Peanut butter- crunchy or smooth?

[Cheesymonster]

And what's your favourite brand? I've just run out of my Tesco own brand smooth - what should I buy next?

Crunchy

Smooth people are wrong

Skippy extra crunchy. Bought by the vat in Costco

Crunchy
In uk - Sunpat
In us - skippy
Have to Carne an s I to top when opening - bad luck of don’t. Old family tradition.
Have yet to find an organic/healthier peanut butter which come close to my faves.

Carve not Carne

Definitely crunchy, I don't understand smooth lovers! No crunch? What's that all about?!
"Yay, sloppy mess with all the crunch taken out!"
Out of the jar with a spoon the best way to eat it

HOW IS THIS STILL ON DISCUSSION OF THE DAY???

Smooth. And lately I've converted to a whole foods one which is more runny like almond butter. You can't spread chunky stuff and it's too sugary and unhealthy to eat regularly. A complete waste of calories. You can also use the smooth one more easily for cooking and smoothies.

Meridian and I like crunchy best

Definitely crunchy if its being eaten by the fingerful straight from the jar, or spoonful if being civilised or being eaten with celery. Smooth for spreading on stuff but it does taste different!!

My mum gave me some vegan peanut butter - which was delicious! nothing in it except peanuts.

Smooth and has to have grape jelly with it

Crunchy, preferably slightly melted on toast. Smooth is pointless.

Blobby most peanut butter is vegan

Always crunchy. Skippy (us) or sunpat (us).
With either grape jelly (if In us and can get schmuckers) or recurrent jelly (in uk) or bicks green pickle ((us) or gherkins (uk).

Just found out about sun butter. Never tried. No substitute (I don’t have an allergy clearly) but intrigued.

Sunpat crunchy and the new marmite one.

Not sunpat, skippy. I don’t know why I wrote sunpat.

Smooth or crunchy, preferably Sunpat though
I find meridian separates and tastes grainy

Ohhhh smoooth....but I get outvoted for crunchy 😭😭

I would once have said Meridian or Whole Earth. But there's one called Proper Nutty, made in Yorkshire, which makes all the others taste rubbish by comparison. They sell it in Booths, not sure if it's available elsewhere. It's neither smooth nor crunchy - they call it smunchy and it's unbelievably delicious. No palm oil, no sugar, just nuts. You can get slightly salted or no salt versions.

I never see the point in smooth peanut butter. If you’re eating NUT-something, you want to crunch the actual nuts!

We have Whole Earth. DC sometimes want smooth so we usually have both.

What is this Sophie's choice? They're both perfect in their own way!

crunchy - I like the ones that don't have sugar added - that morrisons one looks good will keep my eye out for that.

Crunchy!!!

Waitrose wholenut. I think you can only get it in crunchy. They don't skin the nuts so it has a deeper flavour. I usually have that, and then a smooth as well, because sometimes I'll use smooth in cooking.

I love cashew butter, but it seems so expensive in comparison!

Actually, I used to live near a whole food shop where you could grind your own, all different nuts. Even more expensive nicer tasting.

My people! :D
Pip and Nut for me. Crunchy!
A scoop into a majoole date, amazing snack!

Crunchy preferably Sainsbury's but also Lidl