Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect my sister to help cover Mum's care?

266 replies

Neleh64 · 16/08/2026 16:42

So my mum is 84, she has multiple health issues including arthritis, epilepsy and she has issues with her memory at times (we’ve been to the memory clinic and there was no diagnosis).
My daughter is her carer, alongside raising her own children. She makes sure my mum takes all her medication, cleans her home, prepares all her meals, takes her to all appointments, collects her prescription etc.
I currently work 30 hours a week, on the two week days I don’t work, I help out by doing the afternoon visit, this lets my daughter take her children to toddler groups etc.
I also co-ordinate some of my annual leave to cover when my daughter goes on holiday and my son helps out too.
I haven’t been on holiday in 3 years now, I desperately want to go away in the easter school holidays with my children and their children. However my mum is extremely resistant to external carers.
I have asked my sister who lives 20 minutes away, no longer works, has a car etc. If she would be willing to help cover for a week in April, my daughter has asked her cousin too.
Cousin has said she can do the Monday to Friday leg, if we can make sure there are no appointments scheduled, food is stocked etc. She has asked if we can provide a travel cot as she will be brining her own children and just staying overnight for 4 nights, absolutely fine we can do this, we have even offered to make sure there is food stocked for her and the children too (well my daughter has).
However we still need the Friday to Monday covered, I’ve asked my sister and she has outright said no chance. She said she is too busy. I told her she doesn’t have to stay overnight, and a neighbour has offered to check in and make sure the night time tablets have been taken (my mum hates taking them so asking her on the phone isn’t enough you have to go over and stand with her while she takes them or she throws them in the bin!), so it would just be morning and afternoon.

AIBU to think this is ridiculous? It’s months in advance and she hasn’t said anything about a holiday or wedding so I have no idea how she already knows she’s too busy that weekend? Obviously we can just go away for 5 days instead of 7, but I was looking at the Canary Islands and that flight with 5 children doesn’t seem worth it for just 5 days.

OP posts:
stichguru · 17/08/2026 12:32

It's fine that you have chosen to care for your mum, but it's not fine to make it so your choice to do it means that other people have to do it against their will. Use respite care for a few days.

I8toys · 17/08/2026 12:26

We made it clear to the in laws what we were prepared to do and they would buy in care and then moving into a care home. It should not be expected that your children will care for you when you are older. Its a choice you and your daughter have made. Your sister has not. She should not be made to feel bad about that.

hahabahbag · 17/08/2026 12:26

You need to start to look at paid care, if it’s being privately funded look at the option of direct hire locally so your mum can get to know the person/people covering for you. As only short visits with minimal personal care it should be relatively easy to find someone who perhaps has retired but could do with earning a little bit, if you were my neighbour I’d happily do it in fact.

ifonly4 · 17/08/2026 12:23

I know your Mum has health issues, but she has to accept she can't be cared for 365 days a year by her family. It's fine if you and your daughter are willing to do it, but it's not right for everyone. You and your DD need a break, DM will have to accept people coming in or go into a care home.

Monty36 · 17/08/2026 12:20

countrygirl99 · 17/08/2026 12:01

And there's a big difference between that and running yourself ragged for someone too selfish to accept outside help. Given the financial details the OP updated with it would be LA funded as well so not even out of financial con concerns.

I don’t always think it is selfishness when people get older. But fear.
Strangers in your home. Strangers going anywhere they please. Strangers cleaning you.
They won’t feel in control of their home or their body. Which is incredibly frightening. So they resist.
How many of us on Mumsnet would welcome strangers coming in, walking around the house, cleaning us.
Many will have watched programmes or seen the tales of abuse which occur. The purse opened, the money stolen. The jewellery gone.
It is fear. Not selfishness.

Cyclebabble · 17/08/2026 12:17

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 17/08/2026 11:38

How do you get this to happen though when the elderly parent won’t engage or accept the assessment from SS?

You need to be quite firm and you need to fully involve the person your dealing with if you are a carer you do need to learn quickly that you cannot do everything and that you need support. So you do need to say no.

countrygirl99 · 17/08/2026 12:03

BeRoseSloth · 17/08/2026 11:46

Is your daughter claiming Carer’s Allowance? Is your mum getting Attendance Allowance? Could your mum be persuaded to have a week’s respite care in a care home? If you told her it’s either that or carers coming in?

Daughter not eligible for Carers allowance due to insufficient hours but attendance allowance should be claimed. It's to pay for help.

countrygirl99 · 17/08/2026 12:01

Monty36 · 17/08/2026 10:45

I so agree with you.
You do not have to do the caring yourself. But you do have to ensure they are cared for. That is a moral obligation. 100%.

And there's a big difference between that and running yourself ragged for someone too selfish to accept outside help. Given the financial details the OP updated with it would be LA funded as well so not even out of financial con concerns.

moose62 · 17/08/2026 11:58

It is not ludicrous that they are caring for a relative. It is their choice to do so.
What does you sister bring to the party. Does she visit or ever care for your mum?
If not, is there any reason or just because she doesn't want to?

NattyKnitter116 · 17/08/2026 11:57

This all sounds very familiar. I’m the ‘selfish’ sister in this equation. I won’t go in to why as I’ve previously posted about it.
While I understand your motives, you could be creating problems down the line if you don’t get your mother used to occasional outside care now.

While it’s lovely that your daughter is currently willing to help her grandmother, You cannot predict the future and have no way of knowing how long you’ll be able to care for your mum once you retire. Your daughter may end up with a busy job and unable to help as much. Same with your son. Life can be like that.
Hopefully you’ll all continue being able, willing and happy to provide this lucky lady with the sort of care she’s had up to now, but do her and yourselves a favour and get her used to occasional outside help as it will be far less traumatic for her than it happening in a situation where no one has any choice.

I post this from an assumption that everyone is happy with their roles and not just blindly playing their family roles. If it is the latter, then this has the potential to fall apart quite quickly.
It would be really interesting to know how you get on with sis generally and how your daughter relates to her. Also be intriguing to know what everyone’s relationship with your father was like.
Probably best that just book a midweek CenterParcs. Quieter midweek anyway.

MaggieBsBoat · 17/08/2026 11:49

Frankly it is ludicrous that you are both doing all of this. You also have lives. Why should your DD be doing all this? It’s nuts. Your DSis is entirely within her rights to draw a line and I think you also should.

BeRoseSloth · 17/08/2026 11:46

Neleh64 · 16/08/2026 17:14

My daughter volunteered, it works well for her, she gets more time with her children than she would if she had been back at work already, is always able to do school drop off and pick up, nativity plays etc. The children brighten up my mums day.

Is your daughter claiming Carer’s Allowance? Is your mum getting Attendance Allowance? Could your mum be persuaded to have a week’s respite care in a care home? If you told her it’s either that or carers coming in?

DisforDarkChocolate · 17/08/2026 11:42

I can't believe you are all asking so much of your daughter. It may be what your Mother wants but it's not fair and not sustainable. Your daughter has children who are missing out.

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 17/08/2026 11:38

Cyclebabble · 17/08/2026 10:41

Mumsnet seems to believe that children have absolutely no obligations for seeing that their parents are properly cared for. I am a carer and I disagree. There may be circumstances where the relationship was abusive or neglectful, but generally in my view there is a moral duty for children to ensure their parents are okay and looked after. This does not mean you do the caring yourself necessarily and you do need to be careful of burnout. I would start with a Social Services Care Needs Assessment which all of the family should be involved in. If your mum wants to live at home, then it should be possible to cover some or all of the visit needs by using carers. If you need to do this privately I can recommend the UKCIL website recommend by my LA which allows you to place an advert for care staff. Similarly Social Services should be able to help with respite care, though again there will be charges for this.

The collective mind of Mumsnet also seems to think that Grandparents should be on call for childcare needs and should be funding the lifestyle of their children, but support for parents? Nah. Something does not quite add up here.

How do you get this to happen though when the elderly parent won’t engage or accept the assessment from SS?

Rachelshair · 17/08/2026 11:35

Neleh64 · 17/08/2026 11:02

Like I said, DD is free to go on holiday any time, her brother and I step in. In the evening it’s a 3 minute walk from DD to my mums, she does it while she walks the dog and and she’s in for all of 5 minutes making sure mum takes her pills. Mum doesn’t need someone to stand over her she just won’t take them unless someone is there, she doesn’t put up a fight if someone is there.

I feel like people are making up a version of this, that simply isn’t reality based on limited information and I have no idea why?

It just sounds like a lot, if any visits are missed your mum won't eat or take her meds. That really is a big responsibility. You're just used to it. We are not!
And your daughter has a dog to look after too. It sounds like a lot.

Nousernameideaaga · 17/08/2026 11:16

What sort of childhood did your sister have?
Were you treated equally or were you favoured?
Did your sister have exactly the same experience of being parented by your mother that you had?

tinyspiny · 17/08/2026 11:14

YABU your daughter and yourself have chosen to become carers and you cannot obligate someone else to do the same even if it’s only for a week . You have options , which is outside carers but you are bowing down to your mothers resistance to this . I don’t blame your sister as she probably realises that by doing it once she will have set a precedent and it will become the norm for her to step in .

Purposefulactivity · 17/08/2026 11:12

Neleh64 · 17/08/2026 11:08

I can go on holiday at a different time from at least one of my children. I haven’t as that hasn’t been possible.
Thanks to my nieces help we will definitely get 5 days away, and I could in the future just go on holiday myself or with one child each year rather than both.

I feel like I’m losing my mind and people keep making up things or exaggerating things.

You haven’t been on holiday for three years, you say.

I don’t doubt you’re losing your mind, you’re under a lot of unrelenting pressure.

But it’s not a good idea to displace all your annoyance and disappointment onto your sister. She’s not the problem. Your mum’s refusal to accept carers is.

Please just watch you don’t burn out.

LemonSnail · 17/08/2026 11:10

Neleh64 · 17/08/2026 11:08

I can go on holiday at a different time from at least one of my children. I haven’t as that hasn’t been possible.
Thanks to my nieces help we will definitely get 5 days away, and I could in the future just go on holiday myself or with one child each year rather than both.

I feel like I’m losing my mind and people keep making up things or exaggerating things.

Then why did you start a post saying your family needs more help and your DSis should do it if you’ve got everything sorted?

Neleh64 · 17/08/2026 11:08

Purposefulactivity · 17/08/2026 11:05

But you’re not free to go on holiday, are you? And you are desperate to.

So it’s not a great arrangement.

I can go on holiday at a different time from at least one of my children. I haven’t as that hasn’t been possible.
Thanks to my nieces help we will definitely get 5 days away, and I could in the future just go on holiday myself or with one child each year rather than both.

I feel like I’m losing my mind and people keep making up things or exaggerating things.

OP posts:
Purposefulactivity · 17/08/2026 11:05

Neleh64 · 17/08/2026 11:02

Like I said, DD is free to go on holiday any time, her brother and I step in. In the evening it’s a 3 minute walk from DD to my mums, she does it while she walks the dog and and she’s in for all of 5 minutes making sure mum takes her pills. Mum doesn’t need someone to stand over her she just won’t take them unless someone is there, she doesn’t put up a fight if someone is there.

I feel like people are making up a version of this, that simply isn’t reality based on limited information and I have no idea why?

But you’re not free to go on holiday, are you? And you are desperate to.

So it’s not a great arrangement.

Neleh64 · 17/08/2026 11:02

Rachelshair · 17/08/2026 10:49

But she'd get weekends and evenings free at a normal job, plus annual leave. Plus wages! You're minimising this. It's a massive commitment to visit 3 times a day, on top of school runs.
Is she really ok with it, or have you pressured her like you're trying to pressure your sister?

Like I said, DD is free to go on holiday any time, her brother and I step in. In the evening it’s a 3 minute walk from DD to my mums, she does it while she walks the dog and and she’s in for all of 5 minutes making sure mum takes her pills. Mum doesn’t need someone to stand over her she just won’t take them unless someone is there, she doesn’t put up a fight if someone is there.

I feel like people are making up a version of this, that simply isn’t reality based on limited information and I have no idea why?

OP posts:
Neleh64 · 17/08/2026 11:00

FYDistress · 17/08/2026 10:35

I think you should prioritise your daighter getting a break (does she never want to take her kids for a day out, picnic on bikes etc). It would be good for ypir Mum to accept some ouyside help. My MIL regused a cleaner for years but loves her now.

I don’t know where everyone is getting the idea DD never has time to do things.
Shes not long back from a two week holiday.
I work 3 days a week so I’ve been doing other days, tomorrow she’s taking her kids to the zoo and I’ll do the afternoon and evening visits! It’s not some case of her being there all day with no support.

OP posts:
Purposefulactivity · 17/08/2026 11:00

Also, please know that it is entirely inappropriate of you to expect your daughter’s cousin (with young child in tow!) to administer medicines under the circumstances you describe.

Riscotte · 17/08/2026 10:53

Your sister has put a boundary in place. You can only ask and she’s said no. Anyone can put a boundary in place and hers is to not help her sibling, niece and mum out for a weekend. I would go on your holiday and sort carers for that weekend. Perhaps your sister could help organise that? YANBU though and I’m sorry your sister has refused.

Swipe left for the next trending thread