Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AMA

I am an LA educational psychologist, AMA.

201 replies

summerEP · 01/05/2022 05:08

Really enjoy reading the AMA threads so thought I would offer my own. I work for an LA as an EP and completed my training within the last 3 years. AMA.

OP posts:
DrRuthGalloway · 01/05/2022 09:03

ittakes2 · 01/05/2022 09:00

In your experience do children with adhd often get extra time in exams or not? My daughters psychiatrist has recommended extra time but her school won’t award it to her. We’ve offered to pay for further testing and the school senco is an educational psychologist herself so could test her herself if she wants to.

As she has a recognised disability she is entitled to reasonable adjustments. She doesn't need further testing, or a form 8, she just needs to have evidence that it is usual way of working and has a significant impact on her ability to demonstrate what she knows. She would also be entitled to rest breaks and prompting if she loses focus.

summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:11

Haveatakeaway · 01/05/2022 08:22

How much do your visits cost to the school generally?
what adjustments would you recommend a 10 year old child in mainstream settings have that has a comprehension level on the second centile and asd?
recently had to start homeschooling for various reasons other than above.

General adjustments would be individualised for the needs of the child but I often find for asd they centre around reducing anxiety, increasing predictability, teaching social comms skills and supporting sense of belonging (amongst others). This can be to a greater or lesser degree depending on my formulation of the child's barriers to learning. Standardised cog assessment scores are only 1 part of the puzzle and by themselves do not tell us a huge amount as the conifence intervals often span a very wide range (meaning a child can score 2nd percentile but can range between 1st and 25th for example). This means that if a child scored low in comprehension I would choose to do observations and other one to one work with the child to hypothesise exactly what may be underpinning their difficulties then make a choice on provision from there.

OP posts:
summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:15

Snorkellingaround · 01/05/2022 08:26

What support would a three year old with selective mutism at pre-school benefit from?

Just briefly I would be wondering around the child's perception of the function of language and whether they see it as needed, as well as anxiety amongst other things. Then once I felt I had a good sense of what may be going on I would suggest how to make using verbal language beneficial to the child (if the former was the case) or reduce their anxiety if the latter was the case. Can be much more complicated than that but that's a basic answer

OP posts:
MarianosOnHisWay · 01/05/2022 09:17

DrRuthGalloway · 01/05/2022 08:44

Ah OP. Another ed psych did this a few years ago. It lasted a day or so and had to be deleted because (justifiably) angry parents were attacking the OP for what had happened to their children. It's the only AMA I ever saw removed.

How would they be “justified” in attacking the OP?

beautifulflower · 01/05/2022 09:17

What is really the core of your role? From the job title it sounded to me like someone who understands (and hence can help parents and teachers understand) what might make children the way they are in an educational setting and what they therefore need to learn well. But in reality it seems to be more about monitoring for the LA what schools are doing for SEN children and deciding on funding?

DrRuthGalloway · 01/05/2022 09:20

MarianosOnHisWay · 01/05/2022 09:17

How would they be “justified” in attacking the OP?

They weren't.
They were justifiably angry about whatever had happened with their SEN kids.
None of which was the fault of the ed psych who set up the AMA who could do nothing about their situations of course, but those angry people vented at the OP so much the thread was removed.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 01/05/2022 09:22

do you diagnose autism?
are you happy with the teaching/support offered

Sockpile · 01/05/2022 09:22

Have you ever had to defend your reports at a SENDIST tribunal?

Do your LA allow you to freely write 1-1 support into your reports or do you only generally do that when under pressure of tribunal?

summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:23

wonkygorgeous · 01/05/2022 08:28

Isn't being employed by the LA a conflict of interest?

Are your assessments based purely on the educational needs of the child without any bias towards the funding ability of the LA who employs you.

I have been reluctant to ask for an LA funded Ed Psychology assessment as I'm afraid of bias.
I've funded a respected Ed psychologist myself even though it's very expensive.

Ah interesting one. Like NHS staff we are all registered with the hcpc and our work is grounded in the bps code of ethics. We would lose our license if we were found to act unethically and have 3 years doctoral training which primarily centres around managing such ethical conflicts and keeping the child in the centre. Obviously there will be some poor choices made out there as in any profession, but generally the same goes for us whether we are paid by the LA, parent or school. We are trained to try to reflect on unconscious or conscious bias towards our 'client' and ensure that our work is ethical and has the best interests of the child in mind. Many EPs work half the week for an LA and half the week as a private EP. There will be examples where any professional acts unethically, but I do not get a sense from within the profession that LA EPs are more biased than private ones. l would not change my report to meet LA funding requirements for example. The only way our hands are tied is with the time we have to spend on each report but again we are ethically bound to ensure they are representative of the child's needs.

OP posts:
summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:25

MarianosOnHisWay · 01/05/2022 08:28

Were you a teacher first, if so how long for? What undergraduate degree did you do? Thanks

I worked as support staff and did extra training in a variety of therapies and interventions, completed a psychology conversion and then got a place on the doctorate. It's competitive but doable, your experience sounds great. Just keep reflecting on the psychology you are using in your role and think systemically.

OP posts:
PlantingTrees · 01/05/2022 09:26

I have a son who hates loud noises, particularly other children crying. It means that he doesn’t like going to nursery, struggles with play dates sometimes and I’m worried about what school will be like. Some people have suggested ear defenders but I’m not sure about this in case they then become more and more needed and he just lives in ear defenders. He hates loud noises beyond just the normal amount. He is also very switched on regarding other peoples emotions. Much more than other kids his age and has a good understanding of social situations. So I’m not sure if the crying is about the noise or about him being upset that others are upset and feeling it too deeply. Any suggestions?

summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:27

Sorry that was a reply to the other poster, I quotes the wrong thing. Hard to keep up!

OP posts:
summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:29

cansu · 01/05/2022 08:29

How much pressure is there from the LA to write reports which favour what the LA want to fund? I had a very brave LA Ed psych who had to appear as a LA tribunal witness for their case. She then proceeded to support my case. It was very very difficult for her and I think she retired afterwards.

I have not noticed any pressure in the LA I work in. I write the report then it goes to panel so when I assess I do not know the LA'S views. I only provide one part of the advice, the OT, SALT, health and social care also contribute so decision are based on all those identified needs.

OP posts:
BelleTheBananas · 01/05/2022 09:29

@summerEP thanks! No worries 😀

summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:33

Hollyhead · 01/05/2022 08:33

Do you think in an ideal world all children would benefit from assessment to understand how best to learn and where they’d need the most support or would that be overkill?

in an ideal world teachers and sencos are well positioned to assess and know this, however they are so stretched they are often not able to due to pressures and time. The EP is first and foremost a psychologist, not an educationalist who is brought in to look systemically at the environment, relational difficulties, barriers to learning, past trauma, attachment needs etc. So that will not be needed for the majority of children who would better benefit from teachers being given the time to be able to do their jobs properly (don't get me into a rant about government funding for schools).

OP posts:
summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:40

Lougle · 01/05/2022 08:37

My DD was assessed last week. The ED Psych didn't do any formal testing but just chatted to us about how she feels at school (ASD, on a reduced timetable in year 10 because she can't cope with the school environment). When I asked about formal testing he said that it isn't always helpful. Why?

I will only do standardised cognitive assessments in a very few cases. There are a wide variety of situations where the results would not be very useful, for example where a child was experiencing significant anxiety, a child was highly distracted, or experienced significant trauma in the past. The results would likely be confounded and therefore not representative of the child's actual cognitive performance. Then they would be labelled as having slow processing which may become stuck on the child so to speak, when in fact its other things going on. We often don't need a score to know a child struggles with their memory, teachers see that in their interactions with the child every day for example. Standardised cog assessments are very one dimensional, they. An make up a small part of the puzzle but as a psychologist, I am much more interested in observing the child in their setting, speaking to those who know them best and talking/working directly with them dynamically to see how they learn.

OP posts:
summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:42

StateOfTheUterus · 01/05/2022 08:39

General question about Ed Psych. A friend’s daughter is at Uni and has Long Covid. Struggling with brain fog - particularly reading complex information or writing longer analytical stuff. Long Covid clinic day it’s all fatigue/stress. But friend’s daughter feels it’s more than that. Could/would an Ed Psych assessment help?

It coukd possibly help if your friend noticed issues before her daughter had covid? I think its about making sure the daughter is getting the right adaptions necessary in school and maybe an EP coukd identify what they are if she feels school hVe not been able to.

OP posts:
summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:45

itsgettingweird · 01/05/2022 08:40

Another who's first question is about writing reports!

Why do LA funded Ed psychs write "would benefit from" when writing reports for ehcp assessments when they know section F needs quantified and specified inputs.

Is it because the LA pressurises this or is it that Ed psych report writing practice hasn't been updated to reflect the necessary wording required to meet the needs of pupils in education?

Ah yes, we are reminded regularly to be more specific and not tentative to fall in line with the ehc requirements. As psychologists we hold things tentatively in mind a lot so the specificity part of ehc's is hard for us even though we know it's a requirement! I'maways trying to make sure I'm as quantified and specific as possible but it is hard as it's at odds with psychological thinking often.

OP posts:
DrHildegardeLanstrom · 01/05/2022 09:46

If a child twigs they are being observed in a classroom (my DD can tell something is going on a mile away), or a child doesn't engage 121 due to anxiety for example, can this affect the content of any report?

summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:49

TeenPlusCat · 01/05/2022 08:40

Is it usual when doing an assessment for an EHCP (17yo) to
a) not visit the educational setting
b) not look into things like dyslexia
(You can probably tell I wasn't very happy...)

There may have been a reason the EP didn't visit the setting but I would normally do so to speak to the senior and young person. We don't do dyslexia assessments, we don't diagnose dyslexia but may look into literacy difficulties if needed. Our role is to ensure the provision or interventions are appropriate for the child and often we can get a good sense of that without standardised assessments (sometimes they are needed though if the school doesn't have a lot of info)

OP posts:
summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:50

BelleTheBananas · 01/05/2022 08:42

Hi @summerEP

I’m currently doing a psych masters and have 20 years’ experience as a secondary teacher. Do you think I have a good chance of getting a spot on the professional doctorate for EPs? Any tips?

Also, I have a high degree of additional needs and executive dysfunction in my tutor group (lots of ASD/ADHD). Have you got any top tips for supporting them with their planning and organisation?

thanks!

Ah replied above to this but quotes the wrong post. Your experience sounds very relevant! Just keep reflecting on psychology and look up the doctoral applicant Facebook page it's super useful.

OP posts:
summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:52

DrRuthGalloway · 01/05/2022 08:44

Ah OP. Another ed psych did this a few years ago. It lasted a day or so and had to be deleted because (justifiably) angry parents were attacking the OP for what had happened to their children. It's the only AMA I ever saw removed.

Oh god! I do understand the strength of feeling though, EPs are often unduly placed in a gatekeeper role by the system and our children are our world's. I have 2 so I know! :-)

OP posts:
TeenPlusCat · 01/05/2022 09:52

The EP is first and foremost a psychologist, not an educationalist who is brought in to look systemically at the environment, relational difficulties, barriers to learning, past trauma, attachment needs etc.

I do wish I had understood the difference between what an EP would cover and what an OT would cover before DD had her assessment (which didn't include an OT Hmm ). Our EP seemed to have her own 'agenda' on our zoom call, which to our view didn't tally with what we considered the most pressing issues to be.

Question: Do you think parents are well enough informed as to what your role does / does not actually cover?

summerEP · 01/05/2022 09:53

Loopytiles · 01/05/2022 08:45

UK funding and service provision is very low relative to need.

Services are ‘gate kept’ and are either not there or only a few of those who need services can access them.

I wouldn’t want to be part of that. Trying to provide useful services in a fucked up system. Complicit.

then again if no one tried there could be even worse services.

Yes it's very hard. Same for nhs staff I imagine.

OP posts:
Sockpile · 01/05/2022 09:54

Why don’t you diagnose dyslexia?
My son was seen by LA EPs from the age of 5, his literacy difficulties were noted but not seen as a major concern. When he was 11 he saw a private Ed Psych who explicitly told us he was severely dyslexic and needed much more specialist intervention. He’s now 13 and at a specialist dyslexia school. My son has multiple complex needs but being able to separate some out with for example the dyslexia diagnosis has been really important in accessing the help he needs.