Active discussions

Please or to access all these features

Talk
Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Feminism: chat

Original poster

DD14 is regularly assumed to be trans/NB/a boy - any advice on how she can respond?

139 replies

whatsinanumber · 15/05/2024 16:48

She is tall with short hair and a low voice and only wears trousers / shorts etc plus has always liked stuff that people (even in 2024) seem more likely to associate with boys - football, techie stuff etc. She regularly gets assumed to be NB or a boy and, if she says she's a girl, is often then assumed to be a trans girl.

On the whole, she's not bothered if people assume she's a boy and won't bother correcting them but quite a few times people have looked surprised / affronted to find her in a girls loo (or other girl's/woman's space) and she finds this embarrassing. She's asked me what to say to people when this happens. She doesn't want to be confrontational or make anyone fell awkward because she thinks it's not coming from an unkind place i.e. people are either genuinely confused or just trying to not offend. So, any advice on a quick way of knocking this on the head and not turning it into 'a thing'? Thank you.

OP posts:
Original poster
whatsinanumber · 15/05/2024 17:24

@lifeturnsonadime agreed - the gender ideology stuff (and related gender stereotypes) really feels like a step backwards.

I'm not 'worried' about her as such in the girls toilets but she finds it awkward because I guess she's a bit of a rule follower and thinks people are judging her for being in a space she's not meant to be in and she wants to find an unobtrusive way to say she belongs there. And yes, they genuinely don't recognise her to be a young girl. She does look and sound a lot older than she is.

OP posts:
Pinkypinkyplonk · 15/05/2024 17:24

@whatsinanumber you’re right she shouldn’t have to!
Some girls at her age do tho. I guess she just needs to find a little something that stops people making the mistake, but only if it bothers her

Soontobe60 · 15/05/2024 17:23

whatsinanumber · 15/05/2024 17:04

Or they will ask what her pronouns are (when they haven't asked other people in the room / group). Again not a huge problem but I think she feels when she says she/her, she's then assumed to be a trans girl

Who are these people who go around asking other people their pronouns? because IRL, this doesn’t happen. Ive never in my 64 years seen a tomboy being challenged in the girl’s toilets, and Id argue that for the overwhelming majority of time, people know if someone is male or female.

Original poster
whatsinanumber · 15/05/2024 17:21

Pinkypinkyplonk · 15/05/2024 17:19

I guess if it bothers her, she could wear some pretty earrings or a little mascara. Sorry you don’t say how old she is

pretty earrings and mascara really aren't her thing - she just wouldn't wear them and I don't feel she should have to. She is 14.

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 15/05/2024 17:21

God I hate this gender ideology though. Wasn't it lovely when girls could wear and do what they liked without being questioned!

lifeturnsonadime · 15/05/2024 17:20

whatsinanumber · 15/05/2024 17:15

I suspect it won't stop happening for a good while. She's been through puberty now (at least she has breasts and her periods started a few months ago) but because she doesn't wear tight clothes and she's got quite an athletic build and quite narrow hips, her body shape isn't immediately obvious. So I can see it continuing to be an issue.

Show quote history

My daughter was often assumed to be a trans boy or none binary rather than a girl. For a while she thought she was one.

Now if errors happen (which more rarely do post puberty) she laughs it off.

Things like. They are my clothes not boy's clothes.

Or not all girls have to be on tik tok and wear make up etc.

I doubt anyone would approach a young teenage girl in the female toilets seriously believing they are a boy though, is that what you are concerned about?

Pinkypinkyplonk · 15/05/2024 17:19

I guess if it bothers her, she could wear some pretty earrings or a little mascara. Sorry you don’t say how old she is

Pistachiovillian · 15/05/2024 17:19

My DP still goes through this in her 40s and has a lot of anxiety around it. I feel for your DD. And I hate the pronouns thing. Could she confidently just say 'I'm a girl'when asked that sort of thung?

Original poster
whatsinanumber · 15/05/2024 17:15

heathspeedwell · 15/05/2024 17:08

I'm tall and people often thought I was a boy in my early teens, but as girls get older then there's very rarely any confusion.

Do you think it would reassure her to know that it will stop happening as soon as she's a bit older?

I suspect it won't stop happening for a good while. She's been through puberty now (at least she has breasts and her periods started a few months ago) but because she doesn't wear tight clothes and she's got quite an athletic build and quite narrow hips, her body shape isn't immediately obvious. So I can see it continuing to be an issue.

OP posts:
ToThineOwnSelfBe · 15/05/2024 17:09

Oh, that's a challenge. I have that same problem from the other direction, DS12 has long, long beautiful blond hair and rather delicate features and is relatively small. He's assumed to be a girl about 85% of the time. Like your DD, he doesn't really care and is confident to say, "I'm a boy actually" to people, even to other kids. I might encourage him to say he's male as that is (incrementally) clearer these days.

I hadn't actually considered what the reaction in the gents would be if they thought a young girl was in their toilets. Might be worth me discussing it with him now before it actually happens. Thanks for the food for thought, OP. I'm sorry I don't have a more helpful answer and sad that we have to even be having these conversations.

heathspeedwell · 15/05/2024 17:08

I'm tall and people often thought I was a boy in my early teens, but as girls get older then there's very rarely any confusion.

Do you think it would reassure her to know that it will stop happening as soon as she's a bit older?

Original poster
whatsinanumber · 15/05/2024 17:04

Or they will ask what her pronouns are (when they haven't asked other people in the room / group). Again not a huge problem but I think she feels when she says she/her, she's then assumed to be a trans girl

OP posts:
Original poster
whatsinanumber · 15/05/2024 17:02

I don't think she is super bothered, she was sort of laughing about it earlier. But I think she's worried that it has the potential to be awkward. The only time she was actually upset was at an event where a marshall tapped her on the shoulder when she was walking into the ladies and pointed her towards the mens.

But otherwise, it's more like, she'll be hanging out with a male friend and they'll introduce her to another boy or boys as 'a friend' and said boys will sort of do blokey hellos (fist bumps or whatever) and then when she says her name (which is obviously a girls' name) go all weird and awkward for a bit and say "ooooh".

Often happens in shops too when I'm with her and people will refer to her as 'your son'.

OP posts:
Revelatio · 15/05/2024 16:57

Unless they’re saying anything to her in the loo, I would just ignore.

I can’t believe people are so rude to her and keep badgering her, asking if she’s a trans girl etc. you’d think people would have a bit of shame!!

I had short hair once as a child and overheard another mother say, ‘let the little boy have a go’, I was pretty upset!

How does the conversation go, as I’ve never asked a child if they’re a boy or a girl, nor heard people ask (common with babies, my son always got referred to as a girl)?

If they say, ‘oh this is the ladies toilets’, she could just say something like, ‘thanks, but yes, I’m female’. Then carry on as usual. Unless she’s going to see these people again, I would bother too much, it doesn’t sound like she’s bothered.