Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trump's plans for day one: ending child sexual mutilation and having just male and female genders

335 replies

ResisterOfTwaddleRex · 22/12/2024 20:14

He says "genders" but that has to mean "sex". Day one executive orders, apparently:

x.com/chooocole/status/1870920265330528324?s=46&t=WHoOZ_3Kv5G6-FyQuvE0LQ

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Snowypeaks · 22/01/2025 12:56

LadyGreyson

I suspect you still haven't read the Executive Order.

Perhaps that is why you are still framing it as anti-trans. It's pro-women. Nothing in it stops anyone from wearing what they want, or claiming a transgender identity. It just means that society, women in particular, are not forced to believe, or act as if they believe that anyone has changed sex.
That's just asserting normal reality. Why would you oppose that? Why would that make you so angry?

LadyGreyson · 22/01/2025 12:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/01/2025 12:54

Well, quite @RoyalCorgi

RoyalCorgi · 22/01/2025 12:52

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/01/2025 12:39

There's a discussion about this on Threads and it's biologically clueless. They're all at the "what about intersex" and "all embryos start off as female" stage.

I can believe it.

I suppose if you're stupid enough to think that humans can change sex, then thinking that all embryos start off as female isn't such a stretch.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/01/2025 12:48

Because it's my choice not to respond to every spurious "point" you imagine you are making. It's just a predictable list of TRA talking points. Hope that helps.

LadyGreyson · 22/01/2025 12:43

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/01/2025 12:39

There's a discussion about this on Threads and it's biologically clueless. They're all at the "what about intersex" and "all embryos start off as female" stage.

I can believe it.

lcakethereforeIam · 22/01/2025 12:37

Once again we see the inability of tras to take responsibility for the inevitable fall out from their behaviour. They/them did this, not posters on MN.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/01/2025 12:33

Careful, apparently it makes you hard of thinking to have no interest in reading endless paragraphs of self serving waffle in FWR!

I had enough interest to read yours.

ArabellaScott · 22/01/2025 12:31

you are speaking from an ultra feminine looking woman's privilege.

Ostrich GIF
ArabellaScott · 22/01/2025 12:27

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

You wrote the post just above Eresh's, yes?

LadyGreyson · 22/01/2025 12:26

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 22/01/2025 12:21

Every person deserves civil liberties

Just to cut through the paragraphs of predictable, self serving waffle. Men invading women's spaces intended for their privacy, dignity and safety is not a "civil liberty".

LadyGreyson · 22/01/2025 12:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

themostspecialelfintheworkshop · 22/01/2025 10:15

Great post RedToothBrush.

I also am not sure Musk is really a Nazi. He's autistic I believe, so I think he can be very awkward in how he expresses himself.

I really liked the point about democracy. I do think the democrats and Labour don't seem to understand that they should listen to the electorate, they give out vibes of feeling they are superior to the electorate and needing votes is a rather grubby and annoying necessity.

We're in a world where voters felt Trump was the more democratic option, despite what happened when Biden won. They're not stupid, they're not less than human, they genuinely thought Trump was the option most likely to protect democracy. This was shown in polling. Let that sink in.

And I do believe the imposition of the fantasy men can become women and the gaslighting and coercive control in getting people to chant TWAW was probably the underlying reason why.

MarieDeGournay · 22/01/2025 09:40

RedToothBrush · Today 04:54
I do resent the hard of thinking that come here to berate women who are capable of holding two thoughts in their heads;.....

Thank you for your post which put into words many of the things I struggle to put into words.

Your very first point, about being capable of holding two thoughts - or even more! - in our heads at once is so relevant here: so many posters have clearly said I don't like Trump/I don't agree with Trump/I think Trump is a misogynist/I know Trump is not motivated by concern for women's rights etc etc etc BUT this EO has merit.

But like clockwork, along comes someone to say that to agree with the content of the EO is to be a right-wing Trump supporter and that's just what GC feminists are.🙄 It's like talking to the wall.

I appreciate all the thought you put into your post.

RedToothBrush · 22/01/2025 09:11

MalagaNights · 22/01/2025 07:58

Anyone posting that meme isnt paying enough attention to the Authoritarian Handbook either.

That's not my fault. It's not my fault you can no longer identify what a modern day American Nazi would look like and how and why they would be accepted. It's not about Jews.

Shrugs

ResisterOfTwaddleRex · 22/01/2025 09:00

I totally get the point about word count but when you think of how many efforts there are across multiple posts and threads to distort what is real and what we can all see if we bother to actually read, rather than make things up and pretend it's 2015 again, I'm not all that fussed. Those posts add up to a lot of words!

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 22/01/2025 08:35

IdylicDay · 22/01/2025 05:37

Agreed 100% but I fear your post is far too long for the hard of thinking who seem to hate long arguments and facts and links. Anything longer than 2 paragraphs is too much for their short concentration span.

As you said, its basically political purist. So tribal. If the right does it, then it must immediately be wrong. Anything the right does is wrong. Shallow, ignorant, politically purist political tribalism. As bad as the right is, these people are so shallow and closed minded they cannot think outside their tribalist pure bubbles. I pity them. I truly do. I think they genuinely believe they are the good guys, when in reality they are the bad guys locked up amongst themselves in their own closed political enclaves. So when they lose an election or when poll after poll after poll shows most disagree with them, they cannot handle it. Because they're so locked up in their closed political enclaves they don't realise they've shut themselves off from reality. At this point, if Trump/right wing said animal cruelty is bad, I expect them to come out and say animal cruelty is good. That is how pugilistic and politically tribalist they are.

I believe the abbreviated version is

That's nice dear, we've been warning you about Trump for ages but ya didn't listen, so just sit down . Stop telling us that boys can be girls cos we all know that's a load of bollocks and it's just an attempt to control women as per usual. It's boring and it's the same old shit as Trump; authoritarian nonsense. Come back when you've done a few history and politics lessons and understand what democracy actually is. Then we'll listen.

Better? Will that fit in a tweet that we are no longer allowed to use?

I normally prefer to play to any observers rather than worry about word count and having to do Trump level language for the hard of critical thinking though

MalagaNights · 22/01/2025 08:11

Britinme · 22/01/2025 08:06

There's a discussion about this on Threads and it's biologically clueless. They're all at the "what about intersex" and "all embryos start off as female" stage.

Depressingly I heard a podcast with Eric Weinstein who is touted as a great intellectual in the bro podcast world (into which I dip) and he argued the intersex and all embryos start female bullshit. Very eloquently and confidently. Also male and female brains.

Probably where some Reddit bros are getting their info.

Britinme · 22/01/2025 08:06

There's a discussion about this on Threads and it's biologically clueless. They're all at the "what about intersex" and "all embryos start off as female" stage.

MalagaNights · 22/01/2025 07:58

Nazis Everywhere.

x.com/BelannF/status/1881843886953562152?t=5RMV9d_0pUGr4e3hZfwnyQ&s=19

MalagaNights · 22/01/2025 07:54

RedToothBrush · 22/01/2025 04:54

I do resent the hard of thinking that come here to berate women who are capable of holding two thoughts in their heads;

  1. it is good that Trump has recognised reality and that no one actually believes in this shit. AND
  2. Trump has not done this because of women's rights, he has done it because it reflects majority opinion and because he understands it's a subject that undermines trust in the Democratic Party. Thus it's a useful tool to aid his own agenda.

Instead we get called all sorts of names and are accused of being far right. And told that 'you are either with us or against us' in an attempt to force women into being politically manipulated into having to support something they don't believe in and is against their own interests.

Which Trump and Co love because it creates a situation where the left are actively doing their work for them by actively and deliberately alienating and ostracising people who know gender identity is sexist made up bollocks. All without opening their own mouths once.

We are in this mess because people on the left, thought they could force gender religion upon us without being accountable and without public support. Which is as anti democratic as it gets.

This makes arguments that Trump and Co are the enemies of democracy unable to stick because of the erosion of trust and staggering level of hypocrisy.

Meanwhile here on MN free from the inability to think critically we've seen this situation coming a bloody mile off and repeatedly tried to warn politicians on the left it was a recipe for disaster and every time they said TWAW they were scoring an own goal. We got nothing but abuse for our trouble.

So we reached a state where we no longer give a fuck whether we were called Nazis. We knew we weren't because we could still string a coherent intelligent argument together, whilst being civil and rational about it without the need to throw out reciprocal threats and unfiltered abuse. We quoted Orwell and talked about the features and patterns of authoritarian behaviour. We reflected on historical patterns that ushered in conditions which allowed the collapse of democracy in bygone eras: a corrupt elite who had grown so arrogant that they now believed they were above listening to the people and could instead ignore accountability and ableness - because they knew best. We knew we were being not only civil but merely describing material reality and were able to actively demonstrate the harms being done. In short we knew the truth and that the truth will out.

However in the process of shouting that we were all Nazis, the left hand managed to somehow render the accusation meaningless. They successfully silenced many by making them believe their voices were worthless and they were powerless. The power of calling someone a Nazi has been reduced to nothing as it had been used so inappropriately to the point that it no longer held fear of social pariahhood. Everyone had been falsely accused, and knew that they were not Nazis and the accusation was merely a way to try and control them and silence them.

Thus allowing the actual fascists who met the definition of the word in multiple ways to gain traction. And we've now reached a point where someone can stand on stage and do a deliberate Nazi salute to be able to brazen it out openly, because the fuckwits didn't listen to us here. T

We are The Cassandras.

We are still not Nazis nor Nazi sympathisers. We still don't like Trump and don't remotely think he will do anything for women. Because we know that authoritarians of all persuasions come for women first and erode their rights and freedoms. That's because we've been identifying the authoritatism of both the left and the right allies along and continue to do so.

Because we are capable of holding more than one thought in our heads and recognising the world is a bit more complicated than the fantastical dross that gender evangelists like to spout.

All you have to offer is more name-calling and you wonder why we all stand here going 'and?' in response to Trump.

Why?

Because 'we told you so', long before this ever happened. We saw this coming a mile off and you did nothing. And now you stand there shouting insults into the void. No one cares because they stopped listening to you long ago when you told us we had to go along with the make believe no matter how much it harmed us and failed to engage when we presented the evidence of our real life problems.

You made yourselves irrelevant and even now you can't figure it out about how we got here. Cos it's always everyone else's fault but yours. You had the spin to avoid accountability and suddenly wonder why the opposition gets away with worse.

So you carry on shouting at us and telling us how we are to blame for everything and how evil we are.

We can all see it for what it is: 'fiddling whilst Rome burns'.

We were never the enemy. You made us out to be the enemy. We said look out behind you. You ignored us and focused all your attention on continuing to persecute anyone who disagree with you.

You let the real threat just waltz in through the open city gates. And now the city burns. All we are doing now is stand here watching the winds of change fan the flames knowing there's probably little we can do to stop it as we've passed that point.

I'm so over justifying my position and the position of so many women on MN. We don't have to. Material reality holds true.

It's not us who needs to get our house in order to regain credibility.

Engage your brain. And fast. Before it really is too late and there's nothing left to salvage from the mess you created.

Men can't become women. They never could and they never will. Stop being misogynist creeps intent on upholding the bullshit law that states : "men are whatever they say they are, women are whatever men tell them".

Then maybe we'll start to give the slightest fuck about what you have to say again.

May I take this opportunity to quietly remind you that leaders in a democracy are there to serve the people. Until then, it's not us who isn't on your side. It's you that's not on our side. We are not here to serve your own self interest.

This is all mostly true except for the great piece of hypocrisy where you start calling Elon Musk a Nazi.

It's just you throwing the same shit that's being thrown at you at someone else. You are playing the same stupid game.

"I'm not a Nazi. He's a Nazi!!!"

Everyone had been falsely accused, and knew that they were not Nazis and the accusation was merely a way to try and control them and silence them.
Spot your problem here?

Musk believes in free speech and is against gender ideology.
..er he just like you then??
At least in the view of the TRAs and democrats.

It's bloody obvious he was awkwardly throwing 'love' to the audience and that if he was a 'Nazi' he'd keep it a bit quieter.

Even the ADL have agreed it's not a Nazi salute and everyone should calm down. But people don't want to calm down they want to spot Nazis. You and the TRAs. Whether it's you or Elon Musk.

It's a cheap gotcha and it's as tiresome and as ineffective as calling you a Nazi. I'm surprised you can't see that as you accuse others of being 'hard of thinking'?

Maybe we should all agree to save the term Nazi for actual Nazis?

And I'm not sure who the 'we' is throughout your post? I thought FWR wasn't a 'hive mind '? I'm here & I'm tired of being called a Nazi whether it's because I think there are 2 sexes or because I think it's bloody obvious that Musk is an awkward weirdo and not a Nazi.

They call you a Nazi, you call him a Nazi, I'm a Nazi sympathiser?

It's a stupid game which undermines your point.

I actually agree with some of the TRAs on here that's it's fascinating to watch some on FWR try to agree with the rights policy on one point while still playing the old familiar game of goodies and baddies, with all the same tropes and name calling of the TRAs and the far left, but throwing that at someone else to ensure your On the Right Side Status.

Just have the confidence to agree with some policies disagree with others and drop the 'They are literally Nazis' game.

As you said no one cares anymore even when you say it.

IdylicDay · 22/01/2025 05:37

RedToothBrush · 22/01/2025 04:54

I do resent the hard of thinking that come here to berate women who are capable of holding two thoughts in their heads;

  1. it is good that Trump has recognised reality and that no one actually believes in this shit. AND
  2. Trump has not done this because of women's rights, he has done it because it reflects majority opinion and because he understands it's a subject that undermines trust in the Democratic Party. Thus it's a useful tool to aid his own agenda.

Instead we get called all sorts of names and are accused of being far right. And told that 'you are either with us or against us' in an attempt to force women into being politically manipulated into having to support something they don't believe in and is against their own interests.

Which Trump and Co love because it creates a situation where the left are actively doing their work for them by actively and deliberately alienating and ostracising people who know gender identity is sexist made up bollocks. All without opening their own mouths once.

We are in this mess because people on the left, thought they could force gender religion upon us without being accountable and without public support. Which is as anti democratic as it gets.

This makes arguments that Trump and Co are the enemies of democracy unable to stick because of the erosion of trust and staggering level of hypocrisy.

Meanwhile here on MN free from the inability to think critically we've seen this situation coming a bloody mile off and repeatedly tried to warn politicians on the left it was a recipe for disaster and every time they said TWAW they were scoring an own goal. We got nothing but abuse for our trouble.

So we reached a state where we no longer give a fuck whether we were called Nazis. We knew we weren't because we could still string a coherent intelligent argument together, whilst being civil and rational about it without the need to throw out reciprocal threats and unfiltered abuse. We quoted Orwell and talked about the features and patterns of authoritarian behaviour. We reflected on historical patterns that ushered in conditions which allowed the collapse of democracy in bygone eras: a corrupt elite who had grown so arrogant that they now believed they were above listening to the people and could instead ignore accountability and ableness - because they knew best. We knew we were being not only civil but merely describing material reality and were able to actively demonstrate the harms being done. In short we knew the truth and that the truth will out.

However in the process of shouting that we were all Nazis, the left hand managed to somehow render the accusation meaningless. They successfully silenced many by making them believe their voices were worthless and they were powerless. The power of calling someone a Nazi has been reduced to nothing as it had been used so inappropriately to the point that it no longer held fear of social pariahhood. Everyone had been falsely accused, and knew that they were not Nazis and the accusation was merely a way to try and control them and silence them.

Thus allowing the actual fascists who met the definition of the word in multiple ways to gain traction. And we've now reached a point where someone can stand on stage and do a deliberate Nazi salute to be able to brazen it out openly, because the fuckwits didn't listen to us here. T

We are The Cassandras.

We are still not Nazis nor Nazi sympathisers. We still don't like Trump and don't remotely think he will do anything for women. Because we know that authoritarians of all persuasions come for women first and erode their rights and freedoms. That's because we've been identifying the authoritatism of both the left and the right allies along and continue to do so.

Because we are capable of holding more than one thought in our heads and recognising the world is a bit more complicated than the fantastical dross that gender evangelists like to spout.

All you have to offer is more name-calling and you wonder why we all stand here going 'and?' in response to Trump.

Why?

Because 'we told you so', long before this ever happened. We saw this coming a mile off and you did nothing. And now you stand there shouting insults into the void. No one cares because they stopped listening to you long ago when you told us we had to go along with the make believe no matter how much it harmed us and failed to engage when we presented the evidence of our real life problems.

You made yourselves irrelevant and even now you can't figure it out about how we got here. Cos it's always everyone else's fault but yours. You had the spin to avoid accountability and suddenly wonder why the opposition gets away with worse.

So you carry on shouting at us and telling us how we are to blame for everything and how evil we are.

We can all see it for what it is: 'fiddling whilst Rome burns'.

We were never the enemy. You made us out to be the enemy. We said look out behind you. You ignored us and focused all your attention on continuing to persecute anyone who disagree with you.

You let the real threat just waltz in through the open city gates. And now the city burns. All we are doing now is stand here watching the winds of change fan the flames knowing there's probably little we can do to stop it as we've passed that point.

I'm so over justifying my position and the position of so many women on MN. We don't have to. Material reality holds true.

It's not us who needs to get our house in order to regain credibility.

Engage your brain. And fast. Before it really is too late and there's nothing left to salvage from the mess you created.

Men can't become women. They never could and they never will. Stop being misogynist creeps intent on upholding the bullshit law that states : "men are whatever they say they are, women are whatever men tell them".

Then maybe we'll start to give the slightest fuck about what you have to say again.

May I take this opportunity to quietly remind you that leaders in a democracy are there to serve the people. Until then, it's not us who isn't on your side. It's you that's not on our side. We are not here to serve your own self interest.

Agreed 100% but I fear your post is far too long for the hard of thinking who seem to hate long arguments and facts and links. Anything longer than 2 paragraphs is too much for their short concentration span.

As you said, its basically political purist. So tribal. If the right does it, then it must immediately be wrong. Anything the right does is wrong. Shallow, ignorant, politically purist political tribalism. As bad as the right is, these people are so shallow and closed minded they cannot think outside their tribalist pure bubbles. I pity them. I truly do. I think they genuinely believe they are the good guys, when in reality they are the bad guys locked up amongst themselves in their own closed political enclaves. So when they lose an election or when poll after poll after poll shows most disagree with them, they cannot handle it. Because they're so locked up in their closed political enclaves they don't realise they've shut themselves off from reality. At this point, if Trump/right wing said animal cruelty is bad, I expect them to come out and say animal cruelty is good. That is how pugilistic and politically tribalist they are.

Iwishihadariver · 22/01/2025 05:21

And that RedToothBrush is how to do FWR Stormfront. 💪🍾

Swipe left for the next trending thread