Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

MIL’s One Upmanship

60 replies

Whatashittyweek · 22/10/2023 14:15

My mother in law is very lovely however there is one aspect of her that drives me mad and it’s regarding grandchildren.

My child - let’s call her Madge, and my nephew, let’s call him Harold (yes I know it’s neighbours reference but wanted to use names so different)

Harold was born 6 weeks before Madge. At this point, in order not to drip feed, Harold was born after a horrible tragedy in our family. That’s as much as I will say but I’m not sure if it’s relevant to this scenario. It had also taken me & DH several years and multiple rounds of IVF to yet pregnant.

sorry that was a lot of background, but the issue I have is that my mother in law is cannot hear anything good about Madge without saying that Harold does it better. So for instance, Madge can now ride her bike without stabilisers, oh Harold did that 2 months ago. Or Madge is doing really well at school, teacher says her writing is amazing for her age, MIL then says oh Harold’s got really good handwriting too - she never says oh wow Madge thats brilliant well done!

It’s tiresome. My sister in law never makes such comments and always gives lovely praise without boasting about DN. And vice versa, I praise Harold without bragging about Madge.

There’s a million more examples but they’re all in the same vain. I feel it’s quite sad. DH has suggested saying something to MIL, I want to but wonder wherever it’s just worth letting it go.

MIL see’s Harold much more than she see’s Madge as we live about 60 miles away.

does anyone else’s MIL do this? Would you say something or just let it go over your head?

Harold & Madge are currently 5 years old

OP posts:
cherrybakewell24 · 22/10/2023 21:22

This thread has made me laugh with the drinking game reference because at Christmas DH and I (initiated by me!) take a swig of our drinks every time MIL mentions SIL or DN, last year I was half cut by 8pm Grin

Catkitdog · 22/10/2023 21:22

This is my biggest bugbear we have exactly the same situation with SIL being golden child and this her children are constantly compared to my DC. We couldn't celebrate our child taking his first crawl because the other grandchild hadn't yet started crawling. It drives me bloody mad! Me and my DH have agreed to maintained relationships for the wider family (his siblings make an effort with our child, not sure if they notice the obvious favouritsm or not) but if my child starts to notice/ask why grandma favours his cousin or spends more time/does more for cousins then we will speak up and distance ourselves. I don't want our child having emotional difficulties. @Ohgetreal your situation would however make me so angry I'd have to say something!!

Whatashittyweek · 22/10/2023 21:27

It’s sad that this happens to so many people. Madge had her first parents evening last week. She’s settled in amazingly, her handwriting and understanding of words/phonics is really quite advanced. I want to shout it down the rooftops but of course I haven’t mentioned it to MIL. I’m sure she’d be thrilled but I know she will immediately tell me how Harold did in his first parents evening.

I do have other Nieces & Nephews but they are much older. Part of it is I’m sure that there is only 6 weeks between them

OP posts:

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

SiouxsieSiouxStiletto · 23/10/2023 07:24

You can of course celebrate how well your DD has settled and you can tell people how pleased you are. Just not to "D"MIL or the other school Mums Wink

thistimelastweek · 23/10/2023 07:28

SaracensMavericks · 22/10/2023 16:16

My grandma used to do this - when my mum said something about me or my brother she'd start mentioning our cousins. But my mum later found out that she did the opposite too! (So she also bragged about me and my brother to my aunt.) In other words she was really proud of all her grandchildren and couldn't stop talking about all of them! Could it be something like this going on?

I think I'm that Granny!

ilovebagpuss · 23/10/2023 07:54

You could always tell her the gossip about your friend who has gone no contact with her MIL (gosh it's awful) because of the endless favoritism to other DGC.
Now their children are older it was so damaging and they felt it was for the best.
Have you ever come across this MIL? What would your generation think?
More tea?

mrsbyers · 23/10/2023 07:59

According to my own mother children of daughters are much more precious than children of sons , shame that as he daughter has given her no grand children at all

SiouxsieSiouxStiletto · 23/10/2023 08:00

Well don't be @thistimelastweek. It's not endearing in the slightest Wink

Marylou2 · 23/10/2023 08:07

A similar situation has been the cause of much hilarity for 20 years in our family. We also have Harold bingo like a previous poster. Even open sarcasm has failed to stop MIL. Just enjoy it as a family joke.

Whitepeacelily · 23/10/2023 09:23

I would stop telling MIL and don't give her the opportunity to do this and you will no longer get irritated. Just say she is settling in fine or doing fine whatever milestone she is achieving. Just withdraw and withhold that info.

Something else to consider...
If you have always been are very effusive in your praise of your child, maybe she feels you are saying your DD is better than DN so is saying DN can also do that.

Either way, I would stop doing it and withdraw from the competitive convo about the DC.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page