Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

The TRA banging thr symbol in the horses face

238 replies

Eminybob · 24/03/2024 11:42

How can anyone watch this and yet still side with trans rights?
Do people think this behaviour is justified, because GC women wanting to protect their rights are evil incarnate?

Why is this behaviour not peaking the world?

And why do so many otherwise sane individuals think its OK to refer to a rapist as she and house him in a women's prison?

I've just had enough of it all.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
10
Helleofabore · 26/03/2024 10:37

Cauliflowery · 25/03/2024 13:34

I don't understand why I was deleted tbh!

It gets tiring being asked to account for the far right when they've no more in common with GC feminism than they have with trans ideology.

https://deadwildroses.com/2019/10/07/handy-venn-diagrams-the-radical-feminist-position-on-gender/

I illustrated that using the analogy of paedophiles creating the MAP (minor attracted person) pride flag. I specifically said "designed their own flag". My entire point hinges on the fact that a nefarious group can take advantage of another group to further their own aims.

Eg MAPs taking advantage of pride
Eg the far right taking advantage of feminism

If I'd been insinuating that MAPs were affiliated with pride that would have undermined my entire point!

I'd love @mnhq to explain why I was deleted (I received no email)

Or even better, the reporting person to explain which part of my post upset them to the extent it deserved to be removed from the internet?

Those trying to clumsily make points about far right alignment don’t like to be reminded of the constant examples of people with backgrounds of such abuse being in their own movement. Not just a false ‘alignment’ but actually as spokespeople, and governors, and ambassadors and so on.

It is way it is only ever people who have little knowledge about what is happening try this ‘Whataboutery’. Because in doing so everyone reading learns a whole lot more about the very people that we are expected to believe are the most vulnerable and most marginalised. Finding out the depth of evidence that proves this as a lie has to be a shock.

Finding out that the male banging a cymbal under the horse’s nose is most definitely a general indicator of male extreme trans rights protestor behaviour must be inconvenient to say the least. It surely is.

Cauliflowery · 25/03/2024 13:34

Helleofabore · 25/03/2024 12:00

Remarkable how that post got deleted cauli. There are obviously many eyes on this board monitoring posts lately.

I thought it was an apt come back to a weak arsed attempt to deflect from some well established behaviour by extreme trans activists while seeming to backhandedly attempt to just as weakly consolidate feminists as being aligned with 'far right' political entities.

I don't understand why I was deleted tbh!

It gets tiring being asked to account for the far right when they've no more in common with GC feminism than they have with trans ideology.

https://deadwildroses.com/2019/10/07/handy-venn-diagrams-the-radical-feminist-position-on-gender/

I illustrated that using the analogy of paedophiles creating the MAP (minor attracted person) pride flag. I specifically said "designed their own flag". My entire point hinges on the fact that a nefarious group can take advantage of another group to further their own aims.

Eg MAPs taking advantage of pride
Eg the far right taking advantage of feminism

If I'd been insinuating that MAPs were affiliated with pride that would have undermined my entire point!

I'd love @mnhq to explain why I was deleted (I received no email)

Or even better, the reporting person to explain which part of my post upset them to the extent it deserved to be removed from the internet?

Handy Venn Diagrams – The Radical Feminist Position on Gender

Visit the post for more.

https://deadwildroses.com/2019/10/07/handy-venn-diagrams-the-radical-feminist-position-on-gender

Helleofabore · 25/03/2024 12:56

DrBlackbird · 25/03/2024 12:39

It also doesn't mean that the women speaking are associated with Nazi groups, any more than it would mean that the women speaking are associated with the Trans Zealot groups.

For that matter, if we’re attributing guilt by association, why not associate the TRAs with the far right neo nazis? They’re both at the same event protesting. Both being intimidating and thuggish. Both attempting to silence another group with threats of violence. Seems these two groups have more in common than the group of women trying to speak peacefully.

But no doubt such a suggestion would be passionately denied. Fine. If it’s just different groups together at the same event with different agendas, then we can say the same about the women speaking. They have nothing to do with either far right protestors or TRAs activists.

We did do that exercise actually back last year when discussing the Melbourne event. The supporters of the trans rights activists who were jeering about far right associates couldn't quite comprehend it when used back at them...

DrBlackbird · 25/03/2024 12:39

It also doesn't mean that the women speaking are associated with Nazi groups, any more than it would mean that the women speaking are associated with the Trans Zealot groups.

For that matter, if we’re attributing guilt by association, why not associate the TRAs with the far right neo nazis? They’re both at the same event protesting. Both being intimidating and thuggish. Both attempting to silence another group with threats of violence. Seems these two groups have more in common than the group of women trying to speak peacefully.

But no doubt such a suggestion would be passionately denied. Fine. If it’s just different groups together at the same event with different agendas, then we can say the same about the women speaking. They have nothing to do with either far right protestors or TRAs activists.

Helleofabore · 25/03/2024 12:00

Remarkable how that post got deleted cauli. There are obviously many eyes on this board monitoring posts lately.

I thought it was an apt come back to a weak arsed attempt to deflect from some well established behaviour by extreme trans activists while seeming to backhandedly attempt to just as weakly consolidate feminists as being aligned with 'far right' political entities.

SidewaysOtter · 25/03/2024 11:38

The point is, of course, why do all these rallies require police presence at all?

Because some of the TRA protestors are just there for the fight. There's a big over-lap with the sort of people who go hunt-sabbing and think it's OK to scream obscenities at small children, attack hounds, firebomb vehicles and intimidate hunt staff. You've only got to look at them with their masks, combat clothing and weapons to see the same people popping up.

They'd say their actions are justified for "the cause" but they aren't. They just want a fight. Maybe they genuinely believe that there's a cause (and I think some are genuinely looking for a cause to be angry about) but for many of them I even doubt that too.

Then you've got the kids who genuinely believe that gender critical people are going to kill them. I am absolutely baffled at where this comes from but they believe all the shite about suicide rates, erasure and Nazism, as if people who want to restrict puberty blockers are actually plotting a new Final Solution. They're acting out of fear, misplaced as it is.

Either way, they see gender critical people as "other". We're not worthy of human rights or safety or fairness because we're monsters. Unfortunately, it's not that uncommon, I've been at the receiving end of it. Thankfully not physical violence but bullying where my "wrong views" meant that I was ostracised and accused of all sorts, while absolutely none of them cared what the effect of all that on me might have been. I was deemed to deserve everything I got.

Cauliflowery · 25/03/2024 11:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TWETMIRF · 25/03/2024 10:17

Yet we are told time and again that transwomen are delicate, vulnerable little things and that women are the violent ones.

Are the violent brutes not really trans, or are the TRAs lying? It's sure tricky to work out.

SinnerBoy · 25/03/2024 10:01

Fixerupper77 · Yesterday 22:14

Why do you think they are attracted to the events? Is it because they know there’s normally counter protest and its an opportunity to cause trouble?

I'd say that they do go, looking for trouble with Antifa and Trans Zealots. That, however, does not make it the responsibility of the women speaking. It also doesn't mean that the women speaking are associated with Nazi groups, any more than it would mean that the women speaking are associated with the Trans Zealot groups.

It's facile to make that suggestion.

Froodwithatowel · 25/03/2024 09:59

Injured a man. Refused to let an ambulance through to him. Surrounded by police who stood there and let it all happen.

Helleofabore · 25/03/2024 09:41

doc the heroes there were the stewards. They stood in front of the bulk of the crowd that day. Ovaries of steel those women!

The point is, of course, why do all these rallies require police presence at all? Posters who seem to have fuck all ability to critically think this through seem to forget what has now become standard. No women can now meet without being protested, without attempts at being cancelled or blocked entry.

Some people fucking think these protestors smashing cymbals in front of horses is somehow unusual behaviour. We know it is not unusual at all. It is fucking laughable what some people will overlook to attempt to portray women as irrational or prejudiced.

But once readers see the pattern for themselves, they can’t unsee it.

DrBlackbird · 25/03/2024 09:22

Helleofabore · 25/03/2024 08:57

I was once in the line with other women holding hands to form a barrier to the group of shouting protestors. Even with the police spaced between us it was frightening and intimidating. One woman beside me was so scared she was trembling.

And the horns, the amplified music, drums, it is deafening.

And why are they doing it? Because women are there speaking words that they won’t listen to and they refuse to hear.

I applaud you for being there @Helleofabore always throughout history men have used their physical strength to intimidate, silence and control women. Women pay a big price to keep their voices heard and thank god many refuse to be silenced. I’d be very scared to attend one of those rallies for several different reasons.

Helleofabore · 25/03/2024 09:19

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 25/03/2024 09:06

A bit more information about the incident involving the Auditing Australia man and his daughter. I know nothing about any of the people involved so can't vouch for the veracity of any of this, but I'm inclined to believe it, having seen that clip of this one man being aggressively harassed (to put it at its mildest) by a group of several activists.

Thanks Gaspode. That is concerning even if just partially true.

Thanks @Fixerupper77 for posting the news article that pointed out this attack on the man who was not connected to feminists in any way, yet still was attacked by extreme trans activists. Or are you saying they were not trans activists? Either way, thanks for posting your link! It has been enlightening to see just how consistent the behaviour that male protestor smashing at a cymbal in front of the police horse was to the others there on the day.

I believe the two women that were reported to be arrested when the police had to resort to pepper spraying a group of protestors were male and extreme trans activists too.

Great job posting this for us. Thanks.

Boiledbeetle · 25/03/2024 09:17

Helleofabore · 25/03/2024 07:56

https://www.reddit.com/r/redscarepod/comments/qcjtuh/womanshakes_tambourine_while_yelling_repent/

Hard to find a clip with repent motherfucker on but here we go.

Edited

Ooh I'd forgotten about that batshit moment!

SirChenjins · 25/03/2024 09:16

Bloody hell @Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g Shock

The result of this violence that we're seeing more and more of is that people are waking up to what's really going on with the TRAs and are actively turning against transpeople. They may not voice it publicly for fear of retribution, but the days of people living quietly as another gender (whatever that means to them) are long gone.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 25/03/2024 09:06

A bit more information about the incident involving the Auditing Australia man and his daughter. I know nothing about any of the people involved so can't vouch for the veracity of any of this, but I'm inclined to believe it, having seen that clip of this one man being aggressively harassed (to put it at its mildest) by a group of several activists.

The TRA banging thr symbol in the horses face
The TRA banging thr symbol in the horses face
Helleofabore · 25/03/2024 08:57

DrBlackbird · 25/03/2024 08:47

That exchange conveys how terrifying the whole TRA protest must feel to those on the receiving end. Absolutely male. Male aggression and male intimidation with the underlying threat of male violence.

And that was a big burly bloke being involved in the altercation. What would a woman feel? As a smaller female I’d feel so intimidated by those screaming, shouting TRA men.

Exactly what they want you to feel.

And the chasing with cameras, my god when did an iPhone or camera become such an aggressive instrument of intimidation? It looks truly medieval.

I was once in the line with other women holding hands to form a barrier to the group of shouting protestors. Even with the police spaced between us it was frightening and intimidating. One woman beside me was so scared she was trembling.

And the horns, the amplified music, drums, it is deafening.

And why are they doing it? Because women are there speaking words that they won’t listen to and they refuse to hear.

DrBlackbird · 25/03/2024 08:47

Helleofabore · 24/03/2024 18:04

Would you please clarify what your intention of posting this incident was, because the post you quoted has been deleted?

Do you mean this incident? Is this the one that you have posted in the quoted post?

https://x.com/96mitchclarke/status/1771360983023485132?s=20

This may be it from another angle. It seems to fit though. The person screaming 'fucking die', 'kill yourself' seems to be the same person in both and the phone was streaming and captured at the time. There are claims one of those male people following pulled the man's daughter's hair.

Should he have reacted this way, no. He should have referred it to the police immediately and used the footage. Has any footage been released that he had been antagonising transgender supporters?

https://x.com/AnthonyHadj/status/1771713747335184685?s=20

Has this man been identified as having any connection to the organisers of the women's rally? And if so, in what capacity? Just because he might believe that people cannot change sex, it doesn't mean he has any connected to the women's rally. Many other interested parties go to these events for their own purposes.

Would you please clarify what your intention of posting this incident was, because the post you quoted has been deleted?

That exchange conveys how terrifying the whole TRA protest must feel to those on the receiving end. Absolutely male. Male aggression and male intimidation with the underlying threat of male violence.

And that was a big burly bloke being involved in the altercation. What would a woman feel? As a smaller female I’d feel so intimidated by those screaming, shouting TRA men.

Exactly what they want you to feel.

And the chasing with cameras, my god when did an iPhone or camera become such an aggressive instrument of intimidation? It looks truly medieval.

FrancescaContini · 25/03/2024 08:04

PriOn1 · 24/03/2024 11:50

I think there are people who don’t care about animals and haven’t considered the mentality it takes to try and scare an animal (which by definition is innocent) presumably with the intention of causing injury to the police officer on its back, without giving a moment’s thought to the animal’s experience.

Here’s someone who claims to be a lawyer, apparently defending this act. He too only considers the police officer. The horse has to just get on with it as he personally was treated much worse.

x.com/Feintglow/status/1771407380028502381?s=20

His attempt at deflecting criticism away from his unhinged “cymbal repeatedly whacked under horse’s nose” behaviour to “poor me, someone once threw some shit at me” is very blatant. He knows full well that the video doesn’t show someone claiming to be a lawyer in a very good light.

Helleofabore · 25/03/2024 07:56

https://www.reddit.com/r/redscarepod/comments/qcjtuh/womanshakes_tambourine_while_yelling_repent/

Hard to find a clip with repent motherfucker on but here we go.

Helleofabore · 25/03/2024 07:33

While it wasn’t a Let Women Speak event, maybe it is time to remind ourselves to REPENT MOTHERFUCKER!!!

Yeah. I think we can say this male protestor is not an isolated case.

AlisonDonut · 25/03/2024 06:23

Fixerupper77 · 24/03/2024 22:46

Yes I can clarify this.

My point was in response to the OP suggesting that the pathetic actions of this individual in the video were somehow representative of an entire movement of people.

Did you manage to find the clip where the rest of the movement stopped this guy and his behaviour? I've been ill, so I haven't followed this as closely as I usually would.

Do you really need us to document all the disgusting behaviour of this group, going back years and years, at every point that women wanted to meet and have been stopped, blocked, protested, banned, cancelled, threatened, their families targeted, the families of the venues threatened and targeted, all to stop them talking and from being heard? The same tactics, used over and over again, across the globe, all the countries, al the cities, all the same behaviour from the same anti-women group?

This isn't one guy with a cymbal, it is the orchestration of a male rights movement intent on destroying the rights of women to their words and freedoms, and the rights of kids to grow up.

It is kinda why we talk about it and document it on here.

Brefugee · 25/03/2024 06:16

Fixerupper77 · 24/03/2024 22:14

Why do you think they are attracted to the events? Is it because they know there’s normally counter protest and its an opportunity to cause trouble?

So in no way connected to the women. Bloody Norah, mate, just stop.

Helleofabore · 25/03/2024 04:48

Apparently we are to believe that all the cream pies in faces,
the injured limbs due to extreme trans activists trying to damage women’s property,
spraying things in the face,
the following of women screaming,
the wobbling of male naked breasts,
the lighting of flares,
the riding of bikes towards to throw things,
the throwing of soup on, the punching,
and the hitting
and knocking down women,
the assaulting of children,
the screaming at infants,
the wrapping of women in banners and knocking them off their feet,
the hitting of horses,
the clanging of cymbals, drums, stereos,
horns,
electronically amplified horns,
the kettling,
the knocking over….
I can keep going…. but, We are to believe that all this past activity of extreme rights trans activists is not indicative of the actions of extreme rights trans activists…..

It is laughable really. The behaviour some people will overlook in their need to scold women who they don’t agree with on some things.

But here we are. We shouldn’t hold a now established behaviour pattern as representative of extreme trans rights activists. Because, what is it that women are doing that is causing some people to react with so much violence?

Speaking words and telling others of their experience.

BlackeyedSusan · 25/03/2024 01:29

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 24/03/2024 12:07

See, some time googling would show many members of this particular "group of people " are happy to -

> Hold up banners about smashing women in the face,
> Make videos on the internet gleefully talking about TERFS deserve to be shot, die in fires, get raped
> Empty bottles of their own piss on the ground during a demonstration
> Hell, one little Twat from this group even openly smashed an old lady in the face at a demo in NZ. Received no charges and anonymity for life related to this act as his punishment

Trust me these fucking toddlers are smearing themselves with the Idiot brush. They need no help from us.

That'd be Jack Hudner who punched a granny and got away with it.