I do think women should get fully informed of the smear test and it’s limitations - there’s no evidence it saves 1000s of lives. Cell changes happen all the time so if you get tested and it’s abnormal, you could then be normal again 6 months later. But in that time if you go on to have invasive procedures to check you could be doing yourself a lot of emotional and physical damage (it’s known to cause pre-term births).
I did post links upthread with more information if people read them.
I’m not against the smear but I am against the overdone propaganda to have it as there’s no evidence whatsoever that any less women have died since it came into play. And if it’s that super shouldn’t we have it more than every three years? What if I get tested on year 1, develop cancer with no symptoms 6 months later, then don’t get tested again until year 3? Nobody can do anything about that.
It’s screening, not diagnostic. And screening isn’t necessarily a good thing. It’s already been found that the mammograms used for screening cause more harm than good.
0.65% women will get cervical cancer.
We have to screen 1000 women for 35 years to save 10.
That’s the facts. And of course those 10 lives are very valuable but in the meantime 1000s of women who could just as easily die from any other cancer or disease or being hit by a bus or an asthma attack are guilted and pushed and bullied into having what can for many be a horrendous and traumatic experience. It does hurt for many and it doesn’t take a few seconds.
I for one am pretty fed up with everyone spouting the campaign lines and ‘war time’ style propaganda without taking time to do their own research.
The Daily Mail claimed the smear ‘saves 1000s of lives’....the NHS website itself says they cannot back up this claim.
Go to Margaret McCartney’s website or better still read her book The Patient Paradox which is short and only a couple of quid as download.
And fgs with the jokes when people like me have said how dreadful the smears are and how we’ve been abused. Bully for you if it’s all easy but there are a huge number of us who go through hell for them and essentially for nothing as such an incredibly small proportion of women get it - far more will die of breast cancer.
Prostrate cancer is more common so why aren’t they shaming men and telling them they’ll leave their kids fatherless unless they submit up testing?!
It’s financially motivated at its core and I hope with the new blood test etc there will be a change to it but please, do all your research before you spout it saves lives. There’s no real evidence of that.