Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Can we help the birds and insects?

108 replies

LuckyPeonies · 23/06/2023 19:17

This article makes me so sad, and angry as it’s mostly caused by habitat destruction, use of pesticides and herbicides, and profit-driven farming practices, with climate change an additional factor.

I know so many people who poison everything with pesticides and herbicides for their stupid ‘perfect’ lawns and plants and don’t let anything naturalize, even if they have enough space.

If all of us who are able do the best we can by supporting farmers who maintain responsible farming practices, refusing to use poisons ourselves, providing safe habitat when and where we can, planting natives for food and shelter, etc. we may be able to make a meaningful difference by providing pockets of safe habitat for birds and insects.

To that end, we leave dead trees (that are far enough away from structures on our smallish property) for the woodpeckers and owls, maintain several water sources and daily bird seed, and grow wildflowers and native grasses to provide insect habitat. It takes maybe 5 mins a day to put out bird seed and renew 5 water containers, so easily done and one can encourage children to help.

We also keep wood piles (from branches and shrubs) for the wrens and other birds, plant natives that provide food and shelter, host barn swallows who return every year to nest in our entry, encourage other birds to nest by maintaining bird houses, and keep our cats indoors when we can’t supervise them.

Those who don’t have a garden could grow pesticide free outdoor plants (and provide bird seed and a water source for birds, if suitable) on a balcony for insects.

Perhaps if all of us who love birds and nature band together and defy the chemical lawn and perfect plant expectation and support farmers and businesses with the same mindset, we can make a very positive difference. Because once they are gone, we cannot bring them back and future generations will be much poorer for it.

copied & pasted because of the paywall:

Bird Populations Are in Meltdown

Humans rely on birds to eat insects, spread seeds, and pollinate plants—but these feathered friends can’t survive without their habitats.Chris Baraniuk

Jun 20, 2023 1:15 PM

Photograph: Getty Images

Every night, Alice Cerutti falls asleep to the sound of birds singing on her rice farm in the middle of the Italian countryside. In the morning, the voice of the black-tailed godwit, a bird whose numbers are declining globally, wakes her from sleep—a little harshly. Cerutti imitates the bird’s over the phone and laughs. “Her sound is a bit annoying,” she says, though she quickly adds, “I really love her.”

Cerutti has turned her 115-hectare rice farm, exactly halfway between Milan and Turin, into a conservation project. During the past decade or so, she and her family have planted thousands of trees, reestablished wetlands, and brought in experts to help study and manage the precious birds that nest in areas Cerutti has set aside for wildlife.

It seems to be working. “We have this amazing and big responsibility,” Cerutti says as she explains that her farm is the last recorded regular nesting site of the black-tailed godwit in Italy. Local researchers found the bird clinging on there even as it disappeared from other locations.

Half of the world’s 10,000-odd bird species are in decline. One in eight faces the threat of extinction. This problem has been worsening for decades, which means scientists have been able to estimate roughly how many fewer birds are around today than, say, half a century ago. The numbers are startling.
There are 73 million fewer birds in Great Britain alone than there were in 1970. Europe has been losing around 20 million every year, says Vasilis Dakos, an ecologist at the University of Montpellier in France—a loss of 800 million birds since 1980. And in the US, just shy of 3 billion individual birds have disappeared in only 50 years.

“We are seeing a meltdown of bird populations,” says Ariel Brunner, director of BirdLife Europe and Central Asia, a conservation NGO. Loss of habitats, the rising use of pesticides on farms, and, yes, climate change—these are among the factors to blame. Even if you are not a birdwatcher, the loss of birds impacts you. Birds regulate ecosystems by preying on insects, pollinating plants, and spreading seeds—by excreting them after eating fruit, for example. We all rely on healthy ecosystems for breathable air, the food we eat, and a regulated climate.

The disappearance of birds is staggering. But Cerutti and others are trying to make a difference. In total, she has earmarked around a quarter of her farmland as a nature reserve. Six and a half hectares, for instance, are now woodland. If you view the farm, called Cascina Oschiena, using the satellite imagery on Google Maps, she says, you’ll see a wedge of dark green trees—alone amid the huge sea of rice fields that belong to her and her neighbors.
Cerutti has dispensed with pesticides and allowed vegetation in wetland areas to regrow. Besides the black-tailed godwits, there are bitterns and lapwings—both also in decline.

And no, she doesn’t make as much money as she might if she were driven to maximize profits on the same tract of land. It doesn’t matter. “Not every farmer can do what we’re doing, but I think that it’s important to do something,” she says. A neighbor was recently inspired by Cerutti’s efforts to stop spraying places that border her farm with glyphosate, an incredibly potent herbicide. “I think it’s a great step,” says Cerutti.

Speak to birdwatchers and researchers elsewhere in Europe and you’ll hear many examples of birds that were common just a generation or two ago that are now on the edge. Take the corncrake, whose song was once heard frequently across Ireland. There are now just a few hundred individuals left in a handful of locations.

“To be utterly frank, the situation is pretty awful,” says Rob Robinson, a senior scientist at the British Trust for Ornithology who is based in East Anglia. He mentions the willow warbler. Robinson has been putting rings on the legs of these little birds and releasing them, a common monitoring technique, for years.

“We catch one or two a year instead of 15 or 20,” he says, explaining how things have changed since he started the work. He also remembers seeing flocks of finches on farmland as a child. “Those I see very rarely these days.” Nightingales and turtle doves also used to be plentiful around the British countryside in spring. Now they are all but gone.

Brunner adds: “We are not losing just the birds, we are losing the insects, reptiles, amphibians, a lot of plants. We get very, very simplified and impoverished ecosystems.” That means it can be easier for invasive species to spread, he says. Crops become more dependent on chemistry and human intervention—and also more susceptible to diseases.

There’s also what Brunner calls the “moral issue.” Sights and sounds that have been part of the landscape, and of human culture, for millennia are suddenly fading away. Turtle doves are mentioned multiple times in the bible, he notes.

The single biggest cause of the decline in bird populations, he says, is the intensification of farming. High pesticide use, the loss of hedgerows and margins where insects and birds can live, and hyper-efficient harvesting are all problematic. Robinson says that around 70 years ago it was common for wheat farmers to leave 1 or 2 percent of their crop on the ground in fields.
“That doesn’t sound like very much, but if you add up large areas of farmland, it can sustain large bird populations,” he says. Technology and harvesting practices have become so good at catching every grain that this food source just isn’t there anymore.

In May, Dakos and colleagues published a large study in which they analyzed 37 years of bird-population data from 20,000 sites across 28 European nations. The team considered the growing size of towns and cities, the loss of forested areas, temperature rises, and the intensification of farming as key factors. In the researchers’ analysis of population trends for 170 bird species, all of these anthropogenic pressures had some impact, but it was intensive farming that appeared to have the strongest correlation with plummeting bird numbers. All over the dataset were struggling farmland bird species.

“We weren’t expecting to find such a strong result,” says Dakos. Farmland birds declined by 56.8 percent between 1980 and 2016, he and his colleagues estimate. The next most quickly declining group, urban species, fell by 27.8 percent.

Although this huge research project underlines some of the problems birds face, we’ve known about these issues for many years, says Amanda Rodewald at the Center for Avian Population Studies at Cornell University in the US.
“We’ve known enough for a long time to actually take active steps,” she says. “Our failure to do that has reflected that there hasn’t been a collective and strong will to act, in my opinion.”

There are ways to help, however. Countries can make tax or other financial incentives available to farmers willing to protect and encourage wildlife on their land, for instance. Consumer demand for more ecologically sustainable products can also have a positive impact, she says.

In California, some rice farmers are being paid to delay the draining of their fields in late winter to protect breeding areas used by wading birds. The project, called BirdReturns, has been running successfully for years. It targets areas deemed of greatest conservation benefit to bird species. Those areas were originally identified by citizen science bird-monitoring data from Cornell’s eBird app, Rodewald says.

“People are recognizing that we need to take some steps with the way we use resources and manage our planet,” she says. Despite the current bleak outlook, Robinson also maintains hope for the future because efforts to save birds appear to be growing.

Cerutti’s experience, though localized, speaks volumes. In just a few years, she has transformed multiple hectares of land and embraced wildlife—despite having known little about birds just 12 years ago. “The amazing thing is,” she says, “when you give back to nature, she really grabs it right away.”
https://www.wired.com/story/bird-population-decline/

Black-tailed Godwit (Limosa limosa) - BirdLife species factsheet

http://datazone.birdlife.org/species/factsheet/black-tailed-godwit-limosa-limosa

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
eurochick · 24/06/2023 09:57

Leaving an unmown area of lawn is a good idea. Ours is full of butterflies at the moment.

Lucanus · 24/06/2023 13:32

@Scrowy Pied Wagtail is the British and Irish subspecies of the White Wagtail. Continental birds are slightly different. Most likely yours was a normal Pied.

LuckyPeonies · 24/06/2023 17:23

@MothwingdustYour garden sounds wonderful! Your neighbor should be made to move into a concrete skyscraper where she doesn’t have to look at ‘messy’ plants.

I completely agree about human overpopulation, it is grim and must be addressed.

@Orban Many people are forced to use supermarkets because they have no alternative, but buying organic would help.

As for cats and dogs, I believe human overpopulation and associated environmental destruction are a much more pressing issue. Most pet food is manufactured by using by-products from animals killed for human consumption. But there are alternatives, someone mentioned on another thread they are feeding pet food made from insects.

The dogs we’ve taken in were strays off the street, and the cats are all rescues as well who are now indoors except for going out when they can be supervised. So they no longer live outdoors, catching birds and other species.

I do detest irresponsible people who don’t spay/neuter and/or buy from backyard breeders/puppy/kitten farms and thus contribute to pet overpopulation.

@Tipintorecession It is indeed difficult to stay hopeful, but perhaps those of us who do our best can mitigate some of the damage done by others, by providing a safe haven and eco system, as you are doing.

@Scrowy Your bird variety is impressive, to have so many species that are thriving. You are obviously doing all the right things. Your garden will hopefully recover and thrive as well, aided by dung from the naughty sheep. 🐑 😁

@FuckYouEzekiel What size are you digging? Are they difficult to maintain?

@BarbedButterfly I wish you much success and a thriving garden with many birds and insects.

@BunnyBettChetwynnd Same here, I don’t understand why all those poisons are legal. It is irresponsible and damaging, some of them don’t ever break down and stay in the soil and water indefinitely.

@eurochick It really makes a difference. So many wildflowers pop up and, if you don’t mow until they’ve gone to seed, they will come back every year.

@Lucanus Are you an ornithologist? You are very knowledgeable.

OP posts:
Chatillon · 24/06/2023 17:35

Can you post the link to the actual article please @LuckyPeonies

As far as I can tell there are two links to facts about Godwits, not the article itself.

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 24/06/2023 18:46

frozendaisy · 23/06/2023 19:36

People have to want to care. Too many want us to coo at the plastic grass "because it looks good all year round", and their new acrylic nails and all sorts if you attempt to point out "erm the planet is crying out for help" they blank you. Then moan food is expensive and it's too hot.

Yep. I’m hoping a backlash is coming.

Hedjwitch · 24/06/2023 18:47

We have a tiny pond, more of a glorified puddle, but loads of frogs in it. The birds drink from it and it attracts water beetles,water boatmen and damsel flies. Our garden is small but wild..blackbirds nest in the honeysuckle tangle at the bottom of the garden, so I dont cut it back.
We have wildflowers and bug hotels and hedgehog homes. No pesticides used. Despite all this I am shocked at the lack of wildlife; no ladybirds,few butterflies,no worms. Birdwise we have blackbirds, robind,sparrows,bluetits,great tits,starlings and wood pigeons. Thats about it...and we are semi rural with a wild garden!
It is genuinely terrifying.

Chatillon · 24/06/2023 19:25

Thank you @LuckyPeonies

LuckyPeonies · 24/06/2023 20:14

@Chatillon you are very welcome.

@Simplestead thank you, that is an interesting article, the part I pasted below makes sense. Perhaps feeding in winter and during drought/adverse weather should be done:

Human-induced environmental changes have transformed the foraging options for birds globally.

So if the survival prospects of birds are being hindered by the environmental impacts of humans on natural food supplies more widely, then perhaps our feeders are helping to redress the balance in some small way?

Certainly BTO research has indicated that several farmland seed-eating species are visiting garden feeders in winter because altered farming practices have led to a depletion of natural foods.

@Hedjwitch Is that a recent development or has it been gradual? Either way, it is indeed terrifying. I can’t imagine a world without a large diversity of of other species, though we have lost so many already, and many more are on the brink.

OP posts:
Lucanus · 24/06/2023 20:17

Simplestead · 24/06/2023 18:36

I'd say this is somewhat out of date and doesn't take into account recent research into the competitive effects of feeder-using species on declining species as I mentioned above.

Ultimately, the author doesn't actually come up with a good conservation reason to feed garden birds other than she does it because she wants to.

Worth reading these:
https://britishbirds.co.uk/content/rethinking-bird-feeding
https://twitter.com/Alexander_Lees/status/1428298255163699206

@LuckyPeonies No I'm not an ornithologist, more of a general ecologist, but I've become increasingly concerned about the effects of bird feeding on such a massive scale. Improving the habitat is far better and doesn't come with the downsides of feeding.

Rethinking bird feeding

Feeding birds is the most common way that people interact with wildlife in Britain. Up to two-thirds of all households do it, spending a total £250m on 150,000 tonnes of birdfood annually, mostly seeds (such as sunflower), peanuts and fats in various f...

https://britishbirds.co.uk/content/rethinking-bird-feeding

Lucanus · 24/06/2023 20:33

@LuckyPeonies In relation to farmland species, I think this still glosses over the fact that declines in these birds are a reflection of declines in the plants and insects they rely on, so just feeding the birds directly does nothing to address the underlying causes.

If farmland bird numbers are going to be used as a measure of general wildlife abundance, supplemental feeding just distorts the measure and makes it less useful.

Actually, if bird feeding stopped altogether, I think the distinction between good and bad habitat would become much more obvious and people might be encouraged to make improvements on that basis.

LuckyPeonies · 24/06/2023 20:47

@Lucanus I completely agree that improving/providing species appropriate habitat with a thriving insect population and native forage plants is vital.

I’ve noticed by observing the swallows who nest here (who completely rely on insects, so no supplemental feeding on our part), their brood numbers shrink when food/insects are scarce. Which is natural, of course, but also very worrisome because the majority don’t survive migration.

OP posts:
WaterIris · 24/06/2023 21:03

Urban area but lucky to have a large garden. We have various birds as a regular visitors including goldfinches. Squirrels and hedgehogs. No frogs in the pond this year as there are hundreds of waterboatmen who ate all the tadpoles, but the birds are busy feeding on them so I expect it will balance out again next year.

Not so many nests as we had to have a couple of trees taken out, and another two pollarded, but the latter are coming back nicely so I am hoping we'll get some nests again next year.

I overseeded my lawn with a meadow mix and although we mow it (long grass and dog poo being an unhappy mix) it doesn't require any other maintenance. There's quite a lot of clover in it which acts as a natural fertiliser as it fixes nitrogen from the air and is so pretty when it flowers. It's a work in progress but I have noticed this year we have had a lot of butterflies and bees so I am glad that my pollinator planting is working!

Lucanus · 24/06/2023 21:26

@LuckyPeonies Yes exactly, sounds like you're doing a great job with the habitat. And lawns with clover and other flowers are far more attractive than the plain green type.

The other thing is that bird feeding and other wildlife products (nest boxes, hedgehog houses, bee hotels etc, most of which are pretty unnecessary) are now an established industry with a lot of vested interests. It does concern me when the likes of the RSPB and the Wildlife Trusts are making money from these things through sales and advertising - I'm sure it compromises their impartiality.

Lucanus · 24/06/2023 21:32

Oops, the lawn comment was aimed at @WaterIris. Frog breeding success can really decline in established ponds as predator numbers increase, as you're seeing. They do best in new ponds or seasonal ponds that dry out occasionally. Newts tend to do better in more mature ponds.

Strathyre · 24/06/2023 21:32

We are doing our best here! When we moved in we inherited gravel at the front and round the side. We've removed both and sown grass seed at the front. Round the side we had to get imported topsoil as it was allbuulding rubble under the gravel. Long term we are hoping to plant an allotment there, but for now we've sown grass seed for paths and scattered some wildflower seeds where the veg will eventually go. The improvement over the gravel is crazy, lots of posties and cornflowers now which the bees are visiting.

Then in the back garden I've planted a border of flowers, my favourite at the moment is watching the goldfinches eat the seeds on the scabious. In our old house I only ever saw them eat bird seed so it's lovely to thinking provided them with some wild food!

When my kids are older I'd love a wildlife pond. If I had one now they'd never stay away from it!

LuckyPeonies · 24/06/2023 23:15

@WaterIris I hope your tadpoles survive next year. We have patches of clover and the bees love them. We also have a holly tree and it is crawling with bees when it blooms in spring.

@Lucanus What do you think of bat houses? We used to have many bats, but their numbers are dwindling.

@Strathyre Must be very satisfying to see bees and other insects thrive where there once was gravel.

It is lovely to watch the birds forage on various plants. Last autumn we had many finches and other species feasting on sunflower heads.

OP posts:
bellamountain · 24/06/2023 23:31

A well maintained lawn isn't a bad thing, so long as the rest of the garden is an abundance of shrubbery and plants. In fact, the birds have a much easier time finding the worms on a freshly mowed lawn.

Lucanus · 25/06/2023 00:51

@LuckyPeonies Bats are very good at getting into roofs and other spaces in buildings through tiny gaps, plus they will use natural roost sites in tree holes etc (which don't need to be all that big). I'm sceptical that putting up bat boxes is really necessary, except maybe in particular situations. Built-in provision for bats is always going to be better than an external box and shouldn't need maintenance.

I think the much bigger issues are lack of insect food and light pollution. Some bat species aren't too bothered by light and will feed around street lights etc, but others are much more sensitive and require proper darkness. It also affects the insects too.

Ponds are really good at breeding the flies etc that they eat, so the more of them the better.

GreekDogRescue · 25/06/2023 08:40

Due to habitat destruction birds are having a hard time. I’m pasting this in from Hedgehog Cabin (worth following her on Twitter or her website HedgehogCabin.info, she runs a hedgehog hospital in Hants and is an expert re all things wildlife).

This is just a little wet cat food left over from feeding the hedgehogs last night, put out for the starling and corvid fledglings.
I've never, in all my years, known our wildlife to be so desperately hungry.
The food kites once relied on is being fed to fox hunting hounds.

GreekDogRescue · 25/06/2023 08:50

Ive been leaving out water in the garden and a local graveyard. I also have several hedgehog feeding stations in which I put in cat biscuits every night.

quite agree with your point @Lucanus about commercialising wildlife - I was nearly tempted to buy a bee house until I realised that unless they are kept clean they will transmit diseases.
I’m involved with hedgehog rescue and so many hedgehog houses are cheap dangerous rubbish. They need food primarily anyway.

LuckyPeonies · 25/06/2023 16:16

@bellamountain unfortunately, many people seem to believe a well-maintained lawn means ‘spraying for bugs’ and destroying anything that isn’t grass with herbicide.

@Lucanus yes, light pollution is a terrible thing for all creatures, humans included. I’ve read migratory birds are particularly negatively affected.

@GreekDogRescue that is very sad (and infuriating) to read. I really wonder if humanity will come to our senses or if all this needless assault on nature will go on until there is nothing left.

OP posts:
MeinKraft · 25/06/2023 16:24

Birds need hedgerows to nest in. So plant some hedgerows and some shrubs if you have a garden.

LuckyPeonies · 25/06/2023 18:22

@MeinKraft yes, judging by the activity, we have several species nesting in ours. And they like the berries in autumn/winter. The wrens seem to prefer awkward spots, they’ve nested in hanging flower pots and even an old mailbox. A friend kept his garage open for weeks because a wren built a nest on a shelf. So he waited until everyone fledged.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread