Please or to access all these features

Site stuff

Join our Innovation Panel to try new features early and help make Mumsnet better.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Mumsnet forums need updating

188 replies

Mooos · 30/08/2010 04:29

I think it is one of the most old fashioned, user-unfriendly site I've ever seen Shock.

We can't reply to a particular person; we can't particularly see if someone has asked us something and it's just messy.

Anyone else think the same Hmm

OP posts:
TheHeathenOfSuburbia · 31/08/2010 16:39

I have one!

Why can't I squidge MN up to half a screen (if, say, I need to run a Peppa Pig video on the other half Hmm) and have the text wrap around, instead of having to scroll back and forth to read each line?
If it's just my own incompetence, then please someone let me know, FGS!

Oh, and on another forum I use, there is the facility to start a voting thread, with a yes/no choice in the OP and the thread running as normal under it. Would speed up AIBU no end! Wink

ProfessorLaytonIsMyLoveSlave · 31/08/2010 15:30

And there are plenty of other forums for people who don't like the MN look and feel, fortunately. Many of us have gravitated here from them precisely because we find it less cumbersome and distracting and would leave again if it started adding bells and whistles. Others like bells and whistles, and that's fine because there are other places they can get them.

MuckyDucky · 31/08/2010 15:12

Mooos - if you dont like it your choice. we are all free to make choices. You are entirely welcome to chose to go else where if you dont like this. Or you are entirely welcome to stay and live with it. again your choice.

GetOrfMoiLand · 31/08/2010 15:08

OOOOH! (re potential removal of emoticons on sober workplace.

I will never do any work again. Grin and

Mooos · 31/08/2010 15:05

What on earth is a ticker ??

I realise a lot of you think things are happy with things as they are however for just as many of you that are there are (probably) the same amount who find this forum a bit outdated. I was introduced here by a couple of friends years ago who have long since left as they found it too cumbersome. Just saying!

OP posts:
prettybird · 31/08/2010 12:03

True - I hadn't read your post properly, so hadn't registered that you had said it was being considered for Webchats. Blush

JustineMumsnet · 31/08/2010 11:49

Quote facility is only planned on webchats - think they will work much more efficiently with that in place.

prettybird · 31/08/2010 11:47

Actually Justine - if you look more closely at the thread, you'll see that the majority don't want a quote facility!

It gets in the way of the words (you know how we like to talk! Grin) as people abuse it with "quotes" within "quotes" and the message gets lost.

Never crossed my mind that Mumsnet might have put anyone up to this Wink

JustineMumsnet · 31/08/2010 11:33

ProfessorLayton - hmm will ask about how easy/complicated
Getorf - likewise

GetOrfMoiLand · 31/08/2010 11:31

Whilst you are at it, please can you enable the MN Sober Workplace to remove all the emoticons.

Is not good when you are MN at work when you are on a chat thread and there are smileys all over the place. Makes it look obvous that you are skiving.

But LEAVE THE REST ALONE FGS AND DON'T DO TICKERS

ProfessorLaytonIsMyLoveSlave · 31/08/2010 11:24

Actually, the one thing I would really like is a search box to search "all posts by me". Quite often I'm looking for a post I made or a thread I know I was on but I can't remember what name I was using at the time.

JustineMumsnet · 31/08/2010 11:23

Hello all,

No we didn't put someone up to this thread. I'm shocked at the suggestion - do you think we want to make work for ourselves Grin?

Here's what's in our current thoughts for Talk.

  1. Quote facility for webchat threads - so webchatee can answer each question without having to say Dear so-and-so.
  2. Bookmark facility (though that's been on the agenda for some time and is proving tricky - 'tis all to do with pagination I'm told)
  3. Catsbum/sucking lemons emoticon
  4. Highlight OP's post (opt-in on customise)

Also think standard formatting feature sounds useful (eg bold, highlight, italic) and we'll talk to Techs about that if you agree?

You have my word that if anyone at MNHQ tries to introduce Avatars, I'll lock em in the broom cupboard and throw away the key. Grin

ps Said - you are so right about New v Classic Wink.

prettybird · 31/08/2010 11:22

Still don't see where Mooos 40:60 split comes from!

Looking at the thread in Chat, the consumers are unanimous in not wanting change, except, perhaps for some enhanced search facilities.

ProfessorLaytonIsMyLoveSlave · 31/08/2010 02:17
  1. I really don't want to see how many people have read the post

  2. I really don't want to see who is currently reading the post

  3. I would vaguely like to be able to get to my first unread post, but am not hugely fussed about it. It's more useful on a slower-moving forum, TBH.

  4. I like that MN doesn't allow editing

  5. Every forum I'm on that has a quote button winds up with posters quoting great swathes of stuff at each other. I like that on MN if you want to quote something you have to look it up and make a conscious decision what you are going to cut and paste.

I absolutely agree with previous posters who have said that the lack of availability of bells and whistles on Mumsnet makes it about the words. That's one of the things that's refreshing about it.

And assuming for the moment that you are genuinely unaware of what posters are on about, housepricecrash has regular "Hey, let's all go and wind up Mumsnet, it's so funny!" threads.

Aren't we the consumers here? If someone's suddenly given me a shareholding interest in Mumsnet, and/or an income stream from it, I wish they'd told me. Apart from anything else I could have put in valuable time working on my snotty attitude to the rest of you plebs consumers .

ForzaDelDestino · 30/08/2010 23:41

no fgs

OP has asserted 60/40 so I started the thread to see if this is right

I suspect not

prettybird · 30/08/2010 23:40

Don't know about that - I am just making an allusion to MmeBlackberry's comment about her dh working in FMCG and complaining about our attitude to "consumers" Confused

MuckyDucky · 30/08/2010 23:34

Although it would definetly explain the thread from a thread that has been started. Biscuit

i thought the feeling was being made clear enough here. but obviously not HmmBiscuit

MuckyDucky · 30/08/2010 23:32

prettybird were they the ones that got evicted from their own site? I missed their shinagans as their topics were Hmm so i hid them.

not sure why the op cant just use this method to reply to specific posts Confused

prettybird · 30/08/2010 23:27

It is the sort of thing the FMCG guys would do! Wink

MuckyDucky · 30/08/2010 23:26

Well its that or the standard of poster is slipping and that is really not something i would like to even momentarily consider. Wink

Grin
Valpollicella · 30/08/2010 23:21

Muckyducky, are you suggesting this is MNHQ doing some subverted market research...? Hmm

Wink
sunfunandmum · 30/08/2010 23:19

It's not a question of being tacky or not. Little pictures next to the posts (for example) is extra info that I don't want to know. I just want to know what a poster thinks about a topic. I don't want to know anything else about them (i.e. what type of graphics they like). Call me old fashioned but only want an image accompanying text if it helps explain the meaning. Otherwise it clogs things up.

prettybird · 30/08/2010 23:18

Muckyducky - that thought did cross my mind Grin

MuckyDucky · 30/08/2010 23:16

Okay which one of you in HQ put the op up to it?

I hope you arent seriously considering any of this suggested nonsense!

Its simple each forum needs its own style and ways. It is what makes it unique. If all forums looked and functioned in the same way it would 1. be pretty boring and 2. leave a lot of people uncatered for.

MN as it is fills a very important role in the forum world. To change it to make it more like other forums would be signing its death warent. It would be a case for a revival of the m... and tradditionalists to create a breakaway faction. And we all know how Bad that can be. Leave it as it is. Its clear, its concise, and there isnt a hold load of rubbish to wade through when you are trying to get the essential information.

plus where would fast moving threads like the poof of pooh and the adventures of the penguin man be if each post took ages to upload? It just wouldnt work.

leave the forum as it is!

if you dont like it the leave or deal with it.

Valpollicella · 30/08/2010 23:03

MN has to stay as it does, as it offers a 'sober workplace' setting Grin

Enabling MN in the workplace...that's what I love

Bet they don't offer that in Tickersville.

Swipe left for the next trending thread