Please or to access all these features

Site stuff

Join our Innovation Panel to try new features early and help make Mumsnet better.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

getting together information and support for EVERYONE in the child protection system

287 replies

Spero · 21/01/2014 16:50

I am posting here, mainly because I am not sure what I am doing and I don't want to do anything against the rules or contrary to the site ethos.

In a nutshell, a lot of us have been contributing to various threads since before Christmas about the child protection system in the UK and all the controversy that has arisen since the case of Alessandra Pacchieri and the issue of 'forced adoption'.

We have perspectives from every part of the child protection system - there are birth parents, adoptive parents, social workers, lawyers etc and we think it could be a good idea to try to do something to bring us all together, to help people get access to information that is balanced and useful, particularly if they are facing care proceedings or worried they might be.

At the moment, we are thinking a blog could help, with different people providing short posts about their experiences and providing links to other sources that we know are credible and reliable. This could be very valuable for all of us - I am a lawyer for e.g. but I would love to know more about what doctors working in child protection are looking out for, and I would like to get more perspectives from birth parents about what they think is good or bad about the system.

We are also wondering if there could be a separate topic in 'Parenting' - Dealing with child Protection issues or similar, which could link to the blog, once we get if off the ground.

So sorry quite a lot of info there. Trying to précis

  1. We have a lot of untapped knowledge and experience and would like to pull it altogether to provide a good source of reliable and balanced advice
  2. We would like to start a blog, does anyone want to contribute or can think of snappy name?
  3. We would like to use the power of mumsnet to steer people towards our information and provide another platform for discussion and debate
4.What's the best way of going about this?

Any comments, thoughts welcomed.

OP posts:
Spero · 26/01/2014 20:52

I have also had a very interesting chat with a doctor friend today who tells me he has recently been on a thread in a closed chat forum for doctors which was talking about child protection and what doctors needed to do. He is happy to publish a link to our blog on that thread and see if anyone wants to contribute.

He showed me a brilliant post from a registrar which would be very helpful. So I hope we will get a volunteer from that thread.

Sadly, he told me the prevailing view is that the doctors have serious concerns that SW will deal with any reports they make quickly. They also have doubts about the quality of a lot of SW intervention. which again suggests to me that there are serious issues with SW work loads and availalbity.

OP posts:
Spero · 26/01/2014 20:49

Thanks very much all those offering to help - Lilka can you write anything about your perceptions of the system as adoptive parent.

Re concerns about confidentiality and keeping within the law - as I understand it we are not allowed to publish anything which might identify a child in current care proceedings.

But Mr Justice Munby has explicitly said that he thinks parents who wish to talk about their cases should be allowed to do so and he has recently published new transparency guidelines, judges are now saying they will deliver all their judgments in open court.

I cannot see how we will be 'in trouble' if people want to talk about their experiences of the system, provided they do not identify individual children or make accusations/assertions against others that could lead us open to actions in defamation/libel - I always forget which is the written one and which is the spoken one!

But anyway, as long as no one wants us to publish X LA took my child because they are all paedophiles, we should be fine.

I would be very sad if people are put off talking about their own experiences and their own perceptions through fear of legal action.

OP posts:
Lilka · 26/01/2014 17:09

Wow, Spero it's looking great!

Let me know if I can contribute in any way, I'd be happy to write something

MiscellaneousAssortment · 26/01/2014 15:27

Great will do! Will be a draft by mid week if that's ok? My Ds had an op on Friday so I don't have any time today or tomorrow - but Id love to do something to help disabled parents negotiate the confusion and worries that go along with trying to get help from ss.

I can write something about my experiences, and the knowledge I've picked up on the way. Plus references and links that are useful. Although I'm not a lawyer I did get extensive legal help as part of my journey so I'll include some of that where helpful. I have helped others I've met through forums etc and so will remind myself if what specifically was helpful to them as well as myself.

I know the level of confusion, misinformation and 'fobbing off' which happens unless you are really clear on what should be happening. I am also very familiar with the terror in realizing you are so poorly you need help and yet are scared that turning to ss for help could end up with 'having your child taken away'.

So many people end up refusing help or not even approaching ss for help in the first place. It's so sad and so needless.

The gap I have in my knowledge is working directly with children's services (as opposed to adult social services). It's taken 2.5 years of constant effort to educate adult services in their roles and responsibilities towards disabled parents, so am having a breather before I start on the next battle!

FamiliesShareGerms · 26/01/2014 13:16

I'll have a go at a myth busting section this afternoon. PM if you have any specific issues to include beyond the headline "SS have targets and paid bonuses to snatch blonde babies for middle class families to adopt"

LoopyLobster · 26/01/2014 12:23

I will contact the CLA for their input, no problem.

I would have thought that advice from people who have actually been there (please remember, the parents are not actually the primary victims of this) would be the most useful thing? Perhaps along the lines of 'tips from kids in care'?
I can think of a thousand things that adults could/should have done differently, and I'm sure most other care leavers can too. Eg. to try REALLY hard not to criticise their family, no matter what they have done, to not patronise them - these young people are often far more astute than your average child, to not make them choose between one living situation and another, unless in can be done without the fear of upsetting one person or another, etc.

Links would be very useful, for young people as well as adults. Children Act, etc.
Also info re. accessing files etc.

NoseWiperExtraordinaire · 26/01/2014 10:29

Spero I think this is turning into a very much need and highly valuable resource which will be hugely reassuring to many.

I am a huge fan of inclusive and cross-learning between service users (for want of a better word) and professionals, and have worked professionally in this area, albeit not currently active at present.

My only remaining concern at this stage is how we include the lessons from cases which are protected under court restrictions (and might have been for some years already, with some years left to go). Clearly birth family cannot speak out where this is the case, and is probably where a lot of the fears and concern about conspiracy etc is rooted.

I am not for a minute advocating that we reveal anything that is protected but I do think there is a huge amount of learning to be done from cases like this and support/guidance needed for people who must be feeling incredibly isolated as a result (I know I do!). For me it is the only remaining grey area and potential elephant in the room.

Is there anything we CAN include to de-bunk myth and provide reassurance that learning from such cases does happen? Abeit not in the public eye?

Really sorry to also post this and run (off out for day) but the post about CLA has for some reason minded me to raise this.

Spero · 26/01/2014 09:27

And sorry I meant resource primarily for parents but I am hoping that lawyers, social workers, etc will also be able to gain valuable support and information here.

OP posts:
Spero · 26/01/2014 09:26

And for any birth parents who want to post, if you WERE helped by any agencies, please could you flag that up and say why and what they did that was good.

Equally if you felt you were let down by any particular agency.

One of my favourite sayings is one of Carl Rogers, a psychologist - 'the facts are always friendly. There is nothing dangerous or unsatisfying about being closer to the truth'.

OP posts:
Spero · 26/01/2014 09:20

sorry, re-reading and have missed some things

Devora - yes please, you can help by writing something about being an adoptive parent if you felt able? Any to de-mystify the process would be helpful. As short or as long as you want.

Ditto Miscellaneous - we can do a separate section on parent with disabilities and discuss what kind of resources are out there and how best to push for them etc

Loopy - at least as far as I was concerned I deliberately left children out because I was thinking this is a resource for parents and most of my cases the children are under 7 so I didn't think I could offer them anything ... BUT reading your post and remembering that a lot of my clients were themselves children in care AND this is suppose to be for everyone in the child protection system, I think i was wrong to leave out children.

I would be really grateful if you could liase with the CLA and see what they would find most helpful to post. I know outcomes for children in care are dire, we are not trying to push any agenda but rather de-mystify the process and hopefully help people in the right direction for help and advice, rather the direction of 'leave the country' 'don't co-operate'.

OP posts:
MiscellaneousAssortment · 26/01/2014 01:53

Yes I can write something Spero if you want?

On being a disabled parent and getting help?

inlovewithgarp · 26/01/2014 01:32

I think that it would be immensely helpful to have the input of the children affected - well, those over 18 who can reflect back either positively or negatively Thanks

LoopyLobster · 26/01/2014 01:15

I'm a bit late to the party I know, but I wonder if the 'stories from children' section is missing for a reason?

I went through a variety of care placements including kinship, 'voluntary' agreement with parent (not particularly voluntary as it happens) and care order and various foster families. Obviously this is pretty outdated now, but the Care Leavers Association is an excellent resource and advocacy service for Care Leavers, might be worth getting their input? I am a member if you need anyone to get in touch.

CLA

Sadly, not all of my experience is positive, but insight into how children felt about the different aspects of the procedure might be useful?

inlovewithgarp · 26/01/2014 00:49

Grin re hat. paahaa.

inlovewithgarp · 26/01/2014 00:49

Agreed re DV - with links to the Women's Aid site please?

www.womensaid.org.uk/domestic_violence_topic.asp?section=0001000100220002&sectionTitle=Children

I can't link on app - sorry. I am not very technical Hmm

Spero · 26/01/2014 00:45

Yes, we could do section on disabled parents in parents and carers?

Anyone out there want to tell their story?

just been tweeted this

apparently child stealing is a global conspiracy and instigated by the United Nations.

And a man in Scotland is not allowed to be a father because he wears a hat.

I am not making this up.

OP posts:
BertieBottsJustGotMarried · 26/01/2014 00:18

Whiter yes I think that is important. Perhaps a section on DV/when it's your partner or ex partner who is considered the risk and not you. DV is a massive massive issue and hugely under-understood (that's not a word but I hope you get what I mean). It's even harder for victims of DV to get their heads around it especially when it is their normal and/or there has been some level of DV present in your life since childhood.

WestmorlandSausage · 26/01/2014 00:18

and MiscellaneousAssortment what support people with disabilities can access from adult social care to support them in their role as a disabled parent! That is a learning area for many child services social workers

MiscellaneousAssortment · 26/01/2014 00:08

Something on being a disabled parent would be good too. Alot of myths and assumptions around that, which sw themselves fall into as it's quite rare to be dealing with this situation and the processes and procedures just aren't there for many councils

Eg 1 being physically disabled makes you an incompetent/ bad parent

Eg 2 your child is by definition 'in need' / 'at risk of neglect' if a parent has a physical disability

Eg 3 you can only access help/ funding as a disabled adult via children's services

It's these kind of myths that push disabled parents down a road that can lead to very sad conclusions. No one wants this to happen but there is a knowledge gap. Barnados published a paper on this a few tears ago, and as far as i understand it, it remains unchanged. By educating the parents themselves, it can help everyone involved.

MiscellaneousAssortment · 25/01/2014 23:58

Debunking myths is a really really good idea.

Only read first page so far so am hoping that any 'fly under the radar' stuff has been nipped in the bud.

It should be about facts and truths to help families, and also help them know what to expect and what is professional behaviour and what is not, common concerns and errors etc. Obviously nothing that could be used as 'tips' to help abuses carry on abusing! I do realise that's probably been
Jumped on alot already.

Whitershadeofpale · 25/01/2014 23:48

What do we think of a 'what not to do' section drawing on our experiences. Such as; do not bury your head in the sand, do not reduse access, do not become aggressive, do not relocate etc?

As we all know there are lots of bad advise out there hopefully we can counter that with advise backed up with statistics, court judgements and real life experience.

Spero · 25/01/2014 23:30

We're an org!

Thanks sausage.

All good suggestions, keep em coming.

I'd like us to be ready to 'launch' by end of next week.

OP posts:
NoseWiperExtraordinaire · 25/01/2014 23:13

Me too MrsDeVere!

Info for parents by the Royal College of Psychiatrists:

www.rcpsych.ac.uk/healthadvice/parentsandyouthinfo/parentscarers/domesticviolence.aspx

WestmorlandSausage · 25/01/2014 23:09

yep i've used change a lot so once we had got the main stuff on I was going to start and bulk that side of things up a bit. Great minds!

MrsDeVere · 25/01/2014 23:04

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Swipe left for the next trending thread