Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Why are ITV lying about transmen in prisons?

57 replies

WifeOfTiresias · 11/06/2024 21:43

Just watched the latest episode of Emmerdale. Matty, the transman character, has been in court charged with a stabbing, and at the end is shown being transported to a men's prison surrounded by jeering men who will clearly be preying on them at the earliest opportunity.

But why has this been written into the plot? It simply isn't true that transmen are housed in male prisons - precisely because it isn't safe for them! Even the most basic research would have told the scriptwriters that this doesn't happen so what are they playing at? Looks like the latest attempt by soap writers to paint trans people as eternal victims. I seem to recall Hollyoaks had a transwoman in a female prison being beaten up by the "nasty" women - something that has never ever actually happened! Though the reverse has happened plenty of times and has been studiously ignored Angry

OP posts:
WifeOfTiresias · 12/06/2024 00:16

Gosh I'm stunned! Was sure I had read that transmen were not sent to men's prisons. It's horrifying that they are actually!

Though I'm guessing that this only happens rarely or wouldn't we be hearing about a huge numbers of attacks as they would be incredibly vulnerable. Or are attacks happening but reporting of them being suppressed?

Surely they wouldn't be forced into it as being actual biological women there should be no problem housing them with their own sex?

OP posts:
Karensalright · 11/06/2024 23:36

Good point they can still state they are a biological female. It makes no sense to me that a trans man would be sent to a male prison against their will, just don't buy this at all.

Thelnebriati · 11/06/2024 23:12

Karensalright
Surely if they have a GRC they can just not mention it?

No because a GRC gives the holder a new birth certificate. They don't have to show the GRC to anyone.

RandySavage · 11/06/2024 22:35

or trans back again. It only takes a minute.

Karensalright · 11/06/2024 22:20

Surely if they have a GRC they can just not mention it?

SheepDog1 · 11/06/2024 22:12

Unfortunately if they have a GRC they are put jn a men's prison , I worked in an area that means I have access to this information. Saying this , this was around 4 years ago so could have changed now.

Karensalright · 11/06/2024 22:04

Yes i noticed this. Maybe the plight of a trans woman accidentally stabbing a transphobe was too risky for the writers, as it might upset the TRA’s.

Swipe left for the next trending thread