Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Feminised words

63 replies

Davros · 24/10/2024 10:34

I've been pondering this. Why are we no longer supposed to call female acting people actresses or female funny people comediennes but stating pronouns is now possibly mainstream? It seems somewhat opposed ideas

OP posts:
Snowypeaks · 25/10/2024 13:26

MarieDeGournay · 25/10/2024 13:13

You've just reminded me, when I first moved to France, a friend told me that if somebody says 'Madame..ou Mademoiselle?' to reply 'Madame' in a very firm no-nonsense voice, although I wasn't married, because 'it establishes the right power dynamics'Smile

😀

MarieDeGournay · 25/10/2024 13:13

Snowypeaks · 25/10/2024 11:51

Definitely about status and respectability. Like French women addressed as madame after they reach a certain age, older German women would also be addressed as Frau. Think it's the same in Spanish and Italian as well.
German women are generally nowadays referred to as Frauen, however old they are and whether married or not. I don't think people use Fraulein (can't do the umlaut on my keyboard) for a grown woman anymore.

You've just reminded me, when I first moved to France, a friend told me that if somebody says 'Madame..ou Mademoiselle?' to reply 'Madame' in a very firm no-nonsense voice, although I wasn't married, because 'it establishes the right power dynamics'Smile

Sorciere1 · 25/10/2024 13:10

MagpiePi · 24/10/2024 12:12

The phasing out of female versions of professions has been around for longer than preferred pronouns, so I don't think they are related.

I think that for people who make a point of announcing their pronouns, they consider their pronouns (and associated beliefs) to be the most important thing about them.

A woman who tells you she is an actor, author, doctor or lorry driver is just a woman with a job and her sex is not important in how well or badly she does that job. A man who tells you he is an actress is more concerned with being considered female than with the nature of his job.

It ultimately comes from Latin. About 90% of English words of 2 syllables or more derive from Latin or Greek. With the Normans a lot of Latin came into English via Norman French.
Latin has 3 genders: Masculine, Feminine, Neuter.
The -or ending used for a lot of profession words , has the feminine ending -trix
actor is (m) used for men. actrix (f) used for women....actress
doctor (m), ...doctrix (f) ....doctor, dottoressa etc
nutrix (f) nurse
auctor (m) author, auctrix (f)
It has nothing to do with belittling women. Amelia Earheart was called an aviatrix as the Latin was aviator. A female US senator should be a Senatrix. Interestingly the Latin word for citizen , civis can be (m) or (f), even better sacerdos priestess/priest can also be (f) or (m).
I like having words for women! The idea that we need to use the male form to be 'normal' is depressing
PS: seamstress isn't Latin, it's supposedly Old English and the male version is seamster. I do know brewer is (m) and brewster, spinster, baxter (baker) are all (f). Great profession names!

SensibleSigma · 25/10/2024 13:05

More terms have become neutral, which is good.

Vicars still get a fair amount of ‘lady vicar’, though only from people who don’t generally go to church.

I like the specifically female terms myself- we are moving into an era where an actress of the calibre of Helena Bonham Carter can embrace it. We can be proud of our identity, just like anyone else.

Snowypeaks · 25/10/2024 11:51

MarieDeGournay · 25/10/2024 11:45

Now that we're chasing words back through history.. one of my fave hobbies tooSmile

I noticed that in early 19th century documents the Reverend Mother [i.e. Boss Nun] of a convent was addressed as Mrs Smith, Mrs being a term of respect, not of marital status.

But then again, was Mrs Bridges in Upstairs Downtstairs married? I think not.
Similar use of Mrs as a title of respect for her job?

Definitely about status and respectability. Like French women addressed as madame after they reach a certain age, older German women would also be addressed as Frau. Think it's the same in Spanish and Italian as well.
German women are generally nowadays referred to as Frauen, however old they are and whether married or not. I don't think people use Fraulein (can't do the umlaut on my keyboard) for a grown woman anymore.

MarieDeGournay · 25/10/2024 11:45

Now that we're chasing words back through history.. one of my fave hobbies tooSmile

I noticed that in early 19th century documents the Reverend Mother [i.e. Boss Nun] of a convent was addressed as Mrs Smith, Mrs being a term of respect, not of marital status.

But then again, was Mrs Bridges in Upstairs Downtstairs married? I think not.
Similar use of Mrs as a title of respect for her job?

hatboxes · 25/10/2024 09:45

Snowypeaks · 24/10/2024 19:21

No, I am not a languages graduate - and I am horribly envious of you now! I'm just generally interested, purely as a lay person, in how languages develop and are related to each other.

Same here, I find it fascinating. Also my dad was a linguistics professor, so I grew up with conversations about such things.

hepsitemiz · 24/10/2024 19:30

hatboxes · 24/10/2024 11:55

I recall, though can’t remember my sources, discussions around the word actress in particular, that one reason for the move away from it was that it had, at least historically and to some extent today, derogatory undertones. From the time when it wasn’t seen as an entirely ‘respectable’ profession for women.

it could be a character slur in the way that actor never was.

of course it wouldn’t be an issue if women were simply respected.

Edited

Interesting. In the manner of the quip “as the actress said to the bishop”…

Grepes · 24/10/2024 19:29

hatboxes · 24/10/2024 16:10

Midwife is an interesting one. I can’t imagine midspouse ever catching on

My midwife was a man and was just called a midwife.

I have noticed older men using the terms ‘male nurse’ and ‘female doctor’, which I hate.

MayaKovskaya · 24/10/2024 19:27

Snowypeaks · 24/10/2024 19:24

Holly Walsh, the comedian, did a dissertation or thesis or something on medieval marginalia - apparently monks would get so bored copying out manuscripts all day they would draw/write silly or rude stuff in the margins! Presumably they were confident that whichever rich lord was going to own the book wouldn't actually read it...

Edited

That's so true! They copied for hours so must have got bored! Some of the illuminated manuscripts have somewhat racy pictures, too! 😉

MayaKovskaya · 24/10/2024 19:25

Snowypeaks · 24/10/2024 19:21

No, I am not a languages graduate - and I am horribly envious of you now! I'm just generally interested, purely as a lay person, in how languages develop and are related to each other.

Such a fascinating subject - also the points on this thread about the feminisation of words, and how that diminishes status.

Snowypeaks · 24/10/2024 19:24

Holly Walsh, the comedian, did a dissertation or thesis or something on medieval marginalia - apparently monks would get so bored copying out manuscripts all day they would draw/write silly or rude stuff in the margins! Presumably they were confident that whichever rich lord was going to own the book wouldn't actually read it...

Snowypeaks · 24/10/2024 19:21

MayaKovskaya · 24/10/2024 19:10

Yes, I did! I love those languages and suspect you do too - are you a similar graduate?

No, I am not a languages graduate - and I am horribly envious of you now! I'm just generally interested, purely as a lay person, in how languages develop and are related to each other.

MayaKovskaya · 24/10/2024 19:10

Snowypeaks · 24/10/2024 19:09

It is!
Medieval languages must have been a fascinating area. Did you specialise in Germanic languages?

Yes, I did! I love those languages and suspect you do too - are you a similar graduate?

MayaKovskaya · 24/10/2024 19:09

On another note, I saw an old document recently with details of women in WW1 carrying coal, counter parts to coalmen, and they were called "coal lasses", but I suspect that was regional.
I'm glad "doctoress" didn't continue as a term!

Snowypeaks · 24/10/2024 19:09

MayaKovskaya · 24/10/2024 19:07

Yes, that's true. Although my knowledge comes from my studies of Medieval languages and really was intended just to make the point about the word midwife.
I think it's a nice term with a good meaning !

It is!
Medieval languages must have been a fascinating area. Did you specialise in Germanic languages?

MayaKovskaya · 24/10/2024 19:07

Snowypeaks · 24/10/2024 19:04

Weib was slightly derogatory in the same way that "woman" used to be slightly derogatory. (Kids taught to say a lady and a man, the nice lady etc...)
And your example of women of substance being described as Damen somewhat proves my point.

Yes, that's true. Although my knowledge comes from my studies of Medieval languages and really was intended just to make the point about the word midwife.
I think it's a nice term with a good meaning !

Snowypeaks · 24/10/2024 19:04

MayaKovskaya · 24/10/2024 18:57

Although there's no evidence that this is derogatory, as wife meant every woman. Dame was used if a woman had an extra responsibility. Some medieval women farmers were "Dame". Or if they ran a school.

Weib was slightly derogatory in the same way that "woman" used to be slightly derogatory. (Kids taught to say a lady and a man, the nice lady etc...)
And your example of women of substance being described as Damen somewhat proves my point.

MayaKovskaya · 24/10/2024 18:57

Snowypeaks · 24/10/2024 18:53

In German Weib = old-fashioned, slightly derogatory word for woman.
As opposed to Dame which means lady.

Although there's no evidence that this is derogatory, as wife meant every woman. Dame was used if a woman had an extra responsibility. Some medieval women farmers were "Dame". Or if they ran a school.

MayaKovskaya · 24/10/2024 18:55

hatboxes · 24/10/2024 18:29

Thank you, very helpful. So wife refers refers to the mother, not the helper.

Yes. Wife just means woman, so in this case, the woman in labour. "Mid" being "with".
That use of "wife" also remains in the original wedding ceremony - "I now pronounce you man and wife" meaning they are a man and woman together. All women were "wife".

Snowypeaks · 24/10/2024 18:53

In German Weib = old-fashioned, slightly derogatory word for woman.
As opposed to Dame which means lady.

hatboxes · 24/10/2024 18:29

MayaKovskaya · 24/10/2024 16:49

Midwife is an old English term meaning "with woman". Your job is to be with the woman and help her. So a man could be called a midwife as it's not the job title that's gendered.

Thank you, very helpful. So wife refers refers to the mother, not the helper.

MayaKovskaya · 24/10/2024 16:49

hatboxes · 24/10/2024 16:10

Midwife is an interesting one. I can’t imagine midspouse ever catching on

Midwife is an old English term meaning "with woman". Your job is to be with the woman and help her. So a man could be called a midwife as it's not the job title that's gendered.

SootherSue · 24/10/2024 16:46

menopausalmare · 24/10/2024 13:31

I always thought that adding -ess or -ette onto the end off a word to make it feminine belittles the role. I remember my history teacher telling me that when men and women campaigned for the vote, they were collectively called suffragists. When men got the women didn't, the women were called suffragettes, almost a two- finger salute to them.

The suffragists and suffragettes were different branches of women's rights campaigners. Suffragists, who believed in non-violent protest, were the first group to be formed. Suffragettes were an offshoot of the suffragists who grew frustrated by the slow progress of non-violent protest and wanted more direct action. But "suffragette" was indeed coined to belittle the suffragettes.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-42879161

Millicent Fawcett and Emmeline Pankhurst.

100 Women: Suffragists or suffragettes - who won women the vote?

On the centenary of some British women winning the vote, 100 Women looks at the difference between the suffragists and the suffragettes.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-42879161

MagpiePi · 24/10/2024 16:38

unmemorableusername · 24/10/2024 12:50

I distinctly acting from other gendered title professions because actresses are specifically playing female roles.

It is therefore different from what an actor does.

Whereas a waiter/ waitress does the same job.

There are lots of instances where roles are played by the opposite sex. A woman playing Prince Charming in a pantomime could still correctly be called an actress, just as a man playing an ugly sister would be an actor.