Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Labour is betraying women

331 replies

IwantToRetire · 18/09/2024 00:41

. . . If Starmer’s government has achieved so much depressing stuff in 71 days, roughly 4 per cent of the way into a possible 5-year term, what they might achieve by the end of it fills me with dread. I believe that Labour showed us, and in some instances told us, what they would do, or not do, to ensure the continued erosion of women’s rights, and they are doing exactly what they said. Why some feminist women, seemingly in a blind bond to Labour, didn’t believe them escapes me. It also infuriates me that they think Labour deserve a bit more rope to hang us with.

Some prominent left-wing women, before the election, pleaded with us to trust Labour and allow them space to make the right decisions. They suggested that it was wrong to focus on the single issue of gender ideology, because women would benefit in so many other ways under a Labour government.

I wonder, did they envisage this Labour government? The one maintaining unequal benefits, placing violent men amongst their female victims and keeping the blurred line between gender and sex embedded in law? I can understand if those women were now as dismayed as the rest of us at what they are seeing, but instead they appear to be spinning for Labour, suggesting the violent men aren’t really being released or excusing it by blaming the Tories. They suggest we should wait and see what happens, keep the faith, trust the process. After many years of being told that women are influencing Labour “behind the scenes” my faith in that has gone.

If you are a feminist woman openly critical of Labour you may now be accused of “right wing drift”. This is nonsense. Instead, should scrutiny not be focused on how far Labour have drifted from the left? This is where condemnation should be aimed. . . .

NB - these are only some paragraphs from the article - you can read the whole article here - https://thecritic.co.uk/labour-is-betraying-women/

Labour is betraying women | Jean Hatchet | The Critic Magazine

The outrage many women are feeling at some of Labour’s initial acts in government, which will deeply affect women’s lives, is loud and righteous. The past week has been particularly egregious…

https://thecritic.co.uk/labour-is-betraying-women

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
ResisterOfTwaddleRex · 18/09/2024 11:13

There's been a real silence from those who merrily scolded us on these boards since the election. Says it all.

jcakey · 18/09/2024 11:11

If you can't define what a woman is, that will feed into all of your policies.

Were any impact assessments done on female victims prior to the release of (it appears) predominantly male prisoners? How many women are affected by the winter fuel cuts? This article suggests none of that was even considered or was just glossed over.

Even things like the inheritance tax reforms, you'd have thought, should be looked at from a male/ female perspective. Women spend their lifetimes earning far less than men (in what should be called the sex pay gap) and there is a huge disparity in pensions. I'd have thought inheritance was one of the few ways some lucky women might be fortunate enough to come into some money. Women shoulder the vast majority of the care burden in this country and I certainly wouldn't begrudge a woman (or a man, it should be said!) who has - for example - sacrificed her career and time to care for elderly parents. She's likely to have saved the state considerable care costs too.

Not to mention the fact many of the careers Labour has promised to prop up with taxpayers' money are male-dominated ones. Get Britain building again? That'll be male-dominated construction companies, then. Get the train drivers and junior doctors back to work? I believe both of those are male-dominated professions too - in the case of the train drivers, very much so.

But if you don't know what a woman is, perhaps you don't notice this stuff.

TempestTost · 18/09/2024 11:01

Anastomosisrex · 18/09/2024 10:22

I don't always see eye to eye with this writer on many things, but on this yes, I agree. Women here explained repeatedly, but were told they were all wrong. We're stuck with this bunch now for five years, and already things are worse for women than they were under a clapped out Tory govt. Which is saying one hell of a lot.

If the 25% council tax relief goes for single occupancy as threatened that is also going to directly hammer women and children. Many of those single occupiers will be single mothers.

Ithink this is an interesting point.

I don't know that I'd say people were crazy to vote Labour, the fact is none of the options seemed great, all choices were kind of a compromise for most voters, I imagine.

But if anyone looks back, there were women on her who pointed out again and again that the hopes some seemed to have for Labour that involved throwing money around were pie in the sky, and not a very good reason to tick that box. For some reason some seemed to be convinced that Labour would somehow fund all these programs and get public infrastructure back up to speed, all without substantially raising taxes or depressing productivity.

Well of course they couldn't do that, and I wouldn't blame them for that either. Some of the lack of funds is down to the previous government (some is even down to the last Labour government), but also a lot due to world circumstances, every western nation is in the same boat. COVID, and the kind of response the public seemed to demand fucked the economy everywhere.

But if anyone expected them to balance out their lack of sense on identity politics with increased public funding etc they were seriously deluded.

Thelnebriati · 18/09/2024 10:52

De we really have to sound the same warning bells about Reform now? People didn't listen to us about Labour either.

DeCaray · 18/09/2024 10:33

I can't think why anyone would have voted for Labour and I can only think it's because I of protest votes against the Tories.

Both are two cheeks of the same arse.

Hopefully the mess Starmer is making will make people wake up and vote Reform or another Party that isn't Labour or Conservative as both have run the country into the ground.

Anastomosisrex · 18/09/2024 10:22

I don't always see eye to eye with this writer on many things, but on this yes, I agree. Women here explained repeatedly, but were told they were all wrong. We're stuck with this bunch now for five years, and already things are worse for women than they were under a clapped out Tory govt. Which is saying one hell of a lot.

If the 25% council tax relief goes for single occupancy as threatened that is also going to directly hammer women and children. Many of those single occupiers will be single mothers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread