Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Cass Review 'flawed' according to Yale Law School?

29 replies

teawamutu · 03/07/2024 09:53

I saw this and not being a scientist, I've no idea if this is sound analysis or politically motivated - or a mixture of both.

https://www.thenational.scot/news/24425388.cass-review-contains-serious-flaws-according-yale-law-school/

Hoping there are MNers better informed than I am who can break it down.

Cass Review 'obscures key findings' and 'misrepresents data', finds Yale Law School

THE Cass Review “obscures key findings, misrepresents its own data, and is rife with misapplications of the scientific method”, according to a…

https://www.thenational.scot/news/24425388.cass-review-contains-serious-flaws-according-yale-law-school

OP posts:
UtopiaPlanitia · 03/07/2024 10:08

Reasoned argument from evidence is part of the scientific method but I feel that the American attempts to refute the findings of the Cass Report have failed to reach that standard - they often read as ideologically motivated attempts to besmirch the research done by the Cass Review which is a great pity because the healthcare of children deserves better than ideology-based treatments.

teawamutu · 03/07/2024 10:04

Interesting. Despite the self-declared remit they seem only to have written about the importance of medically transing children.

OP posts:
OvaHere · 03/07/2024 10:02

Further info about their work.

In the face of a recent unprecedented wave of state legislation that has targeted the well-being of gender-expansive youth, faculty members from the Yale Law School, Child Study Center, Department of Psychiatry, and Department of Pediatrics came together to synthesize and disseminate scientific and legal knowledge in support of LGBTQ+ youth and their families.
Along with exclusionary measures in school and in sports, new laws have sought to deny access to well-established, lifesaving medical care. During the first half of 2022 alone, 20 states have introduced medical bans with worsening punishments directed towards healthcare providers and parents. The new laws criminalize standard medical care and interfere in relationships among providers and families, vetoing shared healthcare decisions.
In our cross-departmental and interdisciplinary work, we marshal scientific and legal knowledge to lay bare the misinformation used to justify these medical bans. Our team includes specialists in law, child psychology, child and adolescent psychiatry, pediatric endocrinology, and adolescent medicine. Our detailed, evidence-based reports inform litigators, policymakers, journalists, and medical professionals with a common language that upholds the integrity of science, law and public policy. Joining us are colleagues nationwide, including Dr. Laura Kuper (University of Texas Southwestern) and Dr. Hussein Abdul-Latif (University of Alabama Birmingham).

OvaHere · 03/07/2024 09:59

This is a link to the Yale report
https://law.yale.edu/yls-today/news/report-addresses-key-issues-legal-battles-over-gender-affirming-health-care

It was written by an activist group within Yale called 'The Integrity Project'
https://law.yale.edu/centers-workshops/integrity-project

"Underserved and marginalized people are harmed most by the absence of sound science in law. U.S. states recently have adopted a number of measures based on scientific misinformation, in reproductive health, gender-affirming care and HIV prevention. The Integrity Project acts quickly to correct the scientific record and oppose these harmful measures."

transgender flags in a row on grass

Report Addresses Key Issues in Legal Battles over Gender-Affirming Health Care

A new report from The Integrity Project provides an evidence-based critique of a recent independent review that has become central to U.S. litigation regarding health care for transgender youth.

https://law.yale.edu/yls-today/news/report-addresses-key-issues-legal-battles-over-gender-affirming-health-care