Can I ask you, if I happen to be of one of the races or ethnicity Jalapenos doesn’t respect, is it still unreasonable if I don’t want her to explain to me how I should respect her ethnicity? I’m fascinated that anyone would think this unreasonable.
You haven’t answered this question. It’s key really to this conversation. I’d be interested to hear your answer. I mean, I know you can’t answer it. If you say no, you’re admitting I’m right to reject Jalapenos offers to lecture me about antisemitism. If you say yes, you’re admitting you think it’s okay for someone who doesn’t respect the race or ethnicity of the person they are speaking to to lecture them on antisemitism, which is clearly a nonsense. Anyway, you might want to have a go.
I think she made it pretty clear: she not talking out respect. She's talking about not inciting violence.
I thought they made it pretty clear they were talking about respect, the way they repeated it several times and made quite explicit that they don’t respect all races and ethnicities. Did you miss that?
But I tell you what: next time a Jewish person is beaten up or attacked by one of your lot, go up to them and tell them how much you "respect" them. Then chant "From the River to the Sea".
See how that goes down.
Who are “my lot”? Who of “my lot” beats people up, Jewish or otherwise? No-one I know. Why would I chant “From the River to The Sea” if saw someone attacked? I’ve never even said it, never mind chanted it. What a strange thing to say.
It is a very, very odd position to try to defend that a person from group A can say that they don’t respect groups B, C and D but then berate a person from unknown group (possibly B, C or D) and express outrage that that person is not respecting group A. Don’t you think?
And just to be clear, as I know you like to twist things, person D in this scenario (ie me) respects groups A, B, C and D.
You do know that the basis of antiracism is that it applies to all races and ethnicities? Otherwise it’s not antiracism.