Is "openly Jewish" a hate crime under the April Fools Scottish hate crime law?

I have a theory that the gender critical movement has been groomed by the Isreal loby.
I went to a quite exclusive gc event once (tried to chat up prof Jane Clair jones 😂) but anyway, I was cornered by a woman who insisted on grilling me on my views on Isreal.
I have to confess I was a cowerd and kept my mouth shut, just gave her a lecture on the evils of anti Semitism. She just rolled her eyes at this which surprised me.

Ilan Pappe is a self proclaimed, post modernist historian, whose grasp of facts has been much critiqued by other historians. As a post modernist he is all about the narrative, not believing that there are ever any ever concrete truths.

It has been said of Pappe that: "Pappe is just telling stories with villains (zionists in this case) and heroes. Morris ( Historian Benny Morris) writes what he found to be truth (at least, it is his intention… people are not perfect), while Pappe at best writes what he “hopes” to be truth".......Ilan Peppe is not trying to write about history, he is writing about a narrative, the narrative of the Palestinians. He is an ideologue.

Read some history, may I suggest illan pape, there was a whole population that have been there since ancient times.

Lousy, unevidenced non arguments.

Hi, I don't think Isreal-as an ethno state established by extream violence in a place with a native population not of the favored ethnicity -should exist, no.
Can I ask if you think Arabs are human beings with the same rights as other human beings?

I have a theory that the gender critical movement has been groomed by the Isreal loby.
I went to a quite exclusive gc event once (tried to chat up prof Jane Clair jones 😂) but anyway, I was cornered by a woman who insisted on grilling me on my views on Isreal.
I have to confess I was a cowerd and kept my mouth shut, just gave her a lecture on the evils of anti Semitism. She just rolled her eyes at this which surprised me.

The question about the difference between Zionism and antisemitism is a VERY very complicated and multifaceted one. The official debate in the video has 4 experts with huge experience and knowledge. 2 saying that both are the same, and 2 saying that they are very different and not linked (although they can be in some cases). There is NO way this can be resumed in a few sentences. Don't watch of course if you don't want to. And if I gave a summary, you would not trust or believe me.

Far too complex, and far too important, for a non expert like me to summarise, that would be really stupid indeed.

If you cannot condense the discussion, or pick out its essential arguments and then put them into your won words - it might well be suggestive of you not really having an understanding or a grasp of those issues yourself?

Your actual own words ,though, so far, have given a very clear indication of your position. Denial of atrocities, accusations of wilful genocide and various other conspiracy type thinking. You have shown no empathy, nor consideration of the Israeli position at all.

You cannot really expect busy people to take over an hour out of their day to watch a video that someone has posted. Many people now tend to post videos or other clips in place of their own considered arguments. Nobody has the time for that. This is a discussion board.

(((The Israel lobby))). Who exactly are this elusive Israel lobby, as if I couldn't guess.

I have to confess I was a cowerd and kept my mouth shut, just gave her a lecture on the evils of anti Semitism. She just rolled her eyes at this which surprised me.

You claim to have given someone a lecture on antisemitism and then you start stanning for Ilan Pappé, so imagine our surprise to hear someone "rolled her eyes" at you.

Far too complex for me to do so in my own words. And I am no historian nor specialist. Don't bother to watch this truly informed and balanced debate, very well chaired and with a very mixed audience. There is no was I could present all the points made in the debate in a few words of my own. And you wouldn't trust or believe me either.

Watch or don't watch. But don't accuse me of antisemitism or racism.

I have a theory that the gender critical movement has been groomed by the Isreal loby.
I went to a quite exclusive gc event once (tried to chat up prof Jane Clair jones 😂) but anyway, I was cornered by a woman who insisted on grilling me on my views on Isreal.
I have to confess I was a cowerd and kept my mouth shut, just gave her a lecture on the evils of anti Semitism. She just rolled her eyes at this which surprised me.

And?

You know that just saying khamas! I sent an argumen for or against anything right?

I'll raise you a Moumou!

Best get listening to that youtuber then Milky, you haven't watched it yet.
There's a test on Monday to see if you have paid attention.
llan Pape is invigilating, so you might do ok.

This Illan Pappe.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/11/18/exeter-professor-admires-courage-hamas/

An archive:

https://archive.ph/5IFqV#selection-2657.0-2665.153

fungipie. Perhaps AdamRyan on here might want to listen to your lengthy youtuber if you give Adamself a shout up. You seem to have a great deal in common re sources.