Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AMA

I ‘section’ people under the MHA

172 replies

Narwhalelife · 13/07/2022 22:26

I am an Approved Mental Health Professional (AMHP). It is only AMHP’s that can section people.
Little is known about us and our role but lots of people know what ‘sectioned’ means - Ask me anything 😊

OP posts:
LemonSwan · 16/07/2022 14:12

@antelopevalley

Yes that’s exactly what I am talking about.

I have been thinking about this more and I was joking before when I said they should have mental health professionals undercover. But the more I have been thinking I actually think it should be compulsory training to spend a month in a section undercover for all mental health professionals.

It’s one of the only jobs I can think of where people working in it will likely never actually use the service and experience it from the other side IYSWIM. Ie. Shop owners use shops, general medicine people use healthcare, restauranteurs use restaurants, architects live in houses etc.

mumsys · 16/07/2022 16:04

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Therunecaster · 16/07/2022 16:14

Waves at Op. my partner is an AMHP and I'm a RMN. What do you think about the changes to the MHA particularly NR.

Elmo230885 · 16/07/2022 17:29

Hi OP,

How much training did you have within your training around people with a learning disability being made subject to the MHA?

Thanks

Elmo230885 · 16/07/2022 17:31

I'll just add to my post... I mean being subject to the MHA due to a mental health condition comorbid to their LD... before someone corrects me

paddingtonstares · 16/07/2022 17:41

Why would a young suicidal man be released by A&E after 5 hours with the crisis number and 'CPN will be in touch with you within 3 weeks'
Do they hope the distressed person will succeed to get thm off the books?
cynical mother of suicidal man here

Narwhalelife · 16/07/2022 17:53

Felix125 · 15/07/2022 11:09

This might have been asked already, so I apologise if so.

Can a person who has addictions to alcohol or drugs be deemed as having a mental heath issue? As a police officer, we get called to loads of cases where someone appears to be having a complete mental health crises/breakdown. We take them to a local mental health hospital where we have to sit with them until the effects wear off. They then can assessed and they are deemed fit to go back home - but then next day, we are back in the same situation. At what point should the mental health service look at their addictions and section them?

Also (whilst I'm here) people who are deemed to have 'attention seeking' issues never seem to be sectioned. The typical scenario is a person who stands on a bridge and threatens to jump. After quite some time we manage to talk them down and taken them to a mental health hospital - but they are deemed to be 'attention seeking' and are released as fit. A few days later, we have the same scenario. At what point do we say that they have a mental health issue?

Drug & alcohol issues are excluded as criteria for detention under the mental health act. Although we would consider someone who had these issues and a mental illness.

The individuals you are taking about are probably likely to have personality disorder diagnosis (and there are many different types). Admitting these patients to an inpatient unit is complex because the treatment they require is long time psychotherapy and this is not available in most hospitals. However, we definitely do detain people with this diagnosis. Additionally, once in hospital people can struggle with the environment and we often see an escalation in risk, further attempts to self harm, aggression and violence towards staff and other patients, so sometimes this makes the situation worse.

some people can get long term psychological treatment in treatment hospitals but il be honest these can cost in excess of £300k a year to the NHS and there are so few of these types of beds where patients usually stay for up to 2 years, so the NHS has to ration these resources. And they have a very low success rate. In my career I have only known 2 people to go through this whole system including a treatment bed for nearly 3 years and come out much more well and is now back at work etc.

OP posts:
Narwhalelife · 16/07/2022 17:58

TheGreatBobinsky · 14/07/2022 10:44

Why are so many suicidal people just sent home with no interventions? Is it because you think they are lying? I have a diagnosis of EUPD and have never had so much as a phone call after suicide attempts. There are so many failures in the service and it feels like a lot of us are sent home to die to ease pressure on the NHS because its just easier if we weren't here.

I’m sorry about your experiences. The NICE guidelines of treatment for EUPD includes long term psychotherapy or group therapy (which everyone hates usually) but the lists are so long that people often get little support in between, I havnt worked in a mental health team for a few years but in the AMHP service we will try and make the best decisions for people in the moment we see them considering their history and community plan.

OP posts:
Narwhalelife · 16/07/2022 17:59

clpsmum · 14/07/2022 10:54

@Narwhalelife unrelated to work question. But is if pissing you off everyone questioning how well you know your job and trying to prove you wrong because if is me!!!!

A bit but I expected this to a point, hence the post, as it’s such a niche job people know very little about.

plus we work with police a lot and these frustrations are not just on this thread but in real life too.

OP posts:
Narwhalelife · 16/07/2022 18:03

bigkoalacliphug · 14/07/2022 20:36

Hi OP, thanks for starting this thread.

I know it's difficult for you to comment on individual cases but I wonder if I could ask your opinion on eating disorders please?

My DD18 has been diagnosed with bulimia and anorexia, along with anxiety. She also displays traits of OCD and 3 people involved in her care have advised she may be "on the spectrum", but she's never been assessed as her EDs took priority.

Diagnosed with bulimia 3 years ago at 15 and struggled at home with camhs support. Diagnosed with anorexia approximately 9 months ago. She was admitted to a specialist unit in February but discharged herself after 6 weeks. While there she was never assessed for capacity despite openly stating she'd rather die than gain weight. She left the unit weight 6.5st and now weighs under 5.5st. Sees a MH nurse once weekly and is under the care of an OT, dietician, psychiatrist.

Lives with her dad now due to verbal aggression towards me, in relation to her conditions. Eg, would become abusive if I ate anything. She's now gone NC with me but when I spoke to her last, around a month ago, she was considering discharging herself for all services completely.

I guess my question is, what will it take for her to get better / get sectioned? While an inpatient I begged for her to get sectioned as she kept threatening to discharge herself...and then she did. She's lost over a stone since being discharged and DNAs for community appointments.

I'm desperately worried about her 🥲

Sorry to hear about your daughter. The only things I would recommend is keep sharing your concerns with anyone that will listen. Remember that her nearest relative (which will be her dad currently if she is living with him) can request a mental health act assessment from the local AMHP service. Research treatment units and suggest these as there is sometimes scope to use services outside of the ones the NHS regularly use.

There is no set ‘limit’ on what it takes to have someone detained under the mental health act in a case of ED we do have scope to move in before things become terrible.

also take her to A&E if you are concerned for her physical health, all hospitals with an A&E department will also have a floating psychiatric team who will assess her (you might have to mention this to them!)

OP posts:
Narwhalelife · 16/07/2022 18:05

CheltenhamLady · 14/07/2022 11:24

Interesting thread OP

I have a relative who is diagnosed as Schizophrenic but has had no involvement with her Pysch team for years.

Unfortunately, she now has numerous other physical illnesses such as Diabetes, HBP, High Cholesterol and failing eyesight. However, she simply refuses to take her medication and will not give a reason why. She says she will take it, then when asked says she has, but then admits she hasnt.

Her health is deteriorating but we all seem powerless to help.
Could she be sectioned for that? For her own good?

We cannot section people for physical health needs, it’s an exclusion in the mental health act, but if she has a diagnosis such as this and her mental health causing a risk to her health (which is sounds like it is) then yes, we could use it potentially. Get back in touch with the local mental health team, share your concerns and mention her history and the physical health risks

OP posts:
Narwhalelife · 16/07/2022 18:10

Otterses · 15/07/2022 14:30

What are your views on the seemingly increasing number of those with serious and complex mental health issues who are currently being supervised by the probation service? Do you feel there is a place for mental health orders, and do you feel that court directed intervention would impact up the volume of those needing to be sectioned?

Great question.

I think it’s an unnecessary stress on probation services and I see ‘hot potato’ clients in this area.

Mental Health Orders in my experience have little teeth. They are an alternative to hospital orders and sectioning which the court may have at its disposal at the time although hospital orders can only be imposed for schedule 14 offences - not all offences. But there is nothing to enforce them because, if a person refuses to attend and then defaults on the treatment order then the courts are very unlikely to recall to custody because of the mental health element in my experience.

OP posts:
pazwaz70 · 16/07/2022 18:12

Mental health nurses can use section 5(4), nurses holding power. It only lasts for 6 hours though.

Narwhalelife · 16/07/2022 18:17

Therunecaster · 16/07/2022 16:14

Waves at Op. my partner is an AMHP and I'm a RMN. What do you think about the changes to the MHA particularly NR.

Hi!

ermm, I think for some people the changes to NR will be beneficial but will also cause nightmares for AMHPs and patients a like.

The fact treatment will have to have ‘therapeutic benefit’ will also be interesting to justify in practice. I mean, Clozapine for example - great if it works but the side effects and restriction on liberty to retitrate etc - thinking for non concordant CTO recall patients ? Will be difficult to justify depends who the treatment has to be therapeutic for - I imagine the person but what about protection of others - the mind boggles lol but I’m sure it will be worked out

BUT, I’m all for better community resources (let’s hope we actually get them!!) and for people having more say in their treatment.

OP posts:
Narwhalelife · 16/07/2022 18:21

Elmo230885 · 16/07/2022 17:29

Hi OP,

How much training did you have within your training around people with a learning disability being made subject to the MHA?

Thanks

As social workers first, we have to demonstrate a minimum of 2 years hands on experience with all spectrum of mental illness, including autism and LD before embarking on the AMHP training although many AMHPs have much more experience than this.

We then have to have mandatory training in these areas every year.

When a person with LD is being assessed under the mental health act we have to have a psychiatrist with LD experience present also so we have their expertise.

the mental health act criteria is also slightly different for people with LD to avoid these people being put in hospital for long periods inappropriately.

OP posts:
Narwhalelife · 16/07/2022 18:24

paddingtonstares · 16/07/2022 17:41

Why would a young suicidal man be released by A&E after 5 hours with the crisis number and 'CPN will be in touch with you within 3 weeks'
Do they hope the distressed person will succeed to get thm off the books?
cynical mother of suicidal man here

Sadly, I’m not sure. If an AMHP had assessed and made this decision we are duty bound to provide a plan (which one would hope is better than a call in 3 weeks) and this should be communicated to family.

In short, if there are viable community options available people will unlikely be detained under the mental health act. In my area anyone in this position has a follow up within 72 hours so we start with that and then layer up the plan from there.

OP posts:
Cinderella88 · 16/07/2022 18:35

If your background is social work did you also have to undergo mental health training for this job role?

Narwhalelife · 16/07/2022 20:20

Cinderella88 · 16/07/2022 18:35

If your background is social work did you also have to undergo mental health training for this job role?

Yes I’m a social worker first - we have to retain this registration to practice as an AMHP -you have to have a minimum of 2 years frontline mental health experience (but many have more than that) and it’s then it’s a postgraduate diploma at university a year of law, legal training and a 5 month hands on placement in an AMHP service.

OP posts:
Freeasabird76 · 16/07/2022 20:29

Delicate question

Would you 'section' someone who had made plans to take their own lives and the lives of their children.

Narwhalelife · 16/07/2022 20:44

Freeasabird76 · 16/07/2022 20:29

Delicate question

Would you 'section' someone who had made plans to take their own lives and the lives of their children.

Without all the detail - this would seem a police ,children services and indeed an AMHP matter. Depending on the circumstances I would expect all of these services to be involved

OP posts:
Thack · 16/07/2022 21:23

Hi OP, great thread!

Do you have any general advice on how to deal with someone who needs to be detained /is having some kind of crisis?
E.g. Any phrases to use/avoid, is eye contact a good thing etc.

x2boys · 24/07/2022 18:33

I used to be a mental health nurse, I haven't been one for a number of years though now are Amhp ,s still mainly social workers ?
Back in the day it was approved social worker ,s that sectioned people but then the training was opened up so other mental health professionals could do the training ,but ime admittedly a few years ago it was still mainly social workers who were Amhp s

lilypad99 · 28/07/2022 20:37

How bad does someone have to be to get sectioned? I was in A&E with a family member yesterday after being referred there by the GP after an emergency appointment. The family member was having a huge mental breakdown, threatening to commit suicide and and practically begging to be kept in as did not feel safe going home yet all we got were helpline numbers, they are much beyond this and need real intervention. Is there anything I can do to get them some proper help asap? Thank you

Narwhalelife · 29/07/2022 07:47

Thack · 16/07/2022 21:23

Hi OP, great thread!

Do you have any general advice on how to deal with someone who needs to be detained /is having some kind of crisis?
E.g. Any phrases to use/avoid, is eye contact a good thing etc.

Hi! Sorry for the delay I didn’t receive the notification for this unfortunately.

Try and keep your relationship as normal as possible, encourage them to do the things they would have done (if it’s safe). Support them as best you can as if someone was about to go into a physical health hospital for an operation. Find out visiting times, reassure them you can visit and if they need anything, soft lounge wear to wear on the ward is always a good option for them to pack & their favourite snacks.

normal eye contact etc

OP posts:
Narwhalelife · 29/07/2022 07:48

x2boys · 24/07/2022 18:33

I used to be a mental health nurse, I haven't been one for a number of years though now are Amhp ,s still mainly social workers ?
Back in the day it was approved social worker ,s that sectioned people but then the training was opened up so other mental health professionals could do the training ,but ime admittedly a few years ago it was still mainly social workers who were Amhp s

yes still mostly social workers. In our team we had one nurse but they left a couple of weeks ago and we have 2 occupational therapists.

i have never met or heard of a psychologist becoming an AMHP.

OP posts: