Please or to access all these features

Site stuff

Join our Innovation Panel to try new features early and help make Mumsnet better.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

MNHQ - I hope you are going to release your own statement on GMB Union

131 replies

OvaHere · 26/05/2020 10:48

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3920159-GMB-Statement-on-transphobia?pg=2

I'm horrified how little their commitment to women's employment rights matter during a global pandemic. It smacks of paying lip service to something they clearly think so little of if it can be rescinded on the flimsiest of accusations.

It's a common theme for men to punish women as a class for the perceived transgressions of a few. Almost biblical and reminiscent of the 'original sin' narrative.

Not only are GMB Union withdrawing legal advice from women here who discuss feminism they are also withdrawing it from every demographic of women who use this site.

I'm truly appalled at this behaviour whilst the country is in crisis. I hope you push back officially against this. It goes way beyond a company that chooses not to advertise - it's the withdrawing of legal advice for women who 'might' have committed wrongthink.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Pertella · 14/06/2020 17:39

@MNHQ I was wondering if you had any comment on the issue I touched on earlier in the thread. There seem to be a cohort of 'regular' posters intent on doing the TRAs work for them and calling out any trans related discussion as "transphobic" even when its patently clear that it's no such thing.

CaraDune · 12/06/2020 21:36

I'm copying and pasting this from a post I made on an AIBU thread (slightly tangential to the main thread, but worth thinking about). The thread was started by a woman whose employer is now insisting everyone go back into the office, even though she's successfully worked-from-home up till now - and because she's not a keyworker, she can't send her children to school.

I think there's a wider issue here, and I bloody well hope some of the trade unions are keeping stats on this. All companies' turnover will have taken a hell of a hit. A lot of them will be wanting to lay off staff, but wondering how to do it without having to pay huge redundancies payments. If they can make it impossible for staff to continue to do the job by insisting they work in the office (knowing they have children) they can push a proportion of their employees into resigning.

I think it could (in some instances) be a form of constructive dismissal, and it will undoubtedly hit women disproportionately. But in the general chaos of the post-covid economic crash, I worry that there will be so much shit hitting the fan that no-one will have either the will or the necessary stats to join up the dots.

This is exactly the sort of thing the GMB should be following up on. But the GMB have decided they hate women.

EchoCardioGran · 12/06/2020 19:27

Excellent letter.

The GMB is corrupt as hell. ime.

The internal payoffs are staggering, voting each other a financial package.

They re elected Tim Roache for Gen Sec, after stitching up a woman officer of 25 years who was to stand against him.

Then Roache suddenly retired with that whacking big pay out citing health grounds. ( See up thread). Although there was that investigation going on into his sexist and inappropriate behaviour.

Now " Dear John" is running the show.

That's what the membership fees of women cleaners who are union members goes on. Big pay offs for the menz.

Having a pop at MN, is their best chance at a smoke screen for all their internal shabby shennanigans.

( former Apex /GMB member)

CaraDune · 12/06/2020 09:56

@RowanMumsnet thank you for bringing us up to date. Also @JustineMumsnet - very good letter in response.

Can these people at GMB really not see the misogyny here? We face an unprecedented crisis, the worst economic downturn in over 100 years, already it's apparent that women are hugely disproportionately likely to be hit by this. The GMB had a chance to reach out to the women they could help, on the single biggest female-dominated website in the country. But they withdrew from this on the basis of a few tweets. While still continuing to use Twitter and Facebook which are absolute cess-pits of sexism, racism and vile views.

(I'm a single mum, currently negotiating a period of leave with work so I can home-school my son adequately, because he has special educational needs and so I need to be there to support him, not point him at the school's website and say get on with it. Negotiating what the terms and conditions of this leave could be are exactly the sort of things I could do with expert help on... but no, because I believe in biological reality and women's rights, apparently I'm not allowed expert help.)

midgebabe · 12/06/2020 07:38

Thank you MNHQ

thecatfromjapan · 11/06/2020 23:31

Women in the C21 deserve better than this.

And workers do, too.

This is why so many of us are so angry: institutions that are supposed to represent us, act in our interests, derive power from acting in our name, are funded by us, are, in fact, staffed by people who really do despise us.

And I'll bet the average pay of GMB staff is higher than the average pay of the workers they are supposed to represent (and who are paying the salaries of the staff).

S, we're good enough to pay the wages - but actually too contemptible to actually talk to?

What an utter farce 2020 politics is.

thecatfromjapan · 11/06/2020 23:26

Utterly disgraceful.

Ignoring the actual women workers on MN because of the fear of the wrath of Twitter Wokeists - most of whom won't be members of the GMB.

That's what happens when your employed staff are graduates and radically different from those you pretend to represent.

popehilarious · 11/06/2020 22:21

Fuck me, that 'statement' from GMB is absolutely woeful. There is no information being directly communicated there.

"The intention of the sessions was to reach out to working parents at a time of great insecurity - the last thing we would ever want is to cause harm or upset to our LGBT+ members, many of whom may be parents themselves. We of course apologise for any offence this may have caused."

Is the '-' meant to indicate that the second part of the sentence logically follows the first? There's no reasoning there at all. Just saying

  1. We wanted to reach out to working parents
  2. We don't want to harm LGBTQ people
  3. Sorry to ?? for any offence
(4. ???
  1. Profit)

So they can't explain why they didn't do it. Presumably they don't know why people voted 'no' and don't care.

Good response from Justine. The one up-side of me wading into the absolutely revolting tweets I found on Twitter at least meant I went on a reporting spree.

Melroses · 11/06/2020 20:47

I couldn't work out what the GMB were going on about, but Justine gave a good response.

(FO would have been a nice enhancement, but I am looking at a series of e-mails IRL with PA 'Best Regards' and grinning)

Lordfrontpaw · 11/06/2020 17:16

She should have signed off with fuck off' if you ask me...

BoreOfWhabylon · 11/06/2020 17:10

Good response from Justine there, I thought.

Except she should have signed off with "Go well"

Lordfrontpaw · 11/06/2020 16:54

Well thats a longer response than I would have written.

"Oi weasels
FUCK OFF"

RowanMumsnet · 11/06/2020 16:53

Hello

We received this statement today from the GMB:

GMB’s Central Executive Council - the lay member governing body of GMB - met last week and discussed our joint project working with Mumsnet.

On the back of a number of concerns from members and equality activists, the CEC voted not to proceed with our scheduled Q&A sessions.

The intention of the sessions was to reach out to working parents at a time of great insecurity - the last thing we would ever want is to cause harm or upset to our LGBT+ members, many of whom may be parents themselves. We of course apologise for any offence this may have caused.

GMB is a proud and staunch ally in the fight for trans rights. We are a member-led union that has a history of fighting for equality for all. As we look forward to Pride events this month and next, we continue to stand in solidarity with all of our LGBT+ siblings.

Justine has just sent this response (John is the acting General Secretary of the GMB):

Dear John,

We are incredibly disappointed that the GMB has taken the decision to cancel their activity on Mumsnet. We’ve wholeheartedly supported and campaigned for LGBT rights for 20 years, and our millions of users include trans people, gay people, and parents of trans and gay children, who will be bewildered by the GMB’s stance.

It’s ironic that the GMB itself, and the activists who target Mumsnet, continue to use and support Twitter and Facebook, whose moderation standards are lamentable compared to ours. The outright, hateful homophobia, racism, misogyny and transphobia that we see (and report) on these platforms wouldn’t stand for more than a couple of minutes on Mumsnet. We can only conclude the animus against Mumsnet is motivated by the fact that we are a site used overwhelmingly by women.

In that light it’s even more disappointing that the GMB, having asked Mumsnet users in precarious employment situations to share their questions, has left these women’s questions unanswered. The failure to stand in solidarity with these workers has truly surprised us. Fortunately there are other organisations that are able and willing to step up and help - because while Twitter wars rage on, parents in badly-paid, insecure work are suffering through the worst economic crisis of a generation.

Best regards,
Justine

AwrightDoreenTakeAFuckinDayOff · 02/06/2020 16:54

Allowing myself a wry laugh at the pay off.

The person who made my life a misery for years left with a pat on the back, a generous settlement and goodness knows what else with thanks to the same rep who took my case forward.

My case was swept under the carpet thanks to less than truthful management (cosy with same rep).

With the benefit of hindsight I would have gone straight to the police and stopped in by a lawyer on my way home.

Still. As long as the menz are ok eh?

Lordfrontpaw · 02/06/2020 16:42

It was on twitter - must be a recent PE as he refined in April .

Lordfrontpaw · 02/06/2020 16:41

Interesting ... from the FT “ Mr Roache wielded formidable power within the union movement, given that the GMB is one of the biggest donors to the Labour party. It has given more than £12m to the party over the past five years, according to Electoral Commission records.”

Mumsnet I’m disappointed in you - inviting this crowd in to speak.

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 02/06/2020 16:41

@Lordfrontpaw

Can I post this? Reportedly from private eye (on twitter).
Do you know when that's from?
Lordfrontpaw · 02/06/2020 16:37

Can I post this? Reportedly from private eye (on twitter).

MNHQ - I hope you are going to release your own statement on GMB Union
Lordfrontpaw · 02/06/2020 13:10

I do hope its members and potential members are aware. Without members they are nothing.

AwrightDoreenTakeAFuckinDayOff · 02/06/2020 11:49

Frankly I would not be terribly interested in reading what that union have to say now.

To discount so many people/potential members on the say so of the few - without actually really checking facts - is a worry.

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 02/06/2020 11:41

Any update MNHQ?

WhereAreWeNow · 02/06/2020 10:22

@JoMumsnet

Hi *@WhereAreWeNow* - we see you've just mentioned Maternity Action so we thought we'd point you in the direction of this thread which we posted this morning -

MNHQ here: free legal clinic with Maternity Action on maternity and parental rights at work during the Covid-19 crisis

Do feel free to join in if you have any questions. Smile

Brilliant! Thank you! I hadn't seen this.
Gncq · 01/06/2020 20:00

Are the questions to (the spineless) GMB going to be transferred to the new thread?

Grasspigeons · 01/06/2020 19:56

Did GMB get back to you? Do i now need find a new union (can anyone recommend one)

JoMumsnet · 01/06/2020 17:51

Hi @WhereAreWeNow - we see you've just mentioned Maternity Action so we thought we'd point you in the direction of this thread which we posted this morning -

MNHQ here: free legal clinic with Maternity Action on maternity and parental rights at work during the Covid-19 crisis

Do feel free to join in if you have any questions. Smile