Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my boyfriend is too soft with his daughter?

214 replies

YourShyLemonGoose · 02/09/2026 15:51

My boyfriend has a 3 year old daughter from a previous relationship who he has about 50% of the time. She’s a lovely little girl but I do feel like she pretty much runs the house when she’s with him, as he seems to have absolutely no backbone with her!
I know it comes from a place of love and he absolutely adores her, but I worry that constantly letting her have what she wants is going to make things harder for everyone as she gets older.
We’ve been together just over a year and I’ve lost count of the number of times he’s given in when she wants something. If she doesn’t want to do something, he generally just lets her get away with it rather than having a battle.
There’s also the potty training thing. Her mum has tried twice, and I don't think she was ready either time, so I’m not blaming him for that. But he hasn’t really carried on with it at his house either, and I do wonder whether things like that are going to become harder if there’s no consistency between the two homes.
I’m very aware that I’m not her mum and don’t want to overstep, which is why I’m asking here rather than trying to parent her myself.
AIBU to think he needs to be more of a parent and less of a friend to her? Or am I expecting too much from a 3 year old?

OP posts:
YourShyLemonGoose · 06/09/2026 17:31

KilkennyCats · 06/09/2026 16:27

The “incentive”, if he needs one, should be that she’s three years old.

Very true!

OP posts:
YourShyLemonGoose · 06/09/2026 17:31

DaisyChain505 · 06/09/2026 16:23

@YourShyLemonGoose

The fact that you keep excusing his behaviour and poor parenting just shows that you know deep down you’re going to continue this relationship and ignore the red flags until one day it’s too late and you’re stuck with him for life because you’ve decided to stupidly have a child with him and then decide to finally admit to yourself what a subpar Dad he is and that you want out.

His parenting views don’t align with yours. Why are you hanging around.

I’m not excusing it at all I’m just trying to see things from his perspective that’s all

OP posts:
YourShyLemonGoose · 06/09/2026 17:33

IdaGlossop · 06/09/2026 16:07

He could do the planet a good deed and think about landfill.

As you work in childcare, you're probably familiar with the (to my mind compelling) argument that the idea of readiness for toilet training has been quietly planted by manufacturers of disposable nappies to keep their profits up. Disposables are the enemy of toilet training because they keep moisture away from the child's bottom. Buckets of soaking terry nappies were an incentive to get a move on.

I could argue that my DD, at 2yrs 4 mths was unready because she kept having accidents. But she was fine to sit on the loo, do what needed to be done, and well able to summon the words to say she needed the loo. The penny (!) dropped that she couldn't be arsed (!) to ask but persist we did, including during a trip to Rome (nappies only at night, spare clothes in rucksack). A nappy is not dignified for a small child and it's the job of parents to help them get rid of it ASAP as pants are so much more comfortable (and cheaper and better for the planet).

Typo

Edited

You make a very good point! I dread to think about all the extra waste it’s creating.

regarding your theory yes I’ve heard that too and it seems feasible. I definitely think years ago kids were trained a lot younger and there were less people struggling to train older kids over 3.

as you’ve said and well know, sometimes a bit of perseverance is needed which I feel like neither of her parents are providing

OP posts:
loveawineloveacrisp · 06/09/2026 17:43

YourShyLemonGoose · 06/09/2026 17:30

A bit late for that but you’re not wrong!

Oh dear, you haven't have you. I hope you've got somewhere to go.

IdaGlossop · 06/09/2026 17:53

YourShyLemonGoose · 06/09/2026 17:33

You make a very good point! I dread to think about all the extra waste it’s creating.

regarding your theory yes I’ve heard that too and it seems feasible. I definitely think years ago kids were trained a lot younger and there were less people struggling to train older kids over 3.

as you’ve said and well know, sometimes a bit of perseverance is needed which I feel like neither of her parents are providing

Perseverance is, I think, one aspect of something bigger: a form of parental self-discipline that acknowledges that the parent needs to lead. My approach to raising my DD was that if you don't let the small things go, you will rarely have to deal with big things. This involves being calm, not shouting, and being firm, but to do those things you have to be clear about what you're prepared to accept.

I was 42 when my DD was born so had had lots of time to observe how friends of my own age did things, and to work out what I thought would work for us. Looking back, I really see how important it was that DH and I were on the same page. I've seen with three of my god-children what happens when parents are not aligned and it's miserable for everyone. Please don't put yourself in that position, OP.

DaisyChain505 · 06/09/2026 19:24

YourShyLemonGoose · 06/09/2026 17:31

I’m not excusing it at all I’m just trying to see things from his perspective that’s all

You don’t need to understand why he parents the way he does, because that’s just the way he chooses to do it.

If you had a shared child together and he was as shit a parent to them as he is your first child it wouldn’t make everything ok just because you understand his perspective. He’d still be a shit parent.

YourShyLemonGoose · 08/09/2026 23:22

Tried to gently hint about the potty training today but he didn’t get it at all. Don’t want to overstep the mark so left it at that.

meanwhile his daughter was throwing a tantrum because her bottle isn’t at the correct temperature (yes she sends them back if they’re too hot/cold)

OP posts:
DarkForces · 08/09/2026 23:28

YourShyLemonGoose · 08/09/2026 23:22

Tried to gently hint about the potty training today but he didn’t get it at all. Don’t want to overstep the mark so left it at that.

meanwhile his daughter was throwing a tantrum because her bottle isn’t at the correct temperature (yes she sends them back if they’re too hot/cold)

Yeah. She's 3. They do stuff like that. He needs to choose his battles but not avoid all of them.

Stuff like adjusting the temperature of milk isn't worth a fight, tooth cleaning is. You don't want your home to be a constant battle of wills where everything is about winning.

YourShyLemonGoose · 08/09/2026 23:32

DarkForces · 08/09/2026 23:28

Yeah. She's 3. They do stuff like that. He needs to choose his battles but not avoid all of them.

Stuff like adjusting the temperature of milk isn't worth a fight, tooth cleaning is. You don't want your home to be a constant battle of wills where everything is about winning.

I suppose so. I guess I just mentioned it because like you said, he’s avoiding all battles at the moment and just gives her whatever she wants

OP posts:
DarkForces · 08/09/2026 23:52

YourShyLemonGoose · 08/09/2026 23:32

I suppose so. I guess I just mentioned it because like you said, he’s avoiding all battles at the moment and just gives her whatever she wants

I think you've got the ick and now everything will irritate you. It's an absolutely fair enough reaction to watching someone parent badly but be careful it doesn't impact you too much if you decide to stay. She's just a little girl who is dealing with massive feelings, 2 homes and a lack of boundaries. She's got far too much say to feel secure but that doesn't mean that everything needs to swing to a battle to be won.

DaisyChain505 · 09/09/2026 16:02

YourShyLemonGoose · 08/09/2026 23:22

Tried to gently hint about the potty training today but he didn’t get it at all. Don’t want to overstep the mark so left it at that.

meanwhile his daughter was throwing a tantrum because her bottle isn’t at the correct temperature (yes she sends them back if they’re too hot/cold)

So not only if she still in nappies she’s still drinking from a bottle?

Switchnow · 09/09/2026 19:16

YourShyLemonGoose · 08/09/2026 23:22

Tried to gently hint about the potty training today but he didn’t get it at all. Don’t want to overstep the mark so left it at that.

meanwhile his daughter was throwing a tantrum because her bottle isn’t at the correct temperature (yes she sends them back if they’re too hot/cold)

I think she’s got things figured out, she knows how to get her own way. You on the other hand seem less keen…

YourShyLemonGoose · 09/09/2026 19:38

DaisyChain505 · 09/09/2026 16:02

So not only if she still in nappies she’s still drinking from a bottle?

I’m afraid so :/
can you see why I have my concerns…

OP posts:
DaisyChain505 · 09/09/2026 21:01

YourShyLemonGoose · 09/09/2026 19:38

I’m afraid so :/
can you see why I have my concerns…

Yet not concerned enough to end this so he doesn’t end up being a useless father to your potential future child too.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page