Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Why are separate spaces for trans people unacceptable (to trans people)?

414 replies

Superlambaanana · 20/02/2024 22:43

There's a thread on AIBU about people's network's views on the trans debate and a poster suggested trans people ought to campaign for separate spaces - trans toilets, trans sporting events etc.

Is anyone campaigning for this? And if not why not? I'm not clued into the detail of the debate and am genuinely interested. Is it just impractical (cost, insufficient numbers for competitive sport) or is it ideologically unacceptable?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
27
Eminybob · 21/02/2024 02:12

Babla · 21/02/2024 01:22

Being trans is not a fetish

Not for all trans people, but certainly for plenty.
And if you want to tell me that those ones are not really trans, then please enlighten me as to how we are supposed to know which are the real "nice" trans ladies, and which are the fetishistic AGPs who want access to female spaces for nefarious reasons?
Best just to keep all males out eh?

Eminybob · 21/02/2024 02:06

WaitingForMojo · 21/02/2024 01:17

Replace ‘trans’ in the thread title with ‘black’ or even ‘gay’, and you’ll see.

Not even remotely comparable.
Black women and gay women (lesbians) are women and so belong in women's spaces. Trans women are men and so do not belong in women's space.

What a ridiculous and offensive argument.

Emma8888 · 21/02/2024 02:01

"Can you explain why there wouldn't be 'pee on the seat' in a unisex loo? That's not an argument I've heard before.

Or why the mirrors would be low if men are using them too? Things aren't generally designed with women in mind: at one place I worked, even the ladies loo must've been designed by men because we could just about see our eyebrows in the bottom of the mirrors."

You are reading too much into this - all I want from any loo I use is for it to be clean (no pee on the seat being a particular essential) and decent lighting by the mirror so I can check hair / teeth etc. It doesn't matter if that's an aeroplane, train, workplace, bar or gym or what is written on the door.

Littlepinkstarsbyradish · 21/02/2024 01:28

this is a very mean spirited and disingenuous thread (although might not have been started in that spirit, original post seems to have got lost)

Most organisations have limited resources, and so to expect separate provisions for men, women, trans women and trans men, is simply beyond the capacity of lots of groups. For one example, a small community theatre would never be able to provide designated toilets or changing rooms for all 4 of those groups of people. Neither could a local leisure centre.

If people campaigned for the provision of separate trans spaces, this would effectively remove trans people's presence in many community spaces. Its far easier to include trans people into existing spaces in most situations, with proper thought and planning.

That's why most campaigns are about inclusion. Because most people (and most trans people) aren't elite athletes, or in the top income bracket. Most of us are using facilities and services with limited budgets and we're pragmatic and realistic!

Babla · 21/02/2024 01:22

Being trans is not a fetish

WaitingForMojo · 21/02/2024 01:17

Replace ‘trans’ in the thread title with ‘black’ or even ‘gay’, and you’ll see.

Babla · 21/02/2024 01:02

AIstolemylunch · 20/02/2024 22:54

The majority of trans males, the AGP transwomen, don't want them because part of their fetish involves affirmation of themselves as women, even forced. Hence they want to be where women are, because they want everyone to acknowledge that they literally are women, and get off on that. It's a sexual fetish remember. You're not going to be happy with trainers if you've got a high heel fetish.

Since when has being trans been a fetish

ifIwerenotanandroid · 21/02/2024 01:01

Emma8888 · 21/02/2024 00:28

I feel that the rise of inclusive / gender free / unisex / omnisex loos etc. will end up being what non trans women end up using long term. The trans women can have the women's washroom, the rest of us just want somewhere without pee on the seat and a decently lot mirror.

Can you explain why there wouldn't be 'pee on the seat' in a unisex loo? That's not an argument I've heard before.

Or why the mirrors would be low if men are using them too? Things aren't generally designed with women in mind: at one place I worked, even the ladies loo must've been designed by men because we could just about see our eyebrows in the bottom of the mirrors.

SD1978 · 21/02/2024 00:57

@bringbacktheladiesloos- I have absolutely no idea- because trans men are largely silent on the whole thing.

Commonhousewitch · 21/02/2024 00:40

I think normal(? - Non AGP) transwomen - want to use the women's toilets as they feel that that is consistent with where they belong and to use anything else would be restrictive and outing
To be fair where at work we have mens/women and uni sex - you rarely see anyone using the unisex - i think some of the men go in to poo so everyone else avoids it

Gloriosaford · 21/02/2024 00:36

Grumpetsky · 21/02/2024 00:26

Narcissism, misogyny, delusions and sometimes AGP fetishism amplified by internet bubbles and captured institutions. Nothing but complete validation/capitulation will do.

I agree

Whatsnewpussyhat · 21/02/2024 00:30

non trans women

Women.
We are not non men.

Emma8888 · 21/02/2024 00:28

I feel that the rise of inclusive / gender free / unisex / omnisex loos etc. will end up being what non trans women end up using long term. The trans women can have the women's washroom, the rest of us just want somewhere without pee on the seat and a decently lot mirror.

Grumpetsky · 21/02/2024 00:26

Narcissism, misogyny, delusions and sometimes AGP fetishism amplified by internet bubbles and captured institutions. Nothing but complete validation/capitulation will do.

SaunteringOnBy · 21/02/2024 00:21

*The only type of mental hat

Mental Hat... Lol.

But that should say
'The only type of men that..'

QueenBitch666 · 21/02/2024 00:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SaunteringOnBy · 21/02/2024 00:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

bringbacktheladiesloos · 21/02/2024 00:06

SD1978 · 21/02/2024 00:00

Because trans women don't want this. They want women's spaces and sports, and then to grin coquettishly with surprise when they win at all events- because that's what women do. Trans men are pretty silent on this- probably because none of them have ever, or will ever succeed in any male sport......and yet male bodies have no advantage.........

. . . do transmen happily use men's loos / changing rooms etc?

SD1978 · 21/02/2024 00:00

Because trans women don't want this. They want women's spaces and sports, and then to grin coquettishly with surprise when they win at all events- because that's what women do. Trans men are pretty silent on this- probably because none of them have ever, or will ever succeed in any male sport......and yet male bodies have no advantage.........

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 20/02/2024 23:53

SaunteringOnBy isn’t everyone.

Cazpar · 20/02/2024 23:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ToriaB · 20/02/2024 23:43

There's the argument Bridges uses that it's "outing".
Why would anyone be ashamed of being trans?

Superlambaanana · 20/02/2024 23:28

I assume most/all trans people wouldn't agree that it's about fetishisation/ non consensual use of women. So what argument do they put forward? That's it's traumatic not to be able to be themselves... by pretending to be something they're not. Honestly trying to get my head around the arguments and not getting anywhere except to conclude it is all nonsense. If any of you have seen any sane articles or blogs by transpeople explaining why they don't want third spaces, please point me to them. Twitter seems to just be a shouting fest, the media coverage is just click bait and interest group websites are extremely polarised so it's hard to actually hear reasoned debate from the trans side over the shouting. Or maybe all they're doing is shouting because there is no reasoned debate?

OP posts:
pronounsbundlebundle · 20/02/2024 23:27

I don't think it's all sexual, sometimes it's just your common or garden women hatred. I think some of them enjoy making women and children feel afraid, particularly if those women and children can't do anything about it. It's abusive.

Why do abusers abuse? Don't know. Trans ideology is coercive control at a societal level. If there's no-one to control they're not interested.

bringbacktheladiesloos · 20/02/2024 23:21

Do transmen happily use the men's loos?