fast. Most of her nursery friends mums are pregnant or just had another baby. I had such terrible PND that the thought of doing it all again fills me with such dread but I also feel dread at the thought of her being bored and lonely her whole childhood like some people claim she will. Or that I 'overcompensate' to make sure that she isn't and that makes her spoiled.

She won't be lonely or bored. She won't know any different. You can't miss what you've never had. I'm and have always been a perfectly happy only child. And I am much closer to my parents as an adult than most of my friends with siblings.
Yes there are drawbacks but there are equal benefits, just like any decision in life.

Alexbob · 17/09/2024 11:20

I'm generally resilient but I find it difficult when people say thoughtless things. I didn't intend my child to be an "only child", but lost three pregnancies and the window has passed now (he doesn't know this - I'm not sure if he ever should? He was desperate for a sibling and I think it might cause him pain). But even if I hadn't wanted more it's OK for him to not have siblings - families come in all shapes and sizes.

Anyway, my point is, as well as just generally minding their own business, people need to think about the wounds they might be opening when they spout daft opinions about only kids!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread