Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Close to 100 Canadian cities set to march against sexual indoctrination of kids in schools

71 replies

IwantToRetire · 21/09/2023 17:30

In fact this was meant to happen yesterday and not sure whether it happened or if there were any problems.

Article about intention here https://www.rebelnews.com/million_march_for_children_canadian_cities_lgbt_policies

Not sure of the politics behind it here are some other links:
> https://globalnews.ca/news/9973878/million-march-4-children-draws-hundreds-of-supporters-counter-protesters-in-downtown-calgary/
> https://www.meghanmurphy.ca/p/canadians-say-no-to-gender-identity
> https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/cross-country-rallies-against-gender-ideology-in-schools-met-with-counter-protests-1.6569373
> https://theconversation.com/how-the-parental-rights-movement-gave-rise-to-the-1-million-march-4-children-213842

So posting more as a point of information. Though would be good to hear from anyone in Canada what their take on this is.

Close to 100 Canadian cities set to march against sexual indoctrination of kids in schools this Wednesday

The 1 Million March 4 Children is set to take place on September 20 and has been attacked by the Canadian Anti-Hate Network as being 'supported by a big tent of far-right and conspiratorial groups.'

https://www.rebelnews.com/million_march_for_children_canadian_cities_lgbt_policies

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
7
OP posts:
SaffronSpice · 26/09/2023 19:58

Rudderneck · 26/09/2023 19:47

Do you think they were sneakily trying to infiltrate a Nazi, though? That seems like a major miscalculation. Which is to say, an accident, not the point of the thing.

Again, at best it was incompetence and ignorance which in no way can be considered an accident and a damning indictment on all MPs.

Rudderneck · 26/09/2023 19:47

Do you think they were sneakily trying to infiltrate a Nazi, though? That seems like a major miscalculation. Which is to say, an accident, not the point of the thing.

SaffronSpice · 26/09/2023 19:08

Rudderneck · 26/09/2023 18:57

That is all certainly true. It's very sloppy.

I don't really see there being an agenda in this instance though, there wasn't a lobby group trying to score political points or anything like that.

Of course there was - at minimum it was to score political points for funds for Ukraine

Rudderneck · 26/09/2023 18:57

SaffronSpice · 26/09/2023 18:53

This is the problem - they take information given them by lobbyists and ideologues at face value. Too often they are lacking any curiosity about anything a lobbyist categorises as ‘bad’ then squeal ‘it was an accident’ or ‘it was somebody else’s fault’ when they get caught out, or DARVO and claim to be bullied when criticised. The Scottish Government emulates Canada’s in more ways than one.

That is all certainly true. It's very sloppy.

I don't really see there being an agenda in this instance though, there wasn't a lobby group trying to score political points or anything like that.

SaffronSpice · 26/09/2023 18:53

Rudderneck · 26/09/2023 17:56

I think you are overestimating the educational attainments of a great many MPs.

You only need a few people in charge to over-look doing their research on something like this. All the rest assume it's been done and clap when they are supposed to.

The tendency to black and white thinking doesn't help, the Ukrainian War now falls into the category of good, so many will just accept anything coming from that direction is also good.

It's not just gender ideology that the Canadian public (and state) is gullible about.

This is the problem - they take information given them by lobbyists and ideologues at face value. Too often they are lacking any curiosity about anything a lobbyist categorises as ‘bad’ then squeal ‘it was an accident’ or ‘it was somebody else’s fault’ when they get caught out, or DARVO and claim to be bullied when criticised. The Scottish Government emulates Canada’s in more ways than one.

JanesLittleGirl · 26/09/2023 18:23

Sorry, maybe I should have ended my post with (sarcasm).

VeronicaSawyer89 · 26/09/2023 18:16

JanesLittleGirl · 25/09/2023 11:28

I'm so glad that these protests were purely the result of a coalition of anti-federalists, homophobes, fundamentalist Christians, fundamentalist Muslims and racists and didn't reflect the views of the vast majority of Canadians who are totally OK with the reasonable changes around gender that have been implemented.

Just to help me make sure that I fully understand, could you tell me what the difference between a fundamentalist Christian and a common-or-garden Christian is and the same for Muslims?

Really think social services need to be brought in to make sure your children are safe if you think this man teaching children is normal. https://nypost.com/2023/04/14/canadian-trans-teacher-kayla-lemieux-seen-without-z-cup-prosthetics/

Canadian trans teacher confronted by reporter after she was spotted leaving mall without Z-cup prosthetic breasts

Kayla Lemieux made headlines for wearing fake Z-cup breasts to class.

https://nypost.com/2023/04/14/canadian-trans-teacher-kayla-lemieux-seen-without-z-cup-prosthetics

Rudderneck · 26/09/2023 17:56

SaffronSpice · 26/09/2023 09:53

The statement ‘fought against the Russians in WWII’ should have been plenty to make them stop and think whose side he was fighting on. How much else do they lap up without thinking about what they are being told?

I think you are overestimating the educational attainments of a great many MPs.

You only need a few people in charge to over-look doing their research on something like this. All the rest assume it's been done and clap when they are supposed to.

The tendency to black and white thinking doesn't help, the Ukrainian War now falls into the category of good, so many will just accept anything coming from that direction is also good.

It's not just gender ideology that the Canadian public (and state) is gullible about.

Langsdestiny · 26/09/2023 17:44

Ha when the middle class support an actual nazi it's an accident.
Nope no classism at all.

SaffronSpice · 26/09/2023 09:53

The statement ‘fought against the Russians in WWII’ should have been plenty to make them stop and think whose side he was fighting on. How much else do they lap up without thinking about what they are being told?

SaffronSpice · 26/09/2023 09:49

Rudderneck · 26/09/2023 01:36

I think this was really an accident. Stupid of them perhaps, but they did not realize who he was.

You don’t invite a 98 year old WWII SS veteran by accident, then accidentally make a statement honouring him. Nor do you accidentally give him a standing ovation. At the very least it shows a profound lack of critical thinking and by the Canadian parliament, group think in their behaviour plus a lack of knowledge of history. At worst it is a rewriting of history and a acceptance of nazism. Neither should have a place in a democratic parliament.

Codesilver · 26/09/2023 06:35

Yes that was crazy. Big questions being asked around vetting and security I’d hope now. Especially embarrassing and damaging because Zelenskyy was there.

Rudderneck · 26/09/2023 01:36

SaffronSpice · 25/09/2023 18:22

Talking of Nazis, the Canadian Government gave a Nazi - yes an actually Nazi who had sworn allegiance to Hilter and a member of the Waffen SS - a standing ovation in parliament:

https://x.com/UnityNewsNet/status/1705841969845403788?s=20

I think this was really an accident. Stupid of them perhaps, but they did not realize who he was.

SaffronSpice · 25/09/2023 18:22

Talking of Nazis, the Canadian Government gave a Nazi - yes an actually Nazi who had sworn allegiance to Hilter and a member of the Waffen SS - a standing ovation in parliament:

https://x.com/UnityNewsNet/status/1705841969845403788?s=20

https://x.com/UnityNewsNet/status/1705841969845403788?s=20

JanesLittleGirl · 25/09/2023 11:28

Codesilver · 25/09/2023 06:12

Every country was restricting movement at the time. Provincial mandates were about to be lifted /changed. The people involved with the organizing were just very anti (this particular) federal government, and having failed at their ‘wexit’ and anti-UN yellow vest rubbish, locked onto this as their protest.
Bringing it back to this particular protest, some of the same people were involved- they aren’t hiding their homophobic views. The only thing which is a bit surprising, to me, is that fundamentalist Christians have joined forces with fundamentalist Muslims in this particular instance /for this March.
it just feels odd, considering the Islamophobic rants we saw from some of the convoy organizers.

I'm so glad that these protests were purely the result of a coalition of anti-federalists, homophobes, fundamentalist Christians, fundamentalist Muslims and racists and didn't reflect the views of the vast majority of Canadians who are totally OK with the reasonable changes around gender that have been implemented.

Just to help me make sure that I fully understand, could you tell me what the difference between a fundamentalist Christian and a common-or-garden Christian is and the same for Muslims?

Rudderneck · 25/09/2023 10:31

Codesilver · 25/09/2023 06:56

As well, there was an actual general election in the Fall of 2021, so I think that counted as a way ‘the normal ways citizens might challenge government decisions in a democracy’ could have been done.

That's not actually how the system is meant to work - it's not, an election every four years and the PM can do whatever in between. The government not sitting is serious. The media not questioning the government is serious. MPs not raising questions is really serious. Suspending civil liberties is really serious, and needs to be done with the scrutiny of Parliament.

RebelliousCow · 25/09/2023 09:40

Codesilver · 25/09/2023 06:12

Every country was restricting movement at the time. Provincial mandates were about to be lifted /changed. The people involved with the organizing were just very anti (this particular) federal government, and having failed at their ‘wexit’ and anti-UN yellow vest rubbish, locked onto this as their protest.
Bringing it back to this particular protest, some of the same people were involved- they aren’t hiding their homophobic views. The only thing which is a bit surprising, to me, is that fundamentalist Christians have joined forces with fundamentalist Muslims in this particular instance /for this March.
it just feels odd, considering the Islamophobic rants we saw from some of the convoy organizers.

It is interesting to consider the issues around which people come together, from quite diverse sections of society. If we could acknowledge these issues and discuss them openly - then perhaps there might more chance for unity and for the coming together around shared values - which, after all, is what makes for a stable society.

MichelleScarn · 25/09/2023 07:41

I'm still getting to grips with a lot of the things going on re all of this. Is the term 'squirrel' right?
As in parents expressing concerns and along comes 'LOOK!! It's all Nazis that are doing it!' It's evil to be right wing, now I've called you right wing, you'll do what I want won't you'

Codesilver · 25/09/2023 06:56

Rudderneck · 25/09/2023 00:52

Yes, there was some chatter about this. If you recall, it was very much about what possible avenues there could be to deal with a government who had, arguably, suspended many basic civil liberties, with no end in sight.

It is, theoretically, a possible tole of the GG to respond in that kind of situation.

Overblown in this instance? Quite possibly. But it very much speaks to the kind of frustration that many people had with a government that was restricting movement, freedom of association, and a media that was refusing to question any of it.

And to maybe put this in context for those outside of Canada, there were significant interruptions in the House sitting during covid. Really an unprecedented level of centralizing of power in the PMs office. In my province, the legislature did not sit for over a year.

All of which is to say, the normal ways citizens might challenge government decisions in a democracy were suppressed, so perhaps it should be no surprise that frustrated people were discussing what other options might exist within the law, even if they were far-fetched.

As well, there was an actual general election in the Fall of 2021, so I think that counted as a way ‘the normal ways citizens might challenge government decisions in a democracy’ could have been done.

Codesilver · 25/09/2023 06:26

True North and rebel news are both right wing media here, the Canadian version of Fox maybe? But with obviously a much smaller reach. Very anti -Trudeau regardless of what he’s done. Pro- gun /anti climate change / anti covid protections (long gone by now) etc. I’m not a fan of either, but some of the denialism re: residential schools on, especially rebel news, is very sad.

Codesilver · 25/09/2023 06:12

Every country was restricting movement at the time. Provincial mandates were about to be lifted /changed. The people involved with the organizing were just very anti (this particular) federal government, and having failed at their ‘wexit’ and anti-UN yellow vest rubbish, locked onto this as their protest.
Bringing it back to this particular protest, some of the same people were involved- they aren’t hiding their homophobic views. The only thing which is a bit surprising, to me, is that fundamentalist Christians have joined forces with fundamentalist Muslims in this particular instance /for this March.
it just feels odd, considering the Islamophobic rants we saw from some of the convoy organizers.

Rudderneck · 25/09/2023 00:52

Codesilver · 23/09/2023 01:16

The original aim of one part of the convoy (per their memo of understanding circulated) was to somehow get the Governor General to disband parliament, get rid of all covid restrictions and put various other people in charge. It was ludicrous, and there was a big point made when they ‘withdrew’ it.
re. Turning it into our Jan 6th, there was lots of US money being sent into the fundraisers, some by very right wing organizations.
Re: the March, there were some very homophobic people involved in the planning, and I don’t think that’s a win for any kid. sadly home isn’t safe for all children.
There were also lots of churches involved in the counter-protests so I’m not saying all religion is bad.

Edited

Yes, there was some chatter about this. If you recall, it was very much about what possible avenues there could be to deal with a government who had, arguably, suspended many basic civil liberties, with no end in sight.

It is, theoretically, a possible tole of the GG to respond in that kind of situation.

Overblown in this instance? Quite possibly. But it very much speaks to the kind of frustration that many people had with a government that was restricting movement, freedom of association, and a media that was refusing to question any of it.

And to maybe put this in context for those outside of Canada, there were significant interruptions in the House sitting during covid. Really an unprecedented level of centralizing of power in the PMs office. In my province, the legislature did not sit for over a year.

All of which is to say, the normal ways citizens might challenge government decisions in a democracy were suppressed, so perhaps it should be no surprise that frustrated people were discussing what other options might exist within the law, even if they were far-fetched.

IwantToRetire · 24/09/2023 20:26

Notable women’s rights advocate Meghan Murphy was only five minutes into her speech at the Victoria, B.C. 1 Million March 4 Children parental rights rally when police told organizers to shut down the event and leave.

The march planned for later that afternoon never happened, as Victoria police (VicPD) ordered an end to the protest within 15 minutes of it starting on Wednesday, Murphy told True North.

Murphy, as well as other rally speakers and organizers, were demonstrating on the B.C. legislature grounds in support of parental rights and removing gender identity ideology from school curricula.

According to VicPD, “At approximately 12:30 p.m., counter-protesters pushed past police and rushed the stage, creating an unsafe environment, and a decision was made to cease further planned activities.”

Two arrests were made.

A contingent of rainbow-wearing counter-protesters, some of whom support sex change surgeries for minors and giving information about fringe sex acts to preteens, was of a distance from the main protest. However, busloads of young counter-protesters wearing black hoodies began arriving at the grounds, and streams of the masked agitators headed straight for the stage.

https://tnc.news/2023/09/22/police-shut-down-victoria-march/

Not being in Canada I have no idea of the politics of tnc.news but interesting they managed to make a report without referencing christian fundamentalism or homophobia.

Police shut down Victoria parental rights march within 15 minutes

Notable women’s rights advocate Meghan Murphy was only five minutes into her speech at the Victoria, B.C. 1 Million March 4 Children parental rights rally when police told organizers to shut down the event and leave.

https://tnc.news/2023/09/22/police-shut-down-victoria-march

OP posts:
gotira · 23/09/2023 16:17

Coveescapee · 22/09/2023 15:45

Following traditional Christian teachings on sex does not make you"homophobic" whatever that means. Billions of people throughout history and throughout the world today believe exactly the same things as these "homophobes." A very small comparatively number of people in the West believe differently. Whenever a new word is made up with phobe attached (see transphobe) I assume the people using it are unable to debate and discuss and are just resorting to insults because of this.

If by "traditional christian teachings on sex" you mean teaching kids that it's wrong to be gay then yah it kind of does.

Swipe left for the next trending thread