Please can you make it easy to remove bookmarks

Extremely annoying on the phone. Adding my voice here!

If you accidentally bookmark a post just bookmark the one you do want to mark and the first bookmark disappears, like moving an actual physical bookmark from one page of a book to another. You can move it forwards and backwards to wherever you want it. If you want to always go to the OP them bookmark that. I automatically bookmark the last post I read in every thread I’m on. How else do you find where you are up to?

@pringle because you may have just bookmarked an earlier post accidentally and it's a pain when you are dipping in and out of long threads

That makes no sense. Read up to end of thread and bookmark ready for more posts or read what you have time for, bookmark, then pick up where you left off.

Me too, chemenger and Dragonglass

I recognise I'm overly invested now! 😂

Nobody has explained why this would be needed.

heron I'm sorry I haven't helped you find the feature. 😌

Thing is, there is no need to be able to undo it. Just keep reading & bookmarking!!

No, Dragonglass I’m with you. Nobody has given any indication of why this is a problem. I don’t understand the terrible consequences of knowing where the last message you read in a thread is.

Bookmarking happens accidentally on the safari browser while I’m scrolling on the phone. I can’t un-bookmark a thread which is really annoying. Have used MN for years but only noticed this in the last month or so.

earrings a thousand thanks for help and patience. Can’t for the life of me access them despite swiping and hovering - fully understand if some are able to do this, and especially if by mistake, you’d want to be able to undo.

Aarrghh! Why won't anyone say why this is a problem? I don't get it and it seems that I'm not the only one.

Me too

Yes please! I’ve never deliberately bookmarked anything... but I’ve accidentally bookmarked a gazillion random posts

@HeronLanyon

Thanks earrings I just can’t see anything in my screen which would allow me to bookmark within mn.
I use bookmarks all the time irl but couldn’t even if I wanted to in mn absolutely no option or icon etc

It's not like using browser bookmarks.

It is like using real bookmarks in a book!

If you are in the app, swipe left on the relevant post & you have an option to bookmark.

If in the browser on a pc, hover over the post to see a bookmark option.

If you are using the site in a browser on your phone, the option appears underneath each post (by accident it's easy to click on).

I find them essential - or you'd endlessly be scrolling through long threads.

The topic here is that people want to be able to undo them - you can in some places but it's a moot point as (as I'm slightly obsessively saying) you can just bookmark the last post you read & no issue about 'removing'

Me too, or should I say me 55!

I keep hitting it by accident as well, it's really annoying!

I hadn't realised before reading this thread that you can no longer turn the bookmark, this must be a recent change as you certainly used to be able to, like literally in the last few days

No worries Glimmer!

Thanks earrings I just can’t see anything in my screen which would allow me to bookmark within mn.
I use bookmarks all the time irl but couldn’t even if I wanted to in mn absolutely no option or icon etc.

Yes please

HeronLanyon

The bookmark function does what it says!

You use it to bookmark the last post you read; when you click back into a post, it'll take you to that post again, so you can continue reading.

People are getting confused - on any device, app or browser, you bookmark where you want, and if you want to 'remove' that bookmark, you simply bookmark somewhere else. It's not complicated

I actually don’t even know what the bookmark icon is and can’t find it. So not aware I ever have book marked anything whilst scrolling. Nor what it would do. Nor why it would be annoying not to be able to undo. However - I agree fully !!

What is it you don’t like about bookmarks? How else do you keep track of where you are in long threads?

I would like this too it’s really annoying

Yep, me too.