Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my MIL if she wants a son to name she can go have one and not be engrossed on what I choose to name my son.

483 replies

TwinklyPoster · 20/08/2026 12:35

Hi all, this is more of a rant than anything because I’m honestly just frustrated.
I gave birth to my son at the beginning of August, and my husband and I have chosen his name together.

We’ve named him after my father with his middle name being my grandfather’s name. We’ve also given him a double-barrelled surname/name incorporating both mine and his dad’s names.

My family are absolutely thrilled. My dad in particular is over the moon and feels incredibly honoured that his grandson has been named after him.

I am born in 89, my name was old even then and I’ve grown into it I love it, I always get compliments on it or just people curious about it. DH has somewhat of an old name too. I was never going to name my child whether boy or girl something old fashion. If we had a daughter she would have been name Agatha.

The name itself is quite old-fashioned. Think along the lines of Hugo/Herbert, although it isn’t either of those. Personally I love it and think it’s the sort of name that will grow with him. It might sound very “old man” on a newborn, but I can picture it perfectly on him as a little boy, teenager and adult.

The thing is, my husband and I discussed the names at length and he has always been completely on board. We also deliberately decided not to tell anyone the name or even the sex before the birth. This is our first baby and we wanted to keep it completely to ourselves and just enjoy finding out when he arrived.

DH’s parents, however, are furious about the name. His mother mainly.

Apparently it’s “unfair” that we’ve used family names from my side and that they weren’t consulted.

MIL came round last night to check on us and, inevitably, the subject came up again.
I’ll admit I was probably snappier than I should have been, but after hearing yet again how unfair it all was, I told her: “he is my son I name him not you if you want a child to name to have on yourself” She was obviously offended and the atmosphere went very awkward. My husband did his best to calm things down.

Now I’m wondering whether I was completely out of order in how I said it.
I absolutely stand by the fact that DH and I are the only people who get to decide our son’s name. But perhaps I could have handled MIL’s feelings better, especially as I’m freshly postpartum and emotions are obviously running high.

OP posts:
Eightfor15 · 20/08/2026 15:50

sweetsadine · 20/08/2026 15:44

Just admit you hate your MIL (which may or may not be justified). I think the name saga is a red herring.
Have to say that double barrel names are really chavvy not to mention completely unnecessary if you're married.

I don't believe she does hate the MIL. I believe she's frustrated at the MIL not reverting to type and ignoring her grandchild and getting in the way of a recent PP mother from getting on with learning how to look after her child.

TwinklyPoster · 20/08/2026 15:49

HAPPILYMARRIEDSINCE2012 · 20/08/2026 15:39

You are contradicting yourself there a bit. You say she doesn't like you but wants yo have a close girly relationship with you... I think its just that you don't like her so just admit it and move on.

She wants to because she wants control. I do not give a fuck what she has to say I am an adult why is she not respecting my boundaries all she should be worried about if if baby is healthy which he is. She will never have any say on how DH and I parent. She cried because we told her to either delete the photo of our son off her shitty Facebook or never see him again. He’s our child we make decisions he’s unable to consent to anything yet.

OP posts:
Eightfor15 · 20/08/2026 15:49

TwinklyPoster · 20/08/2026 15:43

Hopefully I have my grandmothers traits. She gets on with my mum because she has never told her what to do. Respected that she’s an adult. I will respect that my son will know what how to raise his own son/daughter. Why would I care. If he’s not abusing his children why would I care what they decide to do or how they raise them. I’ll be in my 60s/70s travelling. DHs mum is in her mid 70s and obsessed it’s weird. She has more money than sense If I was her I’d enjoy life to the fullest nor be miserable because your adult. children want to have boundaries. She started crying when DH and I told her to delete the photo with our son off her social media. What kind of 76 year old woman cries over that get a grip! It’s manipulation.

What a pathetic old cunt.

menopausequeen · 20/08/2026 15:46

I think choosing two names from your side of the family and none from DH is a bit insensitive to be fair. MIL shouldn’t keep talking about it but it would have been more thoughtful of you to consider a name from DH side as a second name or just a neutral name. This smacks of your family being more important than DHs and something I see quite often.
You’re not unreasonable to choose names you like but I understand why she feels hurt.

Blueberrybonanza · 20/08/2026 15:44

Totally should be you and your husband to choose names and it is nothing to do with anyone else.
I am a mil, I would never say I disliked a name either, not my business.
As for the daily visiting, tell your husband to tell her you need some days alone, this is not rude to say.
Its great your husband has 3 months off, you should be enjoying visitors on your terms. It’s your first baby, make the most of it.

sweetsadine · 20/08/2026 15:44

Just admit you hate your MIL (which may or may not be justified). I think the name saga is a red herring.
Have to say that double barrel names are really chavvy not to mention completely unnecessary if you're married.

Catza · 20/08/2026 15:43

Lexingtonavenueandme · 20/08/2026 15:18

Sometimes I feel like mothers of boys are l supposed to fuck off into a cave and just send money.. it’s almost like they literally are suppose to give no fucks whatsoever about not mattering at all in anything whilst mothers of daughters have great great grandads honoured and … sorry .. I mean I don’t care about this stuff.. but how can you not see how shit it is

Not really. My aunt just had her first grandson recently. She has a great relationship with her daughter in law and sees her grandchild regularly. She actually, arguably, has a closer relationship with parents than they do with the wife's mother precisely because she doesn't feel the need to nitpick their every decision...repeatedly.
Mothers of boys are welcome to have an opinion. Doesn't mean that they should go on expressing it until everyone drops everything to accommodate them. Same goes for mothers of girls. An appropriate advice for most people, really.

TwinklyPoster · 20/08/2026 15:43

LoveItaly · 20/08/2026 15:34

Wait until he’s all grown up and his partner thinks she’s got the MIL from hell, it’ll come sooner than you think.

Hopefully I have my grandmothers traits. She gets on with my mum because she has never told her what to do. Respected that she’s an adult. I will respect that my son will know what how to raise his own son/daughter. Why would I care. If he’s not abusing his children why would I care what they decide to do or how they raise them. I’ll be in my 60s/70s travelling. DHs mum is in her mid 70s and obsessed it’s weird. She has more money than sense If I was her I’d enjoy life to the fullest nor be miserable because your adult. children want to have boundaries. She started crying when DH and I told her to delete the photo with our son off her social media. What kind of 76 year old woman cries over that get a grip! It’s manipulation.

OP posts:
HollyhocksandPeons · 20/08/2026 15:42

People are so precious and weird, as fucks, with their children's names. I remember asking my dm why this name was chosen for me, like who was I named after. She said 'no idea, could not care less, I was so grateful to God you came out alive, I came out alive out of this, I did not care'. She does not even remember who went to the registry office to get the certificate, she was so ill for a while, my dad, my grandparents or some other relative, so that person must have come up with the name for me.

Maray1967 · 20/08/2026 15:39

TwinklyPoster · 20/08/2026 13:20

If she hates his name then don’t call to the house. Yet here she is every day. He hasn’t changed she was here yesterday now she wants to come later on this afternoon. She had other grandchildren she could go see.

You can say no, OP.

My PIL saw DS1 when. he was two days old and not again until he was five weeks old. Ok, we live eighty miles apart, but if we lived one mile apart I would not have had them round daily.

Lemonymint · 20/08/2026 15:39

One of my children has three Christian names - all of them are from my side of the family. Nobody cared about it. We both liked the names better.

HAPPILYMARRIEDSINCE2012 · 20/08/2026 15:39

TwinklyPoster · 20/08/2026 13:47

He told her many times but she kept on and on she wouldn’t listen to respect our choice.

We have never really got on. DHs dad and I get on but mum doesn’t seem to like me and I’ve never really bothered I don’t really need her I have my own mother and father she always wanted a “girl to girl relationship” but we just had nothing in common. Same thing with all her children’s partners. She’s desperate for me to interact with her but I just don’t want to. I will respect but I don’t have anything to talk to her about and now we have a son she thinks we will be best friends no!

You are contradicting yourself there a bit. You say she doesn't like you but wants yo have a close girly relationship with you... I think its just that you don't like her so just admit it and move on.

YankSplaining · 20/08/2026 15:39

The better tactic would have been to calmly say that this is the name you and your husband picked out together. Your MIL is blaming you for the baby not having a name from their side of the family, but that was a mutual decision, and that needs to be pointed out.

Telling a presumably post-menopausal woman that if she wants to have a baby, she can have one herself, was nasty. Saying that she had a chance to name her children, and this is your chance to name yours, would have gotten that point across without sounding like you were taunting her for being an older woman.

My husband and I didn’t give our children the names of any relatives so we wouldn’t have this kind of situation, but my MIL was still unhappy. We had girls, but our prospective boy name was – let’s say it was “Jonathan George.” She wanted to know if “Jonathan” was in honor of the priest who baptized my husband, which neither of us had thought of, and that disappointed her. My dad, and my husband’s late uncle/godfather, are both named “Henry,” and she wanted to know why we weren’t considering “Jonathan Henry.”

thistimelastweek · 20/08/2026 15:35

LoveItaly · 20/08/2026 15:29

I wonder why you started this thread, really. You don’t like her, she’s a pain in the backside who the rest of the family seem to dislike, too. Why are you pretending to worry about whether you’ve offended her or not? Don’t you have better things to do with a newborn needing your attention?

I don't think the OP is pretending to worry.
I get the feeling she quite enjoys being unpleasant to her MIL.

SemperIdem · 20/08/2026 15:34

Contaminate is such a strange choice of word.

I can understand you feeling a bit claustrophobic, I wouldn’t want my MIL visiting every single day either.

But “contaminating the baby” is a really weird thought process.

LoveItaly · 20/08/2026 15:34

TwinklyPoster · 20/08/2026 15:30

Clearly not based on your analysis. Baby isn’t even 3 weeks old he’s very chill and he’s happy.

Edited

Wait until he’s all grown up and his partner thinks she’s got the MIL from hell, it’ll come sooner than you think.

Harrysmummy246 · 20/08/2026 15:33

Honestly, yes, she's in the wrong here but your attitude absolutely stinks

TwinklyPoster · 20/08/2026 15:30

LoveItaly · 20/08/2026 15:29

I wonder why you started this thread, really. You don’t like her, she’s a pain in the backside who the rest of the family seem to dislike, too. Why are you pretending to worry about whether you’ve offended her or not? Don’t you have better things to do with a newborn needing your attention?

Clearly not based on your analysis. Baby isn’t even 3 weeks old he’s very chill and he’s happy.

OP posts:
HAPPILYMARRIEDSINCE2012 · 20/08/2026 15:30

sealhappy8419 · 20/08/2026 12:49

Whatever her private feelings your MIL should have kept her mouth shut. It’s nothing to do with her. However, it was slightly thoughtless that if you were deliberately going to give your baby your father’s name, to also honour the grandfather on your side too. It’s a bit tone deaf.

Edited

This

MargaretMeldrew · 20/08/2026 15:29

It sounds like you were both rude. But you have more of an excuse due to being a new mum. I was similarly rude to my MIL when she kept pressurising us to have our baby baptised. I eventually just snapped back, after a pretty constant barrage. I do understand a little bit why she’s miffed. She’s feeling emotional - and territorial - about her new grandson and probably thinks you should have been more even handed in choosing the forenames (not saying I agree - my youngest is named after my late dad!) But she should have kept her trap shut. People can feel anything they like, with or without good cause, but saying it out loud and, worse still, harassing you about it, is absolutely not acceptable. The phrase ‘keep your counsel’ springs to mind.

LoveItaly · 20/08/2026 15:29

I wonder why you started this thread, really. You don’t like her, she’s a pain in the backside who the rest of the family seem to dislike, too. Why are you pretending to worry about whether you’ve offended her or not? Don’t you have better things to do with a newborn needing your attention?

TwinklyPoster · 20/08/2026 15:26

Lexingtonavenueandme · 20/08/2026 15:23

Contaminate? Sorry what?

The obsession isn’t normal. She has a grandson that was born this year she has seen him about 10 times. Yet my son born start of August she has seen almost everyday. She lives closer to the other grandson.

OP posts:
Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 20/08/2026 15:26

There was never even a slight chance that our son would be named after anyone in my husband's family. He and I both agree that they had abysmal taste in names for the most part. We would have been choosing from Horace, Ronald, Dennis, Anthony, Sidney and Albert (the only one I would even have considered). As it was, both my PIL had died before we had children, he's an only child and not close to anyone else in the family, so that was that. It could be argued that both our children have names from my side of the family but as we chose classic names in both cases so do hundreds of thousands of others in the UK.

loopyloolou · 20/08/2026 15:25

So your child has your father and grandfathers name, what about your husbands side of the family? She probably shouldn’t have said anything, but it’s sad you haven’t honoured both sides of the family

Holeymoley28 · 20/08/2026 15:24

Also why is mil mad and not fil?

It’s a son not a daughter so it was never going to have a name from mil or her mother.

She’s what offended on her husband behalf? Or her dad’s behalf.

It would make a bit more sense if op had a girl and named her ops mum, ops granny, ops surname, husband’s surname.

Then yeah I get her nose being a bit put out but still she should keep it to her self or at most maybe one sob to her son I guess. But the child’s a boy given boy names.

Swipe left for the next trending thread