Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Can we help the birds and insects?

108 replies

LuckyPeonies · 23/06/2023 19:17

This article makes me so sad, and angry as it’s mostly caused by habitat destruction, use of pesticides and herbicides, and profit-driven farming practices, with climate change an additional factor.

I know so many people who poison everything with pesticides and herbicides for their stupid ‘perfect’ lawns and plants and don’t let anything naturalize, even if they have enough space.

If all of us who are able do the best we can by supporting farmers who maintain responsible farming practices, refusing to use poisons ourselves, providing safe habitat when and where we can, planting natives for food and shelter, etc. we may be able to make a meaningful difference by providing pockets of safe habitat for birds and insects.

To that end, we leave dead trees (that are far enough away from structures on our smallish property) for the woodpeckers and owls, maintain several water sources and daily bird seed, and grow wildflowers and native grasses to provide insect habitat. It takes maybe 5 mins a day to put out bird seed and renew 5 water containers, so easily done and one can encourage children to help.

We also keep wood piles (from branches and shrubs) for the wrens and other birds, plant natives that provide food and shelter, host barn swallows who return every year to nest in our entry, encourage other birds to nest by maintaining bird houses, and keep our cats indoors when we can’t supervise them.

Those who don’t have a garden could grow pesticide free outdoor plants (and provide bird seed and a water source for birds, if suitable) on a balcony for insects.

Perhaps if all of us who love birds and nature band together and defy the chemical lawn and perfect plant expectation and support farmers and businesses with the same mindset, we can make a very positive difference. Because once they are gone, we cannot bring them back and future generations will be much poorer for it.

copied & pasted because of the paywall:

Bird Populations Are in Meltdown

Humans rely on birds to eat insects, spread seeds, and pollinate plants—but these feathered friends can’t survive without their habitats.Chris Baraniuk

Jun 20, 2023 1:15 PM

Photograph: Getty Images

Every night, Alice Cerutti falls asleep to the sound of birds singing on her rice farm in the middle of the Italian countryside. In the morning, the voice of the black-tailed godwit, a bird whose numbers are declining globally, wakes her from sleep—a little harshly. Cerutti imitates the bird’s over the phone and laughs. “Her sound is a bit annoying,” she says, though she quickly adds, “I really love her.”

Cerutti has turned her 115-hectare rice farm, exactly halfway between Milan and Turin, into a conservation project. During the past decade or so, she and her family have planted thousands of trees, reestablished wetlands, and brought in experts to help study and manage the precious birds that nest in areas Cerutti has set aside for wildlife.

It seems to be working. “We have this amazing and big responsibility,” Cerutti says as she explains that her farm is the last recorded regular nesting site of the black-tailed godwit in Italy. Local researchers found the bird clinging on there even as it disappeared from other locations.

Half of the world’s 10,000-odd bird species are in decline. One in eight faces the threat of extinction. This problem has been worsening for decades, which means scientists have been able to estimate roughly how many fewer birds are around today than, say, half a century ago. The numbers are startling.
There are 73 million fewer birds in Great Britain alone than there were in 1970. Europe has been losing around 20 million every year, says Vasilis Dakos, an ecologist at the University of Montpellier in France—a loss of 800 million birds since 1980. And in the US, just shy of 3 billion individual birds have disappeared in only 50 years.

“We are seeing a meltdown of bird populations,” says Ariel Brunner, director of BirdLife Europe and Central Asia, a conservation NGO. Loss of habitats, the rising use of pesticides on farms, and, yes, climate change—these are among the factors to blame. Even if you are not a birdwatcher, the loss of birds impacts you. Birds regulate ecosystems by preying on insects, pollinating plants, and spreading seeds—by excreting them after eating fruit, for example. We all rely on healthy ecosystems for breathable air, the food we eat, and a regulated climate.

The disappearance of birds is staggering. But Cerutti and others are trying to make a difference. In total, she has earmarked around a quarter of her farmland as a nature reserve. Six and a half hectares, for instance, are now woodland. If you view the farm, called Cascina Oschiena, using the satellite imagery on Google Maps, she says, you’ll see a wedge of dark green trees—alone amid the huge sea of rice fields that belong to her and her neighbors.
Cerutti has dispensed with pesticides and allowed vegetation in wetland areas to regrow. Besides the black-tailed godwits, there are bitterns and lapwings—both also in decline.

And no, she doesn’t make as much money as she might if she were driven to maximize profits on the same tract of land. It doesn’t matter. “Not every farmer can do what we’re doing, but I think that it’s important to do something,” she says. A neighbor was recently inspired by Cerutti’s efforts to stop spraying places that border her farm with glyphosate, an incredibly potent herbicide. “I think it’s a great step,” says Cerutti.

Speak to birdwatchers and researchers elsewhere in Europe and you’ll hear many examples of birds that were common just a generation or two ago that are now on the edge. Take the corncrake, whose song was once heard frequently across Ireland. There are now just a few hundred individuals left in a handful of locations.

“To be utterly frank, the situation is pretty awful,” says Rob Robinson, a senior scientist at the British Trust for Ornithology who is based in East Anglia. He mentions the willow warbler. Robinson has been putting rings on the legs of these little birds and releasing them, a common monitoring technique, for years.

“We catch one or two a year instead of 15 or 20,” he says, explaining how things have changed since he started the work. He also remembers seeing flocks of finches on farmland as a child. “Those I see very rarely these days.” Nightingales and turtle doves also used to be plentiful around the British countryside in spring. Now they are all but gone.

Brunner adds: “We are not losing just the birds, we are losing the insects, reptiles, amphibians, a lot of plants. We get very, very simplified and impoverished ecosystems.” That means it can be easier for invasive species to spread, he says. Crops become more dependent on chemistry and human intervention—and also more susceptible to diseases.

There’s also what Brunner calls the “moral issue.” Sights and sounds that have been part of the landscape, and of human culture, for millennia are suddenly fading away. Turtle doves are mentioned multiple times in the bible, he notes.

The single biggest cause of the decline in bird populations, he says, is the intensification of farming. High pesticide use, the loss of hedgerows and margins where insects and birds can live, and hyper-efficient harvesting are all problematic. Robinson says that around 70 years ago it was common for wheat farmers to leave 1 or 2 percent of their crop on the ground in fields.
“That doesn’t sound like very much, but if you add up large areas of farmland, it can sustain large bird populations,” he says. Technology and harvesting practices have become so good at catching every grain that this food source just isn’t there anymore.

In May, Dakos and colleagues published a large study in which they analyzed 37 years of bird-population data from 20,000 sites across 28 European nations. The team considered the growing size of towns and cities, the loss of forested areas, temperature rises, and the intensification of farming as key factors. In the researchers’ analysis of population trends for 170 bird species, all of these anthropogenic pressures had some impact, but it was intensive farming that appeared to have the strongest correlation with plummeting bird numbers. All over the dataset were struggling farmland bird species.

“We weren’t expecting to find such a strong result,” says Dakos. Farmland birds declined by 56.8 percent between 1980 and 2016, he and his colleagues estimate. The next most quickly declining group, urban species, fell by 27.8 percent.

Although this huge research project underlines some of the problems birds face, we’ve known about these issues for many years, says Amanda Rodewald at the Center for Avian Population Studies at Cornell University in the US.
“We’ve known enough for a long time to actually take active steps,” she says. “Our failure to do that has reflected that there hasn’t been a collective and strong will to act, in my opinion.”

There are ways to help, however. Countries can make tax or other financial incentives available to farmers willing to protect and encourage wildlife on their land, for instance. Consumer demand for more ecologically sustainable products can also have a positive impact, she says.

In California, some rice farmers are being paid to delay the draining of their fields in late winter to protect breeding areas used by wading birds. The project, called BirdReturns, has been running successfully for years. It targets areas deemed of greatest conservation benefit to bird species. Those areas were originally identified by citizen science bird-monitoring data from Cornell’s eBird app, Rodewald says.

“People are recognizing that we need to take some steps with the way we use resources and manage our planet,” she says. Despite the current bleak outlook, Robinson also maintains hope for the future because efforts to save birds appear to be growing.

Cerutti’s experience, though localized, speaks volumes. In just a few years, she has transformed multiple hectares of land and embraced wildlife—despite having known little about birds just 12 years ago. “The amazing thing is,” she says, “when you give back to nature, she really grabs it right away.”
https://www.wired.com/story/bird-population-decline/

Black-tailed Godwit (Limosa limosa) - BirdLife species factsheet

http://datazone.birdlife.org/species/factsheet/black-tailed-godwit-limosa-limosa

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Tootsey11 · 23/06/2023 19:25

It doesn't take much time to do a few simple things that will improve their lives. Unfortunately a lot of people simply don't care enough.

frozendaisy · 23/06/2023 19:34

Plastic grass is all the rage around us. We are a tiny haven of natural let it grow garden but it feels like pissing in the wind.

frozendaisy · 23/06/2023 19:36

People have to want to care. Too many want us to coo at the plastic grass "because it looks good all year round", and their new acrylic nails and all sorts if you attempt to point out "erm the planet is crying out for help" they blank you. Then moan food is expensive and it's too hot.

Lucanus · 23/06/2023 20:19

It is the habitat improvements that are vital here. Putting out bird food just makes the problem worse. It mainly benefits the common species that are doing fine (blue tits, great tits, great spotted woodpeckers etc) at the expense of rarer and more specialist species that get outcompeted for food and nest sites.

It also benefits invasives like grey squirrels and rats, and spreads avian diseases such as trichomonosis which is causing declines in greenfinch and chaffinch.

lifesabitchandthenyoudie · 23/06/2023 20:25

I'm with you op. It makes me so sad (would make me mad if I let it but I can't allow it to for my health). We try to leave our patch as untouched as possible, and yes it's not quite as 'nice' as I'd like it due to my health, but it is a haven for insects and birds. I get 'jokey' comments about the state of it but I don't give a flying fck because the gold finches come to us for the dandelion seeds, etc!

LuckyPeonies · 23/06/2023 21:53

@tootsey11 I agree that too many people don’t care, but I do know many of us do want to help and make a positive difference.

@frozendaisy That horrid fake grass is trying to take hold here. It is infuriating, not only is it terrible environmentally by destroying yet more habitat, but it also adds so much plastic to landfills. All for nothing. But I suppose at least people won’t spray it with pesticides/herbicides.

@lucanus i do understand your concern, but i think feeding can be done responsibly. With habitat destruction and insect decline food is often scarce for birds. We have 2 feeders which are regularly cleaned and filled with food for various species, sunflower seeds, walnuts, nijer seed, etc. We also grow thistles and sunflowers and the birds come harvest those.

We do get squirrels who feast on nuts, but they are a native species. I do keep an eye on avian illness reports and stop feeding when we are advised to do so.

@lifesabitchandthenyoudie Same here, the chemical lawn brigade dislike the wildflowers and general naturalized appearance of our yard. Don’t care one bit as we don’t have an HOA which can terrorize us.

OP posts:
Babdoc · 23/06/2023 22:17

My late MIL and I both used the environmental argument to excuse our rather wild gardens! I actually like to see buttercups, speedwell, clover and daisies sprinkling my lawn, it gives a nice meadow feel to it. And my unkempt roses, cotoneaster, oregano, buddleia and lavender seem to attract plenty of bumblebees and butterflies. I have a large compost heap which is well colonised by woodlice, centipedes and worms. A pair of rather dim thrushes nest in the honeysuckle each year, and I have a whole flock of sparrows who shout abuse at each other in the shrubbery while the wood pigeons engage in domestic violence on my roof. My plum tree and large thornless blackberries attract loads of wasps, which I am less keen on but tolerate.
It would be very dull to just look out on plastic grass - the stuff is an abomination.

Lucanus · 23/06/2023 22:21

@LuckyPeonies Bird feeding is actually contributing to national declines in threatened bird species such as marsh tits and willow tits. Increasing the number of common species like blue tit and great tits is of no conservation benefit at all when this has the knock-on effect of displacing rare species. This can happen well away from your garden... birds will travel over 1km to visit feeders, probably further.

I'm also sceptical that cleaning feeders can go very far towards preventing disease transmission. Fundamentally, it's very unnatural to bring together large numbers of individuals of multiple species as feeders do and it's an obvious mechanism for the spread of infection.

LuckyPeonies · 23/06/2023 22:47

@Lucanus Oh, I see. What about water sources?

@Babdoc Your garden (and your late MIL’s) sounds a wonderful wildlife paradise. There should be no need to excuse environmentally sustainable gardening, it should really be the norm!

We have 4 compost towers (fashioned from border edging). Can’t believe I didn’t think to mention them as good for birds, they attract lots of activity. The blackberries do attract wasps, but also lots of birds feasting on various bugs (and the berries 😀).

OP posts:
Lucanus · 23/06/2023 23:00

@LuckyPeonies I don't know if bird baths are implicated in disease transmission - I suppose ideally you'd have as many water sources as possible so the birds spread out more, plus change the water frequently in any that are well used.

I think it's much less of an issue where you are supporting birds through providing good quality habitat with plenty of insects, weed seeds etc, unlike the very high densities you can get around feeders.

I think the other factor that is often overlooked is that birds provide a good indicator of habitat quality. So having lots of birds using your garden is a sign that it's got good habitat that will also be supporting many other species such as insects. Conversely, a lack of birds should be a sign that the habitat is poor and could be improved. Attracting them by feeding breaks that link.

lochmaree · 23/06/2023 23:10

@lucanus Thank you that is really interesting. I have fed the birds through the winter but had to stop this spring as it was attracting rats which we hadn't previously had a problem with. I have naturalised my garden much more though, I have a pond now which attracts birds, and my 'vegetable patch' is very overgrown and there are often blackbirds, Robins and wrens digging around in it. I've also had far less issue with slugs...

lochmaree · 23/06/2023 23:13

@lucanus I also grow things that birds eat the seed of, I grew loads of linseed last year but it hasn't reseeded unfortunately! so none this year. I have perennial sunflowers, oats (as a weed I suppose!), general weedy plants, raspberries 🐦‍⬛, cotoneaster.

LuckyPeonies · 23/06/2023 23:36

@Lucanus Thank you, that makes sense. The water sources are changed daily.

What about winter feeding though? Not many insects, and not many plants producing food in mid-winter once berries etc. have been devimated.

OP posts:
dubyalass · 23/06/2023 23:40

People have a perception of the countryside as being a place where nature thrives. Up in the uplands, perhaps, where it's harder to farm intensively, but in the main those acres of green fields are devoid of biodiversity. Farmers grow monocultures of crops and most permanent pasture is ryegrass that's reseeded every few years; compare that with the meadows of old which had lots of different species. But species-rich meadows aren't much use for silage for dairy cows. Thousands of miles of hedges were grubbed out when farming intensified and much of what remains is gappy and little use for wildlife, or is flailed back on all sides each year. Much easier to spray large fields than small ones, especially with the huge machinery you see today.

Something's got to give, but in the age of ever-increasing demand for cheap food, it will be nature that suffers. I hear a lot about food security, but climate change is affecting crops too (ask any arable farmer), and pests and diseases are evolving resistance to chemicals.

dubyalass · 23/06/2023 23:43

My point being, we can do bits in our gardens, but the choices we make in our weekly food shop will make a much bigger difference. But we're in a situation where many people don't have a choice.

LuckyPeonies · 23/06/2023 23:46

dubyalass · 23/06/2023 23:40

People have a perception of the countryside as being a place where nature thrives. Up in the uplands, perhaps, where it's harder to farm intensively, but in the main those acres of green fields are devoid of biodiversity. Farmers grow monocultures of crops and most permanent pasture is ryegrass that's reseeded every few years; compare that with the meadows of old which had lots of different species. But species-rich meadows aren't much use for silage for dairy cows. Thousands of miles of hedges were grubbed out when farming intensified and much of what remains is gappy and little use for wildlife, or is flailed back on all sides each year. Much easier to spray large fields than small ones, especially with the huge machinery you see today.

Something's got to give, but in the age of ever-increasing demand for cheap food, it will be nature that suffers. I hear a lot about food security, but climate change is affecting crops too (ask any arable farmer), and pests and diseases are evolving resistance to chemicals.

Yes, plus no more crop rotation and, as mentioned in the articles, efficient harvesting which leaves nothing behind for wildlife.

And increasing droughts which dwindle water sources and make growing crops impossible, which will lead to more climate refugees.

But we need to remain hopeful and keep trying, because hopelessness leads to apathy and no more effort.

OP posts:
Lucanus · 24/06/2023 08:46

@lochmaree That sounds great, you should be getting lots of insects etc too I'm sure.

@LuckyPeonies It might sound harsh, but winter food shortages are an important part of nature. Birds have evolved ways to cope with this including migration and, for Marsh Tits and Willow Tits, food caching and detailed territorial knowledge.

These specialist species rely on the fact that winter limits the numbers of generalists such as Blue Tits and Great Tits, which means they have plenty of opportunities for breeding in the spring. When we provide year-round food abundance, we negate their advantages and they get outcompeted by the generalists for food and nest holes.

Mothwingdust · 24/06/2023 08:55

We have the sort of urban garden you would like op. It has two large trees in , one neighbour hates them. They do not shadow her garden but the leaves fall in and go on her plastic lawn and she has zero plants and complains it looks messy. We have a mature hedge down one side, I think it must be about 50 years old and lots of shrubs inc a huge ancient lilac. We also have a pear tree in and I do hang a feeder in and will now remove it having read this thread so thanks for that tip.

I think the world population of humans is just too big now, that’s the bottom line.

Orban · 24/06/2023 08:58

Buy organic, boycott supermarkets and stop getting cats and dogs.

Tipintorecession · 24/06/2023 09:13

I'm struggling not to feel hopeless I must say.

To mitigate my overall desperation at the situation I'm very lucky to have an acre of garden which is full of birds. Far fewer insects this year though. I've seen ONE ladybird 😞. Gaia is going to just flip us totally sometime soon, it's heartbreaking to think about.

Scrowy · 24/06/2023 09:32

To offer a small amount of hope, the new post brexit farming subsidy schemes mostly attempt to correct some of the issues around arable farming and incentivise the creation of wildlife habitat.

It's been less good news for upland farming who are also losing the traditional subsidies but can't access the new versions because they are mostly already doing it naturally.

I stood out in my (farm house) garden and the birdsong is so loud at the moment around the house as some of our sheep got in and destroyed the garden but the chaos and dung they have left behind, plus a bit of rain has lead to explosion of flies and worms and the birds are loving it!

In the evenings I can hear the warning cries of the curlews protecting their chicks. We hear owls screeching away all night. We hear the peewits at various times of day. We have golden plover as regular visitors in the fields, there has been an absolute explosion of voles this year. For the first time in a while there's been a hen harrier hanging around as well as the usual buzzards, kites, peregrines and kestrels.

I saw a lizard a couple of days ago running in and out of the barn walls and newts, frogs and toads are regularly evicted from the house where they seek respite from the heat we've had (I rehome them in an nice dark damp barn that has a stream running behind it.

The hares, the field mice and the voles are eating what's left of my garden after the sheep took all the tops off.

It's all good here. Apart from my poor garden.

Scrowy · 24/06/2023 09:42

I've just been out and used the merlin app for a few minutes (it's fascinating by the way - highly reccommend)

Swallow
House Martin
Blue Tit
Willow Warbler
Mistle Thrush
Song Thrush
Wren
Blackbird
Robin
Jackdaw
White Wagtail
Great Tit
Chaffinch
Goldfinch

The only one I'm not sure about is the white wagtail - It's what I've always called a pied wagtail.

I also saw a flycatcher while I was out but the app didn't pick up it making any song.

Some farmers REALLY care about wildlife and birds. Here in the uplands an abundance if wildlife is a sign of a healthy farm and healthy soil and something to be proud of.

FuckYouEzekiel · 24/06/2023 09:42

We are currently digging a wildlife pond, other than the pond liner, super cheap.

BarbedButterfly · 24/06/2023 09:45

I feed the birds and have water sources. I am moving soon and excited that I will have more space to make a proper nature garden. I am planning bee and butterfly friendly plants, insect hotels, a container pond and many other things. It doesn't take much effort at all and really helps

BunnyBettChetwynnd · 24/06/2023 09:51

I've always fed the birds but have stopped this year as I seem to attract magpies who I've watched systematically steal chicks from song birds nests this spring.

I'm renting at the moment so have bowls of water, bug hotels and lots of bird and pollinator plants in pots. When I buy I'm going to make my first job a pond and then instead of feeding the birds I'm going to concentrate all my money and effort on planting things that will provide food and shelter for song birds. https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/top-10-plants-for-birds/

It makes me bloody mad when I see the rows and rows of weedkiller, slug killer, bug stray in the garden centre and supermarket.

Top 10 Plants For Birds (pictures) | BBC Gardeners World Magazine

Discover 10 of the best plants for garden birds, to provide them with natural food sources all year round - expert advice from BBC Gardeners' World Magazine.

https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/top-10-plants-for-birds